In Ashgrove Bay, Maine, the locals say one thing with the certainty of scripture: nobody drowns here. The tides are so fierce and so regular that the bay always gives its dead back within two days. Fifteen years ago, seventeen-year-old Wren Vance walked onto the pier and never came home. The bay never gave her back, and the town decided to call that grief instead of a warning.
Now insurance fraud investigator Nora Vance, who spends her life proving that people lie, is dragged home when a woman’s body washes ashore wearing Wren’s yellow swim jacket. The corpse has been dead three days. Her lungs are dry. And the town’s gentle sheriff, her ex-boyfriend turned deputy, and her mother, whose memory is slipping, all seem to be guarding the same silence.
Nora has her own secret, the lie she told the night her sister vanished. As she pulls at the threads of a case everyone else buried, she learns that Wren may not be the one who disappeared. Someone in Ashgrove Bay has been waiting fifteen years for Nora to come back and ask the right question.