Chapter 7
THE PAYPHONE
The phone still stood at the head of the pier, bolted to a post under a little tin hood, rusted to the color of dried blood. The cord had been cut years ago. The receiver hung by its stub, swinging in the wind.
I stood in front of it for a long time.
Eli had left me. I’d asked him to. He’d gone back up Harbor Road with his hands shoved deep in his pockets and the paper bag still on the loading dock, and I had come down to the water alone with a mouth full of ash and my sister’s postcards in my coat.
It was nearly seven. The fog had thinned into a pearly sheen, the bay beneath it flat as hammered tin. A man in orange bibs was hosing down a deck three slips away and pretending not to see me. In this town everybody had always been pretending not to see something.
I lifted the receiver. It weighed what a thing weighs when you’ve held it before.
And the quarter was in my hand.
Not now. Then. I couldn’t have told you how it happened, only that the cold of the plastic against my ear opened a door I had leaned my full weight against for fifteen years, and it swung inward, and I fell through.
It was dark and I was crying. The kind of crying that makes your chest hurt, hiccuping, furious. We had fought. I couldn’t remember about what, something small and enormous, as these things are. Wren had said I treated her like a claim to be investigated, and I had said she trusted anyone with a pulse, and she had said at least someone did, and I had walked away down the pier with my hands in my jacket and my heart going like a hammer.
She was at the far end, sitting with her bare feet over the edge. In the water, beneath her, I could see the little pale shapes of her toes.
She was going somewhere. I could feel it. All spring she’d been going somewhere, with her eyes on a point behind my shoulder, drawing tide charts up and down her arms like a girl memorizing a route out. She’d come home from Dale’s boathouse in September white as milk and wouldn’t say why. I’d found her at three in the morning sitting on the closet floor with a flashlight, whispering the numbers.
I was nineteen. I was terrified. I did not know how to say I love you, so I said something else.
I put the quarter in the slot. I dialed the one number every child in Ashgrove Bay learns before their own phone number.
“Sheriff’s office.”
“It’s Nora Vance.” I remembered how my voice shook. “My sister’s going to do something stupid. She’s at the end of the pier. Please. Come get her.”
“Stay right there, Nora.” Dale’s voice. Warm gravel. “Stay right where you are, and don’t look back.”
And I stayed. God help me, I stood at the post with the receiver against my chest, and I did not look back.
But I looked. That’s the thing I’d had cut out. Not at first. When I heard the truck, and the tires on the planks, I turned, because who can obey an instruction like that. A man was walking toward the end of the pier. Big, slow, a silver glint under his hat. Another figure rose from the shadow of the Tidehouse with a lantern. And at the end of the pier, my sister turned her head. She had heard them. She looked down the long boards, past the sheriff, past the lantern, straight at me, at the pay phone, at the girl with the receiver.
She did not look afraid. She raised one hand, palm out, the way you do to a child who’s about to run into a road. Then she mouthed something.
I thought, in the hard light of fifteen years, that it was a word of blame. All this time, I’d believed it was a curse. I’d built my entire adult life on that belief.
It was two words, and I could see them, plain as print.
Go home.
I let go of the receiver. It knocked against the post, and I was a woman of thirty-four standing on a pier at seven in the morning with her face wet and the sun coming up on the wrong side of the world.
She hadn’t been taken. She’d been protecting me. She’d let them put her in the boat, and she had told me, with her last open expression on this shore, to go home. And I had. And then the next morning, a big gentle man had sat me at his kitchen table with a cup of cocoa and said, Nora, honey, tell me what happened, and I’d said, and what I said had been shaped for me, patiently, one soft question at a time, until the pier in my memory was empty and the girl on it had gone swimming alone.
I put my hand flat against the cold post and held on until it stopped spinning.
When I could see again I noticed the shelf under the phone. A narrow tin ledge for a phone book. A phone book that hadn’t lived there in a decade. Something pale was taped to its underside, and my fingers found it before my brain asked permission. An envelope, soft with damp. Inside was a single key, brass, with a paper tag tied through the bow in a handwriting I knew.
Q.
The old cannery stood at the south end of the harbor behind a chain-link fence somebody had stopped fixing, a long brick tomb with its windows boarded and its loading doors rusted into their tracks. At the back, over the water, a boathouse hung on stilts. Its door was padlocked. The key opened it on the second try.
Inside it smelled of tar and tea. A single bulb burned on a cord. The floor had been cut away for a slip, and in the black water, riding on its lines, sat a battered green dinghy with a squeaking left oarlock.
In the bow, wrapped in three blue tarps and an oilskin coat, lay Tobias Quill.
I thought, for one sick second, that he was dead. Then the white beard moved and a pair of watery eyes found me.
“Miss Vance,” he whispered. “You’re early. I’d have said by noon.”
“Mr. Quill.” I dropped to my knees on the planks. He was grey. His lips had gone the color of slate and his hands were shaking so hard the tarps rattled. “How long have you been out here? I’m calling an ambulance.”
“No.” The hand that shot out was surprisingly strong. “Not Dale’s ambulance. Dale’s driver. Dale’s hospital. Not anyone’s, Nora, not yet. Wren brought me in last night. She said it was the safest cold room in Maine.” A faint cracked sound that could have been a laugh. “I told her I’ve been a cold room for fifteen years.”
I took off my coat and tucked it around him. I found a thermos in the dinghy, ancient and dented, tea in it still faintly warm, and I held it to his mouth. He drank like a child.
“You cut the page,” I said.
“I did not cut the page.” The pale eyes sharpened, and for a moment they were the eyes of the man who had logged the sea for forty-one years. “I removed it. There’s a difference, and I’ve spent fifteen years living in it. Dale said, Tobias, you’ll write that night as quiet as the rest. I couldn’t. So I took the page and I sewed it into my coat and I let him think I’d burned it.”
He pushed a shaking hand into the oilskin, and I heard a seam give. A folded square of paper came out, thin and brown, and I took it.
Quill’s perfect pencil. The nineteenth of October, 2011.
High water 2:03 PM. Wind SW 8. Fog after dark.
11:14 PM. Telephone at pier head. N.V.
11:31 PM. D.P. at pier head. W.V. sitting. She does not resist.
11:40 PM. W.V. aboard my tender. E.M. at the oars. She will not look at him.
11:52 PM. Slack. Away.
Below that, a gap, and then a different ink, smaller, pressed hard enough to dent the paper.
She did not go because of the man Dale told E.M. about. There was no such man. She went because of what she saw in the Pruitt boathouse in September. She told me. She asked me to keep it. I have kept it for fifteen years and I am ashamed. Written by T.Q. so someone will know.
I read it three times. The words were doing a slow terrible dance. The Pruitt boathouse. September. Wren in the closet at three in the morning, whispering numbers.
“What did she see?”
“I don’t know.” His whole body began to tremble. “That’s the shame of it, Nora. She wouldn’t say. She said if she told me, I’d have to do something, and I was never a man who did things. I only wrote them down.” His fingers closed on my wrist. “But I know this. Marnie came to me Monday. Wren’s friend. She had found something in Dale’s boathouse that Wren never got out. She went back to get it Tuesday night after she left the shop.” His breathing had begun to scrape. “She never came to the Tidehouse. I waited. Then dawn, and the tide, and there she was in the yellow jacket.”
“She was dead before she went in.”
“Dead and set on the water. The bay doesn’t wait three days when it’s given a body.” He closed his eyes. “Somebody kept her somewhere cold. And let her go when they were ready for you to find her.”
The bulb swung on its cord. My phone buzzed against my hip.
I took it out with fingers that no longer felt like mine. An unknown number. No message, only a photograph, grainy, taken through glass in poor light. My mother, asleep on the plaid couch under the afghan, one hand curled around fifteen postcards.
A second text came while I was staring.
Slack water tomorrow. Bring the ledger.