Chapter 10: THREE TRUTHS0% read • ~8 min

Chapter 10

THREE TRUTHS

8 min read•1,662 words

Dale came down the steps one at a time, favoring the left knee, and sat on the edge of the cot like a man who had carried something heavy a very long way.

“Don’t,” he said, when Eli’s hand moved toward his belt. “You’re not wearing a gun, son, and I’d hate to see you find that out the hard way.”

Eli’s hand stopped. His face did something I’d never seen it do, a collapse, like a tent losing its pole.

“Where’s Ruth?” I said.

“Safe. I’ll get to that.” Dale set his paper cup on the blanket, beside a lock of Marnie’s hair. He looked at the hair for a long moment. “First I owe you three things. You’ll like none of them. I’ve been owing them for fifteen years.”

“I don’t want your confession. I want my mother.”

“You’ll have her. But you won’t keep her unless you listen.” He lifted his eyes. “Sit down, Nora. Please.”

I didn’t sit. I put my back against the cold granite and gripped the phone, and I told him to start.

“Truth one.” He folded his big hands. “The Fund wasn’t mine. It was Carol’s. Carol and your father’s. Tom Vance and my wife started it in ninety-six, with six hundred dollars and a boat. They took women out of bad houses at night. A woman would write herself a letter saying she was going to drown herself, and walk down to the water, and Tom would be waiting with the dinghy. Carol had the papers. She worked a copy machine at the courthouse. Don’t ask me what’s legal. They were saving people.”

“My father,” I said.

“Was the best man I ever knew.” Dale’s mustache trembled. “That’s why he’s on the list. Ruth signed his insurance to the Fund after the Lucy May went down in ninety-nine. It wasn’t a fraud, Nora. It was a funeral. He really died. A winter storm took him, and four men with him, and not one of them came back, bay or no bay.”

Something in my chest I had kept shut for twenty-five years gave way, and nobody in the room knew.

“Except one,” I whispered.

“What?”

“Mom said every name on that list was alive when they left the dock. Except one.” I looked at him. “That’s Dad.”

“That’s your father.” Dale’s voice cracked. “She’s been carrying that sentence for decades, and the disease has taken everything but that. I think it’s the last thing it’ll take.”

“And Carol?”

“The skiff swamped on the Reach. Twenty years ago this December. Carol was ferrying a girl with two children. All three lived.” His eyes went to the wall, to something past the granite. “I took the Fund over after, because it seemed an insult to let it end. For years it was what it said it was. Then Ames found it.”

“How?”

“Through you, in a way.” He shrugged, an enormous slow movement. “He was auditing the Raske-type cases for the firm’s board, looking for a fraud ring. He found a pattern, a dozen small-town payouts that all went to one charity. He didn’t report it. He came here with a briefcase. He said, I can make this pay.”

“And you said yes.”

“I said yes to the first one.” Dale lifted his head. “That’s truth two. I said yes for the money, Nora, because the roof was rotting and the Fund had run dry, and there were three women in the shelter in Rockland who needed beds. I told myself I’d stop at one. I kept telling myself.”

The bulb swung on its cord. Eli stood perfectly still beside the stairs, not looking at either of us.

“Three,” I said.

“Truth three.” Dale rubbed his eyes with the heel of his hand. His voice had thinned. “I made you call.”

“I know. I remember.”

“No. You don’t. You remember the call. You don’t remember who put the quarter in your hand.”

The cold seemed to deepen in the room.

“September of that year, Wren walked into this boathouse.” Dale looked at the hatch above us, the square of grey. “She’d followed me. I’d brought a man down here, a man who’d tracked one of the Fund’s women to the bay. Lyle Prewitt. He had a rifle in his truck and a plan to kill her and her son. He wouldn’t leave. I tried to put him on a boat and make him go. He went for me and I hit him with an oar, and I hit him again.”

“Dale.”

“Wren stood right where you’re standing.” His eyes were wet. “She didn’t scream. She was seventeen and she looked at the man on the floor and she looked at me and she said, is he going to be okay? And I said no.”

I could see it. God help me, I could see it, Wren in her wet boots and her inked arms, taking the weight of it in silence.

“She said she wouldn’t tell. She said it to me, to Tobias, to nobody. She couldn’t sleep for a month. She started drawing tide charts, and I knew what they were. She was working out a way to leave.” Dale pressed his knuckles to his mouth. “I couldn’t let her carry it, and I couldn’t let her tell. So I made a deal. If she went away, truly away, on the water, with a new name and a new life, I’d see that nothing ever touched the people she loved. Not her mother. Not her sister.”

“Me.”

“You, especially. You’d been seen with a notebook following her around that summer.” He laughed once, ashamed. “I called you at the station that night and said, I’ll take care of it. Stay put. Then I came for you with a cup of cocoa the next morning and I asked you the questions I needed you to answer. I told myself I was giving you peace. I was giving you a lie you couldn’t climb out of.”

I had stopped feeling my hands. I looked at the man I’d called Uncle Dale until I was nine and called Sheriff for the next twenty-five, and I tried to find the anger, and what I found instead was a great gray hollow.

“You wrote my name on the list,” I said.

“No.”

“It’s in your handwriting.”

“It is.” He pulled a folded sheet from his jacket and spread it on the cot. LOST. Forty-one names. “These forty-one are mine. Here, in my kitchen, I wrote them over twenty years. I count them every year.” His finger found the last entry, my name, the ink barely dry. “But this one was added this week, by a hand that has been practicing mine.”

I leaned over it. He was right. The letters were a little too even, a little too deliberate. The R in VANCE had a curl my sheriff never made.

“Ames forges documents,” I said slowly. “Claims. Endorsements. It’s how he makes a policy look old. He did it to Raske’s beneficiary form.” I stopped. “He’s the one who put the list in the tin.”

“He had a key to the shop,” Dale said. “From the old days. I let him have one for emergencies, God forgive me.”

“Why my name?”

“Because it’s what he plans to do. Slack water, tonight, twelve forty-one. He’s going to make you a vanishing.” Dale looked at me and for the first time I saw naked fear in him. “You’re the last person who can connect the Fund to him. You closed Raske. You’ll know what you signed. He can’t kill you, an investigator with a clean record, not without an inquiry. But a woman lost at sea, in her hometown, on the anniversary of her sister’s disappearance? Grief and a cliff. Nobody asks a question.”

“Marnie.”

“I found her Tuesday night, here, in the cold room.” His throat worked. “Somebody’s driver had been through. She’d been strangled. I kept her cold until dawn, and I put her in the bay in the yellow jacket and the bracelet, because I knew that if the body had your sister’s things on it, Wren would send for you, and you’d come, and I’d have you in this town where I could hide you.” He stopped. “I was going to put you on a boat tonight. I swear it. A new name. A cottage in Nova Scotia. That’s what the list was supposed to mean.”

“You were going to disappear me.” My voice was a thread. “Like Wren.”

“I was going to save you.”

“That isn’t the same thing.”

“I know it isn’t,” said Dale. “I never knew the difference. That was my whole trouble.”

I heard Eli make a sound, low in his throat, and I turned and saw him staring at the sheriff with the face of a boy being told his father had left without a word.

“And my mother?”

“At my kitchen table. Kettle on. I left her there with the door locked and told her not to answer it for anybody.” He stood, a long creak of knees. “She’s the safest woman in Maine.”

His phone chimed.

It was an old phone, a cheap flip model. He took it out of his pocket and looked at the screen and I watched every drop of color leave his face. He turned it toward me without speaking.

A photograph. A kitchen. A kettle tipped over on its side in a spreading puddle. A chair pushed back. A white-green mug on the floor with its handle broken off. And in the corner of the frame, partly out of focus, a woman’s good wool coat, lying where it had been dropped.

A message came in under it, from a number I knew.

Hello, Dale. Hello, Nora. Twelve forty-one at the Reach. Bring the ledger and the girl’s phone and I’ll give you back Ruth. Come with anyone else, and I’ll give you back what’s left.

Nobody Drowns In Ashgrove Bay — Chapter 10: THREE TRUTHS | BlueNov