Chapter 1: THE JACKET0% read • ~9 min

Chapter 1

THE JACKET

9 min read•2,014 words

The body in the bay was wearing my sister’s jacket, and it had been dead for three days.

I knew the jacket before I knew anything else. Yellow, sun-bleached at the shoulders, the Ashgrove High swim team patch stitched crooked over the left breast because Wren had sewn it on herself, badly, the night before her first meet. I’d teased her about it. She told me crooked was a sign of character.

I stood at the end of the pier with a paper cup of gas station coffee gone cold in my hand and stared at it.

“Nora.”

Eli Marsh had his hands in his jacket pockets, the way he’d stood at seventeen, like his body was trying to take up less room than it owned. The dimple was gone from his cheek. Fifteen years will do that.

“You drove all night,” he said.

“Six hours. It’s not the Oregon Trail.”

He almost smiled. Almost. “Dale doesn’t want you down here.”

“Dale called me.”

“Dale called you before he saw the jacket.”

That sat between us. The wind off the water carried salt and diesel and something under both of them, something sweet and wrong. Below us, on the rocks at the foot of the pier, two deputies in rubber waders had spread a white sheet over a shape I wasn’t ready to look at.

I looked anyway.

A woman’s hand lay outside the sheet, palm up. The nails were chewed to nothing. A thin braided leather bracelet circled the wrist, and from it hung a tiny tin fish, dull, dented.

I had made that bracelet. I’d been eleven. I had pinched the fish out of a bait tin with my father’s snips and it had cut my thumb to the bone, and I’d bled all over the kitchen floor, and Wren had worn it every day since like it was a medal.

My knees did something. I put a hand on the railing.

“Don’t,” Eli said quietly. “Don’t go down there. Please.”

“Is it her?”

He didn’t answer fast enough.

“Eli.”

“I don’t know.” He pulled one hand out of his pocket, rubbed his jaw, shoved it back. “She’s the right size. She’s got the jacket. She’s got the bracelet.”

“But.”

“But she’s been in the water three days, maybe four. Wren’s been gone fifteen years.”

Fifteen years. Nobody had needed to say that out loud in a long time. It had settled into the town like silt.

“Where’s Dale?” I said.

“With the coroner. The van’s coming from Belfast.”

“I want to see her face.”

“There’s not much of a face to see, Nora.”

“I want to see what there is.”

He looked at me then, really looked, and I watched him decide not to argue. It was the old thing, the way he’d given up arguing with me at eighteen, once, in the front seat of his father’s truck, and I’d thought it meant he’d understood me. It had only meant he was tired.

“Ten minutes,” he said. “I’ll walk you down. You touch nothing.”

“I know how to look at a scene.”

“You look at insurance claims.”

“Same thing. Everybody’s lying about something.”

The rocks were slick with kelp and the cold came up through my boots. Close up, the smell was worse. Not rot exactly. The sweetness of a thing kept too long in a warm room. One of the deputies, a kid with a sunburned neck, stepped aside and wouldn’t meet my eyes.

Eli lifted the corner of the sheet.

I won’t describe it. I’ll say that the water takes what it wants from a face, and that she was small, smaller than I’d remembered Wren being, and that her hair was dark and cropped short, and that Wren’s had been sandy red down to her waist.

I let out a breath I hadn’t known I’d been holding.

“That’s not her.”

“Nora.”

“Her hair.” My voice came out strange. “Her hair’s wrong.”

“People cut their hair.”

“People don’t cut off a foot of hair and then put on a fifteen year old jacket.”

Eli let the sheet fall. Neither of us said anything.

Behind us, above, a door banged. The Tidehouse, Tobias Quill’s old harbormaster shack at the head of the pier, its windows fogged from the inside. A shape moved behind the glass and was gone.

“Is that Quill?”

“He found her,” Eli said. “Five this morning. He logs the tide at dawn, same as always. Saw the yellow from the window.”

“Then he’s the first person who touched the body.”

“He says he didn’t.”

“Everybody says that.”

I climbed back up the rocks without taking his hand. The kid with the sunburned neck watched me go, and I felt his eyes on the back of my head until I reached the planks.

The Tidehouse smelled of kerosene and old paper. Tobias Quill sat at a table covered in folded charts, a mug of tea gone skinned and brown beside his elbow. He’d shrunk. The white beard I remembered had gone ragged, and his hands trembled on a pencil he was turning end over end.

“Mr. Quill.”

“Nora Vance.” He didn’t look up. “Your mother’s girl. The older one.”

“The only one, now. Or I thought.”

His pencil stopped.

“You found her at five,” I said.

“At 5:07.” He tapped a ledger, open under his palm, his writing cramped and neat. “High water was 4:41. She came in on the ebb. Twelve minutes after the turn.”

“That’s very precise.”

“It’s the only thing I’m good for.”

I sat across from him without being asked. “You know what everyone in this town says about the bay.”

“Nobody drowns in Ashgrove Bay.”

“Say the rest.”

He closed his eyes. “The bay always gives them back within two tides. Forty-eight hours, more or less. It’s the cove shape, and the current, and the way the shelf drops off at Keeper’s Reach.” He opened them. They were pale, watery, and sharp as pins. “It’s not folklore, Miss Vance. It’s hydrology. I’ve logged this water for forty-one years. I’ve pulled out eleven bodies. Every one inside two tides.”

“Wren’s never came back.”

“No.”

“So she didn’t drown.”

He said nothing for so long that I heard the wind find a gap in the window frame.

“I’ve never written that,” he said at last.

“You’ve never had to.”

“I’ve never had to.”

“Why is this woman three days dead,” I said, “and only coming in now?”

His hands went still. Not a tremor in them.

“That,” said Tobias Quill, “is the question I’ve been sitting here trying not to ask.”

I stood. My coffee had gone over the edge of the cup and onto my wrist, cold, and I hadn’t noticed. “What aren’t you telling me?”

“The tide tables don’t lie, Nora.” His eyes dropped to the ledger. “But somebody can stop writing them.”

Before I could press, boots hit the planks outside, heavy, unhurried. The door swung in on a gust of salt and the shape of Sheriff Dale Pruitt filled it, silver mustache, tan jacket, a paper cup of his own in one big hand.

“Nora,” he said gently. “Come outside. Let’s not do this in front of Tobias.”

“Do what?”

“Whatever you’re about to do.”

I followed him out. Gulls were working the shoreline now, and the coroner’s white van had backed down the pier road with its hazards winking orange. Dale stirred his coffee. He stirred it for a long time. I remembered that. The slow spoon, the careful non-answer.

“Your mama doesn’t know yet,” he said. “I’d like to tell her myself.”

“Dale. Is it Wren?”

“I don’t believe so.”

“Then why did you call me before you’d looked?”

His spoon stopped.

“Because I thought it was,” he said. “For about a minute and a half. And then I thought, no, Dale, you know better.” He looked out at the bay, grey and flat and innocent. “And I thought, she should be here either way.”

“That’s not an answer.”

“It’s all I’ve got this morning.” He finally met my eyes, and what I saw wasn’t evasion. It was something older, a tiredness that went down into the bone. “Go home. Hug your mother. Sleep. We’ll know more after the autopsy.”

“I’ll go to my mother’s.”

“Good.”

“But I’m not going to sleep.”

“No,” he said. “I didn’t think you would.”

Vance Bait and Tackle sat where it had always sat, at the bend of Harbor Road, a low shingled building with a hand-painted sign Dad had made the year before the storm took him. The paint had flaked away from the V. Someone had patched it with a Sharpie.

The bell over the door jangled the same way. Inside, nothing had changed except everything. The tank of live shiners bubbled in the corner. The wall of lures glinted like a lit chandelier. My mother stood behind the counter with her silver braid down her back and her sleeves pushed to the elbow, wiping her hands on her apron.

“You’re late,” Ruth Vance said.

“Hi, Mom.”

“I told you six. It’s after eight.”

I had not told her anything. I had never told her anything about when I’d arrive, because I hadn’t spoken to her in four months. I let it go. In the last year I’d learned that you let it go.

“Dale called,” I said. “Did he come by?”

“Dale’s always coming by.” She wiped her hands again. “Is there something wrong with your coat? You’re standing funny.”

“Mom, they found a woman in the bay.”

She went on wiping.

“She was wearing Wren’s jacket.”

The cloth stopped. Just for a second. Then it started again, slower, the same square of apron, back and forth, back and forth.

“That old thing,” she said. “I told that girl to bring it in. It’s been hanging by the door since July.”

I stared at her.

“Mom. Wren’s jacket has been gone for fifteen years.”

“Has it?” She frowned, genuinely, like I’d corrected her about the weather. Then the fog cleared off her face and she looked at me with one hundred percent of her mind, which was the worst thing, the clearest thing. “Don’t be silly, Nora. Go wash your hands. You smell like the harbor.”

I went to the back room to wash my hands because it was the only thing I could think to do.

The sink was the same cracked porcelain. Over it hung the same corkboard, now crowded with pinned receipts, tide charts, a faded photo of Dad on the Lucy May, grinning with a cigarette in his teeth. Next to it, under the board, was a coat hook. Empty. I stared at that hook as the tap ran over my wrists.

Then I went back out and stood in front of the register.

Ruth kept the receipts in a coffee tin. She’d done it for thirty years, because she didn’t trust computers, and because every night she logged the day’s sales in a green ledger with a ballpoint pen. The tin sat where it always sat, beside the cash drawer. My hand was moving before I’d decided to let it.

“What are you doing?” Ruth said.

“Looking for something.”

“That’s private.”

“I know.”

I tipped the lid. Paper curled out. Bait, ice, tackle. A man named Hollis, Tuesday, twelve dollars. A tourist. A boy buying shiners.

Then, near the bottom, a slip I almost missed. Bait, one dozen. Paid in cash. Signed on the line, in blue ink, in a looping, forward-slanting hand I could have picked out of a thousand, with a little flourish on the W like a wave.

Dated Tuesday.

Three days ago.

I read the name four times. Then I looked up. My mother had gone still behind the counter, her hands folded in her apron, and she wasn’t confused at all.

“Mom,” I said. “Who was here on Tuesday?”

Ruth Vance looked at the door, then at me. And very softly, the way you’d tell a child about a dream, she said, “Don’t let them see you with that.”