Chapter 11: THE INDEX0% read • ~7 min

Chapter 11

THE INDEX

7 min read•1,618 words

A good confession is built like a good fraud. It is mostly true, with one lie holding up the roof.

I stood in the cold room with Dale Pruitt’s flip phone in my hand and Ames’s message glowing on it, and I did what I do with every claim that lands on my desk. I stopped asking whether the story was sad and started asking what it needed me not to look at.

“Sit down,” I said. “Both of you.”

“Nora,” Eli started.

“Sit. Nobody runs. Nobody calls anybody. We have fourteen hours and I’m about to spend ten minutes of them thinking.”

Dale lowered himself back onto the cot. Eli took the stairs, the third one from the bottom, and sat with his elbows on his knees and his hands finally, finally out of his pockets. The bulb swung on its cord. Our three shadows slid across the cork and back again.

Ames wanted the ledger. That was the part that didn’t sit right. He had stolen a forged name onto a list, a key to my mother’s shop, my mother. A man with that much reach doesn’t need a dead harbormaster’s tide book. Unless the book held something he couldn’t buy, forge, or frighten.

I spread Quill’s 2011 ledger on the cot beside Marnie’s hair and went through it page by page, the way you go through a claimant’s receipts. Tides. Wind. The cut stub of the nineteenth. I turned it over and found nothing on the back cover, and then I ran my thumb along the inside of the binding and felt a thickness where the endpaper had been lifted and glued down again, neatly, by a man who did everything neatly.

I slid my toothpick under the paper and peeled.

Pages. Dozens of them, thin as onion skin, folded flat into a pocket the width of the spine. Pencil, in Quill’s tiny perfect hand, ruled into columns. Date. Tide. Boat. Oarsman. Passenger. Dock.

“What is that?” Eli said.

“An index.”

I read it aloud, because somebody should. Twenty-five years of departures, forty-one lines in all, and every line carried the same discipline as his weather entries. The hour, the vessel, the name of whoever held the oars, what the passenger carried and whether they spoke. He’d logged the dock witness every time. He’d had a column for it. In the early years it said C.P., which was Carol, and T.V., which was my father, and D.P. after.

Then, four years back, the dock column changed.

March, two years ago. R. passenger, heavy, overcoat. Oarsman E.M. Dock: a man in a camel coat. Paid E.M. one hundred dollars. I did not log his name. I logged the coat.

And above it, six more like it. A surgeon. A developer. The hedge fund man with the boat. Each of them with a witness on the dock, camel-colored, unnamed, and each one clearer than the last, until the fourth entry, in handwriting gone shaky with outrage, where Quill had broken his own rule and written what he saw. G.A., Hartford. Face seen by lantern. Same hand on the fee each time.

“He was building a case,” Eli said slowly.

“He was building an alibi for his conscience.” I turned the page. “He couldn’t stop it. So he wrote it down in the book where he’d failed.”

“Why that book?”

“Because it’s the night he didn’t log. He put the correction where the mistake was.”

Dale made a noise like a wall settling.

I read the last pencil line twice, because the first time I didn’t believe it. The ink was fresh, a little smudged, written in a hand that shook.

Oct 20. 12:41 AM. N.V. Oarsman D.R. Dock G.A. Written from what M. told me. God forgive a man who records a plan and cannot stop it.

“D.R.,” I said. “Who is D.R.?”

Nobody answered. Eli’s face had gone slowly, terribly gray.

“Say it.”

“Cody Rudd.” He swallowed. “The kid. Deputy. Twenty-three. The one with the sunburn on his neck, he’s always got it, he never wears a collar.” His voice cracked on a laugh that didn’t have anything funny in it. “He’s been in my truck every day since June.”

“Cody Rudd,” Dale said, very quietly, “is Rose Rudd’s boy.”

I looked at the list. I didn’t have to. I found it by memory, ROSE RUDD, 2004, SLACK 4:55 AM, and a check mark.

“She was running from a husband who broke her jaw,” Dale said. “Carol’s year. Not mine, I wasn’t running it yet. We told the boy she drowned. He was eleven. He used to stand on the pier and wait for her, every morning, and I’d bring him doughnuts and tell him the bay was keeping her warm.” He pushed a hand across his mustache. “I put him on the force myself.”

“And Ames got to him.”

“I’d say Ames told him she was alive. That’s what I’d say, if I were the kind of man who wanted a boy to row.” Dale’s eyes closed. “Lord. That’s the lever.”

I put the ledger down. I breathed in the cold, mineral smell of the granite and let myself think in a straight line, which is the one trick I’ve ever had.

“Here’s what we know. Ames can’t kill me without noise. He needs a lost woman, a grieving anniversary, a rowboat on a rising tide, and a deputy who’ll say he saw me walk off the rocks. Cody Rudd is the deputy. He’s the only part of the plan that isn’t paper.” I counted it out on my fingers. “He’s also the only one on that rock tonight who doesn’t want me dead.”

“You can’t trust him,” Eli said.

“I’m not going to trust him. I’m going to read him.” I turned to Dale. “Does your phone take photographs?”

“It does not.”

“Eli.”

He pulled out his own phone. I made him photograph every page of the Index, the cut stub, the tag on page forty, and then I took Marnie’s phone, eleven percent, nine now, and Bluetoothed the video across while we watched the little bar crawl. When it was done I made him go up and stand on the porch of the cottage, in the one spot at the top of the point road where a single bar of signal lived like a rumor, and send all of it to a woman named Priya Nair at the Maine Bureau of Insurance. She’d once owed me a favor large enough that I’d never called it in. I wrote her address on his palm in ballpoint.

“Then drive to Rockland,” I said. “The state police barracks. In person. Hand it to somebody with a badge who has never heard of Dale Pruitt.”

“And leave you?”

“You’ll be back on the oars by midnight. Two hours there, two hours back.”

“Nora.”

“You held the boat five times.” I said it gently, which surprised us both. “Hold it once for me.”

He looked at me for a long moment. Then he did the thing I’d waited fifteen years to see. He didn’t deflect and he didn’t joke. He just nodded, once, like a man picking up something heavy, and went up the stairs.

I turned to Dale. “My firm phone is company-managed. Ames reads it. That’s how he knew I’d been at the Tidehouse.” I laid it on the cot between us. “I’m keeping it with me. Everything I say into it, he hears. Everything I write, he reads. It’s the only weapon I have that he thinks is his.”

“A decoy.”

“A claim form. I’ll file exactly what he wants to see.”

Dale’s mouth moved under the mustache. For the first time all day it looked almost like pride. “Your father used to say that. That the trick to a lie was a good clean receipt.”

“Don’t,” I said.

“I’m sorry.”

“Don’t be sorry. Be useful.” I picked up the ledger. “Marnie came here Monday and found something that Wren never got out. Quill said so. It was in this boathouse. Where do you keep what you don’t want found?”

“I don’t keep anything.”

“You keep your wife’s chime on the porch for twenty years. You keep a tape in the safe. You keep a cold room under a tarp.” I looked around the six-by-ten room. “She hid down here Tuesday night. Why this room? She could have run. She stayed in a hole in the ground with a man at the door. She came back for something.”

I crossed to the cot and knelt. The cork on the back wall was old and gray and crumbling, pinned in sheets. One sheet, at about the height of a girl’s shoulder, had a fresh scrape along its edge, a bright line where the nails had been worked loose and pushed back. I dug my nails into it. It came away in my hand.

Behind it, in a hollow cut into the granite, lay a bundle wrapped in oilcloth and tied with fishing line.

I carried it to the bulb and cut the line with my teeth. Inside was a boat hook, an old brass-tipped pole, the point stained black. A paper tag hung from its neck in a pencil I could have recognized in the dark.

T.Q. Oct 19, 2011. Lyle Prewitt’s blood. Not Dale’s oar. I should have said.

Behind me, the sheriff of Ashgrove Bay made a sound I had never heard a grown man make, and when I turned around he had slid off the cot onto the floor and was kneeling there, big hands open in front of him, staring at the hook like it was a thing risen from the grave.