Chapter 16
SECOND TIDE
By dawn the Reach was empty, and the bay was the color of a wound that has stopped bleeding.
They took Cody Rudd first. A Coast Guard cutter came up the channel at four, white lights, a tinny voice on a loudspeaker, and two medics in orange went over the rail with a stretcher. He was alive. The bullet had gone through the meat of his left shoulder and out, and he had lost a great deal of blood, and he spent the entire transfer asking one question.
“Is she in Duluth?”
I walked beside the stretcher with my hand on the rail. “I don’t know, Cody.”
“You said.”
“I said what I could read in a file.”
“You said a green duffel bag.”
I looked at Wren. She stood a step behind me with a blanket around her shoulders, still dripping, the headlamp lying forgotten around her neck. She had not spoken since the Reach. She was looking at the boy on the stretcher the way you look at something you’ve been carrying so long you forgot it had a face.
“Rose Rudd,” Wren said, “runs the bakery at the Landing in Duluth. Cardamom buns. She wears an apron with a burn on the hem. She’s got a scar on her jaw from a man named Teddy, and she keeps a photograph of an eleven-year-old boy on the shelf behind the register, with a sunburned neck.” Her voice broke on the last word. “She doesn’t know what happened to him. We were told he was being cared for. We were told he was fine.”
Cody turned his head. The medics stopped.
“A green duffel bag,” he whispered.
“Navy surplus,” Wren said. “It’s still in her closet.”
He cried then, flat on his back with the sky going gray overhead. I stood very still. I had made a thing up on a boat, in the dark, with a gun in a boy’s lap, and it had turned out to be true, and I did not know what that said about me or about the town.
I didn’t ask.
The state police came at six.
There were eleven of them, in vests, with a woman at the front who held a folder to her chest like a shield, and when she saw me, she stopped dead on the pier and let out a long breath.
“Priya,” I said.
Priya Nair of the Maine Bureau of Insurance looked as though she had not slept in three days. Her hair was in a rubber band. She wore a raincoat over what looked like pajama bottoms. “You,” she said, “owe me a very good explanation, and a hot meal.”
“I owe you nothing. You owed me a favor.”
“I’m calling it paid.” She pushed the folder into my hands. “Eli Marsh walked into the barracks in Rockland at nine last night, and the desk sergeant tried to log him as a walk-in and send him home. He sat on the floor until somebody called me. I took the first drive I could find.” She glanced past me at the cutter, at the stretchers, at the wet ledger-sized hole in the world where Quill’s book should have been. “Is that Dale Pruitt?”
I turned.
The sheriff of Ashgrove Bay sat on an overturned crate at the head of the pier, his leg bandaged, his coffee spoon in his fist and a paper cup of nothing. He was not stirring it. He was looking at the water. When he saw Priya’s vest, he lifted one hand, big and slow, and held out both wrists.
“I’d like to make a statement,” he said. “It’ll take a while.”
They let him sit. They let him talk. I stood at the edge of the circle and listened to a man with a voice like warm gravel lay out twenty-five years of rowboats and bus tickets and a cold room cut into granite, and every sentence he spoke was a sentence he had been rehearsing for a decade and a half, and every one of them was true. When he reached 2011 he stopped and looked at me.
“The Prewitt boy,” he said. “I’ll tell you what I know, and then I’ll tell you what I did.”
I waited.
“Tobias killed him with a boat hook. I didn’t know until tonight.” His mustache trembled. “That night I came back from being sick in the dark and found two of them standing over a dead man, and I took the blame because it felt like mine. And I called Lorraine Ames.”
Priya’s pen stopped.
“Carol’s old friend from the courthouse,” Dale said. “She’d known about the Fund from the start. She was the one who forged the first papers. When I called her that night, in a state, she came with a truck and a tarp. She said she knew a place in Rockland that kept things cold.” He closed his eyes. “I never went inside. She never let me. I paid the rent in cash every month for fifteen years. Penobscot Cold. Unit seven. She told me she’d cleaned it. I never looked.”
I felt it more than I understood it. Fifteen years of rent on a dead man, and a woman who held the key.
“Why call Lorraine and not the state?”
“Because Wren was seventeen,” Dale said. “And I thought it would all be over by morning.”
Nobody said anything. The gulls started up along the pilings.
The second tide came in at ten past noon.
I had not slept. I sat on the end of the pier, in a borrowed sweatshirt, with a paper cup of coffee that Eli had brought and I had not touched. He sat a careful three feet away with his hands out of his pockets, and neither of us had said anything for twenty minutes, and it was fine. It was the most comfortable silence I had ever shared with another person.
Wren sat on my other side. She had not let go of the edge of the pier since we arrived.
Out in the bay, a small shape rolled in the swell. A gull lifted from it. It came on slowly, the way the water brings things, patient and indifferent, until it grounded on the rocks at the foot of the pier with a soft, wet bump.
Tobias Quill had written that the bay returned its dead inside two tides, and he had never been wrong.
It was Pike. He lay on his back in a dark coat, one huge hand still curled around a scrap of wool, and the deputies in waders went down to him without hurrying. I made myself watch. I made myself count the minutes, because counting is the only form of respect I know.
When they turned him over, one of the deputies reached into the coat’s breast pocket. He drew out a small brass key on a ring, a paper tag tied through the bow, and he held it up to the light.
Penobscot Cold, 7.
I felt Wren’s hand close on mine.
“We go,” she said.
“I’ll come,” said Eli.
“No.” Priya had appeared at my shoulder, her raincoat flapping. “Nobody goes anywhere. The unit is evidence. A team’s on the way from Rockland. You’re all going to give statements, in order, and then you’re going to sleep, and then I’m going to hand you a bill.”
“Priya.”
“Nora.”
“Where’s the launch?”
She hesitated. It was a very small hesitation, and I have built a career on them.
“The Coast Guard found it at nine this morning, east of Matinicus,” she said slowly. “Empty. Engine running. A lantern lit in the cabin, and two coats folded on the seat. A camel coat and a black wool one.” She looked at me. “No bodies. They’ll drag the bay all week. But they’ll be inside two tides, won’t they? That’s what everyone says.”
Nobody answered her. Out on the water the swell lifted a log, a gull, a piece of rope, and set them all down again.
We went home. We sat at my mother’s kitchen table under the yellow light, the four of us, Ruth with her hair freshly braided, Wren with her hands wrapped around a mug, Eli in the doorway, and none of us could say anything, so we ate toast. At some point I fell asleep with my head on my arms. At some point Ruth put the afghan over me and wiped her hands on her apron, once, and it was not a lie. It was only a habit.
I woke at dusk.
The shop was dark below, the shiner tank humming. A light on in the kitchen. Wren stood at the counter with her back to me, holding something at arm’s length, the way you hold a thing you suspect of being alive.
“This was in the mail slot,” she said.
She turned. It was a postcard, cream-colored, a little yellow at the edges, with a lighthouse printed on the front. Postmarked yesterday. Halifax.
She turned it over.
A tide chart in blue ballpoint. A little shaky sine wave, with the hours down the margin and one point circled so hard the pen had nearly gone through. Beneath it, in the quick forward slant I would have picked from a thousand, a W like a breaking wave, and a single line.
Slack, Duluth, 4:55 AM. Come home, Nor-Nor.
I looked at my sister, who was standing right in front of me.
“Wren,” I said. “Did you write this?”
She had gone white to the lips.
“I haven’t signed anything,” she said. “Not in fifteen years.”