Chapter 3: THE PAGE THAT WASN’T THERE0% read • ~6 min

Chapter 3

THE PAGE THAT WASN’T THERE

6 min read•1,286 words

Dale Pruitt stirred his coffee for nine full seconds before he said a word. I counted.

“Dry lungs,” he said.

His office smelled of burnt filters and old paper. A window unit rattled in the corner. On the wall behind him hung a framed photograph of the Ashgrove Bay lighthouse, and beside it, smaller, a snapshot of a woman in a green raincoat laughing at whoever held the camera. Dale’s wife. Twenty years in the water, and she still had a better spot on his wall than the deputy commendations.

“The county medical examiner did a preliminary this afternoon,” he went on. “Dead somewhere between Tuesday night and Wednesday morning. No water in the lungs. No froth in the airway. She was dead before she went in.”

“Cause?”

“Pending.” The spoon clicked on the cup. “I’ll tell you what I can tell you, which is that she didn’t drown, and that’s going to shake this town more than any murder would.”

“Prints?”

“Not in the system. No missing person matching her description in Maine or the next three states.” He tilted his head, his silver mustache lifting with a slow, tired breath. “Whoever she is, nobody’s looking for her. That bothers me.”

“The bracelet.”

“What about it?”

“It was Wren’s. I made it.” I watched his face. “Did anyone mention the clasp?”

The spoon stopped. Just for an instant.

“The clasp was repaired,” Dale said. “Recently. New solder, clean work. Somebody cared about that bracelet enough to keep it in repair for a long time.”

“For fifteen years.”

“Or for a week.” He set the cup down. “Nora. Has your sister contacted you?”

It was a good question. Soft, sideways, folded into the tone of a man asking after the weather. A woman who investigates claims for a living recognizes the shape of an interrogation even when it’s wearing a cardigan.

“My sister has been dead for fifteen years, Dale.”

“Has she.”

“You said so yourself. At the funeral. With no body.”

“I said what the town needed.” His eyes held mine, and again I saw that bone-deep weariness, the thing beneath the evasion. “I’m not accusing you of anything. I’m asking you to tell me if you hear from anyone claiming to be her. Because if somebody’s wearing her jacket and signing her name, that somebody isn’t your sister. And that somebody is dangerous.”

I had not said a word about a signature.

I kept my face smooth. I’d had practice. “I’ll tell you if anyone calls.”

“Good girl.”

I let that one pass, too. On his desk, half under a blotter, a manila folder lay open to a photograph of a rocky shelf with a lantern on it. A yellow sticky note was pressed to the corner. Three words, in Dale’s heavy block hand.

Q’s gap. Page 40.

I memorized it. I didn’t look at it long enough to be noticed.

The rain had softened to a fine cold mist by the time I reached the head of the pier. The Tidehouse stood at the end of its short walkway, lit from inside, a yellow lamp swinging in the draft from a cracked pane. I counted three steps up the porch and noticed that the door was open an inch.

“Mr. Quill?”

The room was empty. His tea sat on the table, skinned over and cold. His reading glasses lay folded on a tide table, one arm bent as if he’d taken them off to rub his eyes and been interrupted. His coat hung on its peg. His boots stood by the stove.

A man who logs the tide by hand every dawn for forty-one years does not walk out into October rain without his boots.

“Tobias?”

Nothing. The lamp creaked. I stepped around the table and my toe hit something. A shoebox, half out from under the bench, lid off. Inside were decades of ledgers, bound in black cloth, each labeled with a year in white paint marker. I ran my finger along the spines. 1998. 2003. 2009.

It lay on its side, slightly apart from the rest, as if recently handled. I pulled it out and opened it to the spring entries. Quill’s tiny, perfect hand. High water 5:14. Wind SW 10. Ebb. Slack. Flood. The tide in orderly rows, a litany of hours, each time a promise the water had kept.

I turned to October. I found the night.

Wren had walked onto the pier on the nineteenth of October, a Saturday. The ledger for the eighteenth was complete. The ledger for the twentieth was complete. The nineteenth had been cut out with a razor, cleanly, along the gutter, so that you could see where the page had been only by the stub in the binding and the pale sliver of paper where somebody’s blade had gone in and out.

“Q’s gap,” I said aloud. My voice sounded very small.

But the missing page was the smaller of the two surprises. Under the ledger, folded into the shoebox, was a loose sheet of lined paper, newer, the edges still crisp. It was today’s tide table in Quill’s neat pencil. High water at 4:41, the number he’d given me that morning. Low water at 11:20 tonight.

Next to the low-water mark, a note.

11:52 is not slack. Check the tables for the 19th.

I flipped the old ledger back to the stub. I flipped forward to the twentieth and read the previous night’s last line, the one that bled into the edge of the cut. Slack water at Keeper’s Reach, 11:52 PM.

I sat down hard on his bench.

Wren’s tide chart didn’t give a time for tonight. She’d drawn the minute she disappeared. The same minute, fifteen years later, to the second, at the same place. She wasn’t summoning me to a meeting. She was summoning me to a reenactment.

I was still holding the page when I heard the engine.

It idled outside, low and patient, then cut off. A truck door shut. Another. Boots on the walkway, two sets, one heavy and slow and one lighter, restless.

I put out the lamp.

I’m not proud of what I did next. I slid under the table in the dark with the ledger pressed to my chest, and I held my breath the way I used to when Wren and I played hide and seek in the bait shed and she’d forget to be quiet. The door creaked. A flashlight beam crossed the floor, touched the cold tea, moved on.

“He’s not here,” said Eli.

“He’ll turn up.” Dale’s voice. No gravel in it now, no warmth, just a flat practicality that I had never heard from him in thirty-four years. “He always turns up.”

“Dale, she’s going to the Reach tonight. I can feel it.”

“She isn’t.”

“You didn’t see her face when I asked about the stranger. She lied to me. She’s lying right now, probably, wherever she is.”

“Of course she’s lying. She’s Ruth’s daughter.” A long breath. “Eli, listen to me. If Nora finds out about the boat, everything we did, everything we did to keep this town standing, goes down with her.”

“I know.”

“Do you? Because you’ve been soft on her since the second she got in that car.”

“That’s not fair.”

“Isn’t it.” The flashlight swung. It passed over the table, an arm’s length from my face, and lingered for one terrible half-second on the stub of the shoebox. “Somebody’s been in here.”

Eli said nothing.

“Check the porch,” Dale said.

Boots crossed the floor. I pressed myself flat against the planks, and the beam reached the underside of the table and found the toe of my left boot sticking out into the light.