Chapter 4: SLACK WATER0% read • ~7 min

Chapter 4

SLACK WATER

7 min read•1,487 words

Eli’s flashlight found my boot and stopped.

I watched the beam through the gap between the table legs, a white circle that sat on the toe of my boot and did not move. My heart was going so hard I felt it in my teeth. He was crouched six feet away. If he said my name, Dale would turn.

The light lifted. It slid up the wall, across the stove, and away.

“Nothing,” Eli said. His voice was perfectly steady. “Rats, probably. This place is a wreck.”

“Check the porch.”

“I just did.”

“Check it again.”

The boots went out. The door shut on its gasp of wind. I lay on the cold planks with the ledger crushed against my ribs and listened to their voices fade down the walkway, to the engine turning over, to the tires hissing on wet gravel. Then silence, thick as wool.

He had seen me. I was certain of it. Eli had spent six years learning how to read my face in the dark, and he had looked straight at my boot and chosen the lie.

I did not know what that meant, and I did not have time to find out.

I took the ledger, the tide table, and nothing else.

Keeper’s Reach is the last finger of rock before the bay opens to the Atlantic. At low tide a spine of black stone rises out of the water, slick and ridged, running three hundred yards from the abandoned lighthouse to a shelf that drops off into forty feet of green dark. As children we were forbidden to go there, which is why Wren took me. She showed me the shelf. She stood at the very edge in her bare feet and said, listen, Nor-Nor, can you hear that? The water’s breathing.

I couldn’t hear anything. I told her she was weird. I think she was already starting to leave.

I came at it the back way, along the old service road, through bayberry thickets that tore at my jeans. The mist had thickened into proper fog. At 11:31 by my watch I could see my own hands and not much farther. A foghorn sounded from the channel, one long note, and I realized I’d stopped breathing again.

I counted exits. There weren’t any. Water on three sides, the road behind me, the lighthouse a black tooth ahead.

At 11:49 a light came on.

It was a lantern, small and steady, hung from a post at the far end of the shelf. By its glow I saw the shape of a rowboat tied to the rocks, riding the slack, and beside it, standing at the edge, a figure in a long coat with the hood down.

My feet carried me forward. I will never be able to explain this. Every instinct I owned, every habit, every rule I’d built a life around, screamed that I was walking into the exact thing I’d been warned about. I walked anyway. The stone was slick under my boots. The water on either side was so still it looked solid.

She stood with her back to me. Taller than I remembered, though people grow, I told myself, they grow in all kinds of ways. The coat was too big. Her hair was cropped close to her skull, and not dark, as I’d expected, but a faded, silvering red.

Sandy red, down to her waist, once.

“Wren,” I said.

The foghorn sounded. She did not turn.

“You came,” she said. “I told Ruth you wouldn’t. She said you always do.”

The voice was lower than it should have been. Rougher, sanded by fifteen years. But the cadence was the same, the slight lift at the end of a sentence like she was about to laugh at her own joke. My throat closed.

“Turn around.”

“In a minute. Let me look at the water first. I haven’t been allowed to look at it in a long time.” A small, dry sound that wasn’t a laugh. “Nor-Nor. You’re still counting exits, aren’t you? You’re counting them right now.”

I was. I’d found two. The boat, and the road.

“Please turn around.”

She did.

She was thin, and her face had been weathered into something sharp and brown, and the gap in her front teeth was still there, the one thing time hadn’t touched. A white scar curled along her jaw. She was smiling, and she was crying, and I couldn’t tell which one she’d started first.

I didn’t remember crossing the distance. I remembered the smell of her coat, wool and woodsmoke and salt. I remembered her hands in my hair and my own sounds, ugly, helpless, the noises of a girl on a pier fifteen years ago who had never learned to make them.

“I’m sorry,” I said into her shoulder. “I’m so sorry, I left you there, I told them you went swimming, it was my fault, Wren, I’m so sorry.”

She stiffened.

“I know,” she said gently. “I know you did.”

She held me away from her. Her eyes, grey like mine, searched my face as if memorizing it.

“You told them I went swimming alone.”

“Yes.”

“You didn’t tell them about the boat.”

“What boat?”

Something flickered across her face, fast, then gone. A woman checking a calculation and finding it wrong. “You really don’t know.”

“Wren, what boat?”

“Nora.” Her voice dropped. “The woman in the bay. Did they tell you who she was?”

“No. They don’t know.”

“Her name was Marnie.” She said it carefully, like setting down something that might break. “She was twenty-nine. She’s been helping me for two years. She came into town on Tuesday because I asked her to, because I couldn’t risk it myself. She wore my jacket because I gave it to her. She was supposed to be safe.”

“Safe from what?”

“From what I know.”

The lantern hissed. The tide, which had been dead still, shifted against the rock with a long, soft sound like a sigh. Behind me, far back along the spine of stone, came the sound of a truck door.

“Nora.” Wren’s grip tightened on my arms. “Listen to me. You have maybe four minutes. I’m going to ask you one thing, and I need you to answer it honestly, because everything depends on whether you remember it right.”

“Anything.”

“The night I went into the water. After we fought. When you walked off the pier, who was waiting at the end of it?”

I opened my mouth.

I had never told anyone, not Dale, not my mother, not a single therapist, because there was nothing to tell. I’d been seventeen and furious. I had walked off the pier and down the road and gone home. No one had been waiting.

Had they?

The memory shifted under me like wet sand. A shape at the end of the pier. A small light. The gleam of a silver mustache, or a sandy head, or a stooped white beard. I couldn’t hold it. The harder I reached, the faster it ran.

“I don’t know,” I whispered. “I don’t remember.”

“I know,” Wren said, so softly I almost didn’t hear. “That’s what they counted on.”

Boots on stone, closer. A beam of light cut through the fog, swung across the water, and found us.

“Wren,” a voice called. Eli’s voice, hoarse and thin. He stood thirty feet away with his hand out, not reaching for a weapon, just reaching, as if he might catch her across the distance. His hat was gone. His face was bone white. “Wren, don’t.”

She looked at him.

I understood it before she said a word. It was in the way she held herself, no fear at all, only a long, weary recognition. Fifteen years of silence, and neither of them was surprised.

“Hello, Eli,” she said.

“I didn’t know you’d come tonight.”

“Yes, you did,” said my sister. “You’ve known the whole time.”

He took a step. Wren took one back, toward the boat, her heel on the edge of the shelf. Beyond her the water had begun to turn, the first slow pull of the flood.

“Nora,” Eli said, without taking his eyes off her. “Whatever she told you, don’t repeat it to Dale. Please. Not until I explain.”

“Explain what?”

“Ask him,” said Wren. She stepped down into the rowboat, and the lantern swung, and for a moment her face was lit from below and she looked seventeen again, freckled and fast and furious. “Ask Eli who held the boat for them.”

The oars bit the water. The fog took her in three strokes.

I stood at the edge of Keeper’s Reach with the flood tide climbing the rocks around my boots, and behind me, Eli’s breath was ragged, and farther back, down the stone spine, a second flashlight was coming on, slow and steady, and I knew the exact cadence of the man behind it.