Chapter 5: A FOOL IN THIS FOG0% read • ~6 min

Chapter 5

A FOOL IN THIS FOG

6 min read•1,273 words

Dale Pruitt came out of the fog with his flashlight pointed at the ground, and that was how I knew he had already seen everything he needed to.

The flood had reached my ankles. It came in quietly, the way tides do when they mean business, no splash, only a steady rising of black over black. On the post at the end of the shelf the lantern still burned. Of my sister there was nothing left but a pale scuff on the rock where her boot had pushed off, and out in the dark a small rusted sound, a gate hinge swinging, moving away.

Eli had put himself half in front of me. I don’t think he knew he’d done it.

“Evening, children,” Dale said.

Nobody answered. He came down the spine of stone at the pace of a man walking to his own mailbox, a thermos tucked under one arm. The lantern caught the silver of his mustache. He looked at Eli. He looked at me. Then he looked at the lantern, and he did not seem surprised by it.

“That’s Tobias’s lamp.”

“Dale,” Eli said.

“I’m only remarking.” He unscrewed the thermos, poured a cup, and stirred it with a spoon he had apparently brought for the purpose. “I heard oarlocks. The left one’s been squeaking since ninety-four. You’d know that sound, Nora. You grew up on it.”

I hadn’t known it. I’d have sworn on anything that I hadn’t. But the sound out on the water went on, thin and patient, and some old animal part of me turned toward it like a plant to a window.

“Then somebody’s out there,” I said. “On a flood, in this. You should radio the Coast Guard.”

“Should I.”

I have sat across from arsonists who burned down their own warehouses and wept for the cameras. I know the face of a man doing arithmetic with a lie. This wasn’t that. Dale looked out at the dark water the way you look at a grave when you’re deciding whether to stay for the rest of it.

“Tobias has rowed this bay for fifty years,” he said at last. “A man who knows his water knows when to be on it. If he’s a fool, he’s earned it.” He drank. “Go home, Eli.”

“I’d rather stay.”

“Deputy.”

One word, and not loud. Eli’s jaw worked. He looked at me, one second, and his mouth shaped something with no sound in it. Later. Then he went back along the stone and the fog took him in pieces, the pale shirt last.

The ledger was pressed flat against my ribs under my coat, wet through, a cold slab of forty years. I made my breathing slow.

“You’re holding yourself funny,” Dale said. “Like you’ve got something in there.”

“A cinnamon toothpick and a headache.”

“Did you go into the Tidehouse tonight?”

“Why would I?”

“Why indeed.” He screwed the cap back on the thermos. The tide slid over the toe of my boot and he watched it do it. “Come on. You get your feet wet on the Reach, you won’t need a boat to go missing.”

I hadn’t said a word to him in that sentence’s direction. I followed him anyway.

His truck smelled of coffee and wet dog, though he’d never owned a dog. He drove with two fingers on the wheel. The wipers dragged. For a mile he said nothing, and I let him, because silence is a tool and I’m better at it than he is.

I wasn’t, as it turned out.

“You did what I asked of you that night,” he said. “I never thanked you.”

My hand went still in my lap.

“What night?”

“Any night.” He turned onto Harbor Road. The sign for Vance Bait and Tackle swam up in the headlights, the patched V, the Sharpie. “You were a good girl, Nora. Whatever you’ve come to think of me. You went home when you were told.”

“Who told me?”

He pulled up at the curb and put the truck in park and looked at me, and the tiredness in his face was so enormous that I almost felt sorry for him. Almost.

“Get some sleep,” he said.

The kitchen light was on upstairs.

Ruth sat at the table in her nightgown, no apron, her silver braid undone and lying over one shoulder like something shed. The coffee tin stood open in front of her. She had set her hands flat on the oilcloth, side by side, and as I came in I understood what was wrong with the picture, the thing that had been wrong with it all night. She was not wiping them.

“Sit,” she said.

I sat.

“She’s alive.”

It was the clearest voice I’d heard from her in a year. Not a drift in it, not a thread. A woman reading a verdict.

“I know, Mom. I saw her.”

“I’ve known since the first card.” She slid a bundle across the oilcloth. Postcards, bound with a rubber band gone brittle. I counted them without wanting to. Fifteen. Each one had come on the nineteenth of October. No return address. Halifax, Duluth, Astoria, Savannah. On the back of each, a tide chart in blue ballpoint, the little sine wave of a coastline I’d never seen, and a single circled hour.

“You let me bury her,” I said.

My voice had gone quiet. When I’m really angry I get quiet, and Eli used to say it was like standing near a transformer.

“You buried her yourself, honey.” Ruth’s eyes didn’t leave mine. “I only didn’t dig you out.”

“Why?”

“Dale said if you knew, you’d go looking. And if you went looking, they would look at you.”

“Who’s they?”

She opened her mouth. I watched the answer come up in her and I watched it fail, the light behind her eyes going out room by room. When she spoke again it was smaller.

“I don’t remember,” she said, and it was the truth, and it was the worst thing she had ever told me.

She reached into the tin. Her fingers pressed along the bottom, and a disc of cardboard lifted away, and beneath it lay a sheet of ruled paper folded in thirds.

“This wasn’t here Tuesday,” she said. “I look every night. Tonight it was.”

I unfolded it. Names, in columns. A date beside each, a time beside the date. The handwriting was heavy block capitals I had seen that morning on a sticky note under a blotter. Dale’s hand. Across the top, a single word.

LOST.

I ran my finger down it. Forty-one names across twenty-seven years. A check mark in ink beside each one. WALTER MARSH. 1998. SLACK 3:10 AM. I knew that name. It was Eli’s father. A few lines down, THOMAS VANCE. LUCY MAY. 1999.

“Dad’s on here.”

“Is he?” Ruth said. She had begun to drift. “He was alive when he left the dock. They were all alive. Every one of them was alive when they left the dock. Except.” She frowned at the wall. “Except one. I don’t remember which.”

Near the bottom I found my sister. WREN VANCE. OCT 19, 2011. SLACK 11:52 PM.

And then, in the last line, with no check mark beside it yet, in ink that had barely dried, I found myself.

NORA VANCE. OCT 20. SLACK 12:41 AM.

Tomorrow night. Almost exactly twenty-four hours from now.

Ruth had stopped talking. She sat with her hands flat on the table and watched me read my own name, and somewhere below us in the dark shop the shiners turned in their tank and turned again.