Chapter 9: THE CLEANEST INVESTIGATOR0% read • ~6 min

Chapter 9

THE CLEANEST INVESTIGATOR

6 min read•1,320 words

I watched the video three times, and the third time I stopped hearing the words and heard only the voice, because the voice was the same one that had said good morning to me every Monday since the day I’d signed my contract.

“Pellam’s the largest we’ve done,” Gideon Ames said on the dock, his breath fogging in the lantern light. “Four million for the door and two for the paper. His board meets Thursday. He wants to be on the water by Friday.”

“I’m not doing it.” Dale’s voice, flat and gravel-rough.

“Dale.”

“I’m shutting the Fund. I’ve told you. It was never meant for this. Carol didn’t build it for men like Pellam.”

“Carol’s dead. Carol’s been dead twenty years.” The smile crept into Ames’s tone, the same one he used on claimants who tried to wriggle. “I’m the only reason the Fund has a roof. You can have your widows and your fishermen. I’ll even leave them alone. But the Pellams pay the heating bill, and you take the money, and you’ve taken it for four years.”

“You said it would be quiet.”

“It’s been quiet. Do you know why? Because of the investigator.” There was a pause. The lantern hissed. “She closed Raske in eleven days. I gave it to her because I knew she’d see it as grief. And she did. She’s the cleanest investigator I have. She asks every question except the one that matters, and she thinks that’s integrity.”

“Leave her out of this.”

“I hired her out of Hartford four years ago, Dale. Did you think it was luck?” Ames laughed, a pleasant sound. “Her sister vanished off your pier. The daughter of the woman who runs your cover story. I couldn’t have asked for a better pair of blind eyes. She won’t look at Ashgrove Bay. She told me herself, the first interview. She said, I don’t go home.”

Under me, the cot creaked. I realized I had been gripping the phone hard enough to make the screen flex.

“You’re done talking about her,” said Dale.

“I’ll talk about whoever I like. There’s a girl in your boathouse.”

The picture lurched.

I heard Marnie’s breathing for the first time, a high, shallow whistle behind the phone. The strip of orange light slid sideways and the voices dimmed. Dale: “There’s nobody in my boathouse.” Ames, softly, close to the slats: “I can hear her. Can you hear her, Dale? She’s about as quiet as a kettle.”

A thump. A shout. The screen went black, then white, then the video ended on a still frame of wet planks and the toe of a boot.

I lowered the phone.

The cold room had gone completely silent. Somewhere above us water dripped from a rafter, once, twice, a clock counting down something I couldn’t name.

“Say it,” I said.

Eli didn’t move. He stood against the granite with his hands at his sides, for once not in his pockets, and I watched him decide.

“I’ve seen him,” he said.

“Where?”

“Two years ago. March.” His voice came out hollow. “Dale called me at midnight. Said there was a man who needed to be on a yacht by four. I rowed him out past Keeper’s Reach. Man in a good overcoat, scared, sweating through it. Heavy. He kept saying he’d never been on the water at night.” He rubbed his face. “There was a second man on the dock who handed him over. A camel coat. He tipped me a hundred dollars. I thought it was a funeral director, Nora. I swear to God, I thought he was a funeral director.”

“Raske,” I said.

“I never knew his name.”

“You rowed my own claim out to sea.” My voice had gone quiet. “And then you came home and sat across a table from me at Thanksgiving.”

“I didn’t know it was your claim.”

“Would you have said?”

He opened his mouth. He closed it.

“That’s what I thought.”

I moved past him, up the stairs. He caught my sleeve on the third step and I stopped, and I did not turn, because if I turned I would hit him.

“You can hate me tomorrow,” he said, very low. “Right now there’s an old woman in Dale’s kitchen and a man who tells you good morning on Mondays and doesn’t blink at murder.”

“He didn’t kill her.”

“Who?”

“Marnie. Listen to the tape. He said she was quiet as a kettle. He knew she was listening. He didn’t say a word about what he’d do.” I forced air into my lungs. “But somebody did something.”

The phone in my coat buzzed.

My own phone, not Marnie’s. I pulled it out with the nervous shuddering of someone defusing a wire. The screen glowed. The sender’s name read GIDEON AMES.

Nora, you around? Pellam moved up. Need you on the file by Thursday. Don’t let me down.

Eli saw it over my shoulder. All the blood left his face.

“He doesn’t know,” he whispered.

“He knows.” I made my thumbs steady. “He knows exactly where I am. He sent me a photograph of my mother this morning. But he wants me to know that he knows, and he wants to know that I know it, and he wants us both to go on pretending until it’s useful.”

“What do you do?”

I did what I’ve done all my life. I answered the claim.

Sure. Pulling it now. Be in touch, I typed. The little bubble turned blue. I counted three seconds. Four. Five. The dots appeared under his message and then vanished, and what came back was a thumbs-up.

I felt sick. I felt, God help me, a fleck of old gratitude, the reflex of a woman who had spent four years wanting this man’s approval. I put it away.

“Call Dale’s house,” I said.

“What?”

“The landline. You know the number. Ask for Ruth. Say you’re checking in.”

Eli dialed from his own phone with a thumb that wouldn’t hold still. It rang eleven times. I counted. Nobody picked up. He let it go to a long, dead tone and said, “He doesn’t have a machine.”

“He doesn’t have to.”

Above us, outside, gravel crunched.

We both went still. A vehicle was rolling down the point road, unhurried, the engine’s idle as familiar to me now as my own breath. The slap of a door. Boots on the porch of the cottage. A pause. Boots coming around the side of the house toward the boathouse.

“The slip door,” Eli breathed. “He’ll come through the slip.”

“The slip’s rolled shut. The side door’s open.” I looked at the hatch above us, at the square of grey light we’d left it with. “We never closed it.”

“We can still.”

“No.”

I couldn’t have said why I made that decision. Maybe it was the way the footsteps came, slow, patient, with a faint drag on the left that I had never noticed before in thirty-four years. A bad knee, or a bad conscience. Maybe it was that I was tired of hiding.

I stood at the foot of the stairs in the light of the bare bulb with Marnie’s phone in my hand and my sister’s key around my finger and I waited for the sheriff of Ashgrove Bay to find me.

The hatch darkened. A pair of boots, resoled twice, appeared on the top step, then big knees, then a hand holding a paper cup that didn’t have a drop in it.

Dale Pruitt looked down at us the way he must have looked at a hundred frightened people who thought they’d found their way out.

“I wondered how long it’d take you to find the cold room,” he said. “Put the phone in your pocket, Nora. We’ve got about four hours to keep your mother alive, and I’m the only one in this town who knows where she is.”