Chapter 12
THE OARSMAN
Dale never asked me to repeat what the tag said. He sat on the floor of the cold room with the hook across his knees and read it the way you read a diagnosis you’ve already given yourself.
“I hit him twice,” he said at last.
“You hit him with an oar. Quill’s tag says it wasn’t the oar.”
“Then why have I carried it?”
I had no answer that was kind. I told him to stay where he was, to keep my mother’s kettle from boiling dry in his head, and to be on the water with Eli at midnight. I took the key, the ledger, and the pole of brass, and I went up out of the granite into a day that had gone the color of dishwater.
It was dusk when I reached the cannery.
The fence had been cut in one place, a neat slit a person could slip through. I counted the windows on the harbor side as I went. Nine, all boarded. The boathouse hung over the water at the back, its stilts furred with weed, a light burning in the one unboarded square. I stood at the door a moment with my hand flat against the wood. The wood was warm.
I knocked twice, then once. I don’t know why. It was the knock we used on the bait shed when we were small.
“Come in, Nor-Nor,” said my sister. “You’re letting the cold in.”
She sat on an overturned crate with Quill’s head in her lap, a lantern burning low beside her, and she did not stand. Up close she was smaller than she’d been on the rock, small the way a person gets who has spent fifteen years holding herself in. The cropped hair had been silvered by something other than age. She wore a gray knit cap and a man’s wool coat and, on her left forearm, pushed up past the elbow, a tide chart in fresh blue ballpoint, still wet.
“You’re late,” she said. “Mom would’ve said so.”
“She did.”
Something crossed her face, brief as a hand across a window. “Is she all right?”
“Ames has her.”
I watched it hit her. She did not cry. She went still, the way Ruth goes still, and I saw where I’d gotten my quiet from.
“Then we haven’t got long,” she said, and looked down at the old man. “And neither has he.”
Quill’s face had gone the color of candle wax. His eyes were open, glossy, the pupils swimming. When I knelt he knew me. The corner of his mouth lifted, the old dry ghost of a joke.
“Miss Vance. You found the hook.”
“I did.”
“I wrote the tag in the spring, after Marnie came. I thought, now somebody will look.” The breath shuddered out of him. “I’d have liked to say it to your face, Dale’s, not a bit of paper. But I’m a coward who writes things down.”
“Tobias,” Wren said softly. “You don’t have to.”
“I do.” He took her wrist and held it. “Let me log it.”
I’d stood in a hundred rooms where someone was telling the truth for the last time, and I know how to be silent in them. I took the ledger out of my coat. I put it on the crate next to the lantern. I did not say anything.
“He’d hit him twice,” Quill said. “Dale. Two blows, with an oar, to the head. Lyle Prewitt went down on the planks and lay there. Your sister stood in the doorway, Nora, in her wet boots. Dale said, I’ve killed him, and he walked out into the dark to be sick. I had come down behind her with the lantern. I’d followed her from the pier.” His eyes slid to the ceiling, the old rafters. “Lyle got up.”
Wren’s hand tightened in his.
“He had a knife in his boot. A fishing knife. He got up on one knee and he turned his head and he saw Dale’s back in the doorway and then he saw her.” His voice dropped to a thread. “I’d never done a thing in my life, you understand. Forty years logging other people’s tides. But there was a boat hook on the wall, and I took it down, and I put it through him.”
“Tobias.”
“I stood there with the pole. The lantern was shaking so hard the light went round the room.” A long wet breath. “And Dale came back and found him dead, and found me with the hook, and he took it out of my hands, Nora. He said, it was me. You were never here. He said it was the oar. He thought two blows had killed him, and I let him believe it.”
I understood, then, what I’d been reading in the stooped way he moved. It wasn’t the fear of a man who had failed to log one night. It was the fear of a man who had done the only brave thing of his life and spent fifteen years letting somebody else pay for it.
“Why did you let him?” I said.
“Because a sheriff who thinks he’s a murderer will protect a seventeen-year-old girl, and a harbormaster who knows he is will not.” Quill’s mouth worked. “I thought it was the practical choice. I thought, it will be one night. And then one night was a week and a year and a life.”
“And Wren?”
“Kept the hook.” His eyes went to my sister. “She wanted me to have a way out. She hid it behind the cork the next morning. She said, someday you’ll want it, and I told her I never would.”
“I told him he was wrong,” Wren said, so low I almost missed it. “I’d have told Dale myself. But I’d seen what Dale does when a person’s sorry. He puts them on a boat.” She laughed, a wet, ruined sound. “So I went on the boat.”
“Wren.”
“I was seventeen, Nora. I’d watched two men decide that the fastest way to bury what happened was to bury me. Dale to protect me. Tobias to protect himself. Eli to protect whoever Dale said needed it. Nobody asked me.” She didn’t look at me. “Nobody asked you either.”
“I’d have said no.”
“I know.” She looked up then, grey eyes, my eyes, wet in the lantern light. “That’s why I mouthed it. Go home. I knew if you stayed, you’d fix it. You’d audit the whole thing. You’d do it perfectly, and you’d burn down everyone we loved to be right.”
It was a hard sentence. It was also fair. I took it the way I take most things, in the sternum, and let it sit there.
“I’m sorry I left you on the pier,” I said.
“You left me on the pier because I told you I was fine. You were nineteen. I was a liar.” She wiped her face with the heel of her hand. “I’ve been sorry for fifteen years that I said it.”
Neither of us touched the other. We didn’t have to. Some things you hold across a gap, and the gap holds.
“Marnie,” I said, after a while.
“Was Ames’s paralegal.” Wren’s voice was steadier now. “Four years at the Hartford office, drafting the policies. She noticed the Fund payments. She traced the Relief Fund’s board to a P.O. box that belonged to his sister. She went looking for someone who could tell her what it was for.” She smiled faintly. “She found me. I’ve been running the other end for twelve years, the Landing, they call it, a handful of rooms in cities where a lost person can learn to be found. Halifax. Duluth. Astoria. I send postcards home, once a year. I’d stopped believing anyone read them.”
“Mom read every one.”
“I know. She never wrote back.” Wren pressed her lips together. “That was how I knew she understood.”
Quill’s chest rose, fell, rose. I felt rather than saw Wren bend to his ear, and I heard her say something I didn’t catch, and he smiled, a small, startled, unguarded thing. When his eyes found me again they were looking through me at something very far.
“Slack,” he whispered.
“Tobias?”
“Slack water, Nora. Log it.”
His fingers uncurled from my sister’s wrist, one at a time. His eyes stayed open. For a while, neither of us moved. Wren’s hand rose and settled on his face and closed the lids, the way you’d close a book you’d loved.
The lantern guttered. Outside, the harbor slapped at the pilings. Somewhere in the cannery a pipe ticked as it cooled.
I took the pencil from his pocket. I opened the ledger to the last page of the Index, below the line he’d written about me, and in my cold bad handwriting I logged it. The date. The hour. Tobias Quill, harbormaster. Of the cold. Of the truth in pieces. Not alone.
“Nor-Nor,” Wren said.
“Yes.”
“Did you bring the phone?”
My hand went to my coat. The firm phone sat in my pocket where it had sat all day, a flat black stone, a leash I’d chosen to keep on. I had meant it as a decoy. Somewhere in the last twenty minutes I had stopped thinking of it as anything at all.
I looked up. Wren was already on her feet. She had heard it before I did, tires on gravel, slow, a long way off, and a car door.
“He’s early,” she whispered. “Stay with the body. Let him take you.” Her hand closed hard on my arm. “I’ll be behind you in the water. Don’t look for me.”
“Wren.”
“Say it back.”
“Don’t look for you.”
She went out through the slip door into the dark, and I heard the small wet sound of someone entering the bay. Then the boathouse door swung inward on the light of a flashlight, and Cody Rudd stood on the threshold with a revolver held out in both hands and a sunburn that had gone gray with fear.
“Miss Vance,” he said. His voice cracked in the middle. “Mr. Ames says it’s time.”