Chapter 6: WHAT THE TIDE LEFT OF THE ANNIE0% read • ~9 min

Chapter 6

WHAT THE TIDE LEFT OF THE ANNIE

9 min read•1,919 words

The Annie lay on her side in the mud flats beyond the ice house, a black rib cage with the fog moving through it. Her planking had been stripped for firewood a plank at a time over twenty years, and what remained looked less like a boat than the memory of one. At low tide you could walk right up to her keel.

It was low tide.

I came down the slick steps from the pier with my gloves on, and Eli did not turn around. He stood with his back to what was left of the stern, one hand flat against the old wood, and his coat hung off his shoulders in a way that made my chest hurt.

“You saw,” I said.

“I saw.”

“You heard none of it.”

“I didn’t need to.” His voice carried in the gray quiet. “I watched your face through the window. You were looking at Wren, and then you weren’t. I knew it was done.”

I stopped four feet away. Mud sucked at my boots. The smell of low tide rose around us, salt and rot and iodine and something very old.

“I have a question,” I said.

“I figured.”

“It’s yours for the day. You promised honestly.”

“I did.”

“Why didn’t you ask me?”

His hand slid down the wood. He stood quite still, and the fog moved around him in slow ribbons, and I thought he would do what he always did, go silent until the room gave up. I did not look away. I had spent seven years being furious in a space where he could not answer. I would not waste his presence.

“Because you’d have said yes,” he said at last.

“To what?”

“To everything. To paying. To going to Pell yourself with your hat in your hand. To signing the shop away. To sitting in a courtroom beside Wren.” He turned to face me then. His eyes were red-rimmed, and I did not think it was the wind. “I know you. You can’t see someone drowning without wading in. And I’d watched my father’s debt eat three generations of Hartwells down to nothing. I couldn’t stand to watch it start on you.”

“That wasn’t yours to decide.”

“No.”

“You don’t get to choose what I can survive.”

“No,” he said again, and the plain word cracked at the edges. “I know that now. I’ve known it for about six years and eleven months. I just couldn’t think of a way to say it that wasn’t another lie.”

“Try the truth.”

“I was twenty-six and scared out of my mind, and the only thing in the world I was sure of was that I’d rather you hate me than be hurt.” He looked at the Annie. “It was the stupidest, most arrogant thing I’ve ever done. And if you gave me the night over, I think I’d do it again, and I’d despise myself the whole way.”

“That’s not an apology.”

“It’s not meant to be one. I’ve got a whole list of those. You’ll get them one at a time.” A flicker crossed his face, not quite a smile. “You said one question a day.”

“I did.”

“That was today’s. You asked it well.”

I wanted to hit him. I wanted to fold myself against his chest and howl. I wanted, with a fierceness that shocked me, to be twenty-four again, standing in a church basement at two in the morning with a pen in my hand and a whole life stretched ahead like a clean sheet of paper.

Instead I walked up to the Annie and put my own hand against her ribs, beside his, without touching.

“Wren says there’s a plan,” I said.

“There is.”

“Tell me.”

“Not yet.”

“Eli.”

“I’m not holding out on you. I’m holding something I can’t set down in front of the wrong person.” He looked up the shoreline toward the cannery, where the lights burned yellow in the fog. “Pell has eyes in this town. I will tell you all of it. By the end of the week, I swear. I just need the vows to get started before I can say what the vows are for.”

“That makes no sense.”

“It will.”

“I don’t like being used as a tool.”

“You’re not a tool.” The words came out sharp, and he caught himself, and softened. “Nora. You’re the only reason I have a plan at all.”

The tide sucked softly at the hull. A cold wind came off the water and moved through the gaps in the planking and made a low note like someone blowing across a bottle.

“I’m not going to forgive you today,” I said.

“I don’t expect it.”

“I may not forgive you for months.”

“I’ve waited seven years. I can wait for a Tuesday.”

I pressed my thumbnail into my finger. He saw it. I watched him see it, his eyes dropping to my hand, and the soft, devastating recognition that crossed his face made me want to pull the glove off and show him the mark.

“You’re lying,” he said, very gently.

“I’m not.”

“You are, a little.”

“A very little.”

“How little?”

“I want to forgive you right now,” I said, and my voice broke on the last word, “and I’m furious that I do.”

For a moment neither of us moved. The tide whispered. A gull settled on the cracked stern post and regarded us with a flat yellow eye.

Then Eli reached out, slowly, the way you reach toward a skittish animal, and with two fingers drew a loose strand of auburn hair back behind my ear. His knuckle grazed my cheekbone. Barely. It might have been the wind.

I stopped breathing.

“There it is,” he murmured, and it was not clear whom he was talking to.

His hand dropped. He stepped back. I felt the loss in my whole body, a cold slice of air where his warmth had been, and I hated how perfectly I remembered the shape of him.

“I’ll walk you back,” he said.

“I know the way.”

“I know you do.”

“I’d rather go alone.”

“All right.” He did not argue. He watched me climb the pier steps, and when I reached the top, I turned and he was still there at the foot of the old boat, a lean dark figure against the fog, one hand again in his pocket, turning the compass over.

I walked to the shop on legs that did not feel like mine.

Aunt Dot was not in the shop. The sign still said CLOSED, and the lights were off, and Wren had gone, though somebody had swept the china from the floor and put the lilacs in a milk jug on the counter, where they sat like a reproach. A note in loopy blue ink was tucked into the jug. Gone to see Theo. He’s feeding me. Don’t hate me. W.

I did not hate her. I put the note in my pocket with Eli’s.

My apartment was above the bakery. When I climbed the stairs, the lamp on the landing was burning, and the door stood open, and the kitchen light was on, and at my own table, in my own chair, with a manila folder squared in front of her and her reading glasses on their chain, sat my aunt Dot.

She had made tea. Two cups. She had put sugar in mine, which she knew I did not take.

“Sit,” she said.

“How did you get in?”

“I’ve had a key since you were seven.”

“Dot.”

“Sit down, Nora.”

I sat. The tea steamed between us. She laid her hand flat on the folder and did not open it, and I understood that I was looking at a woman who had been working up to this moment for seven years and had decided, today, to stop being brave in installments.

“Your sister told you,” she said.

“About the forged loan? Yes.”

“Good. That saves time.” She took off her glasses. Without them, her eyes looked old and fierce and very tired. “Did she tell you that I knew?”

I did not say anything. The refrigerator hummed. Somewhere below us, faintly, I could hear Theo laughing.

“I found out the week after Eli left,” Dot said. “Pell’s lawyer came to the shop. Very courteous. He laid the paper on my counter and asked if I recognized the signature. I looked at it for a long time. And I said, Yes. That’s mine.”

“You lied.”

“I lied to a lawyer to protect a child who had done a foolish, loving thing.” Her chin lifted. “I would lie to the pope. But it didn’t help in the end, because Eli had already signed the debt over to himself, and Pell wasn’t buying my story. He wanted the loan to stay hers. A hook he could pull on when he chose.”

“You’ve known for seven years.”

“I’ve known. And I’ve been paying Pell’s interest out of the shop every month since, because it was the only way I could think of to keep Eli’s note from growing.” She said it flatly, like a bill. “It isn’t enough. It was never going to be enough.”

My tea had gone cold. I did not remember lifting it.

“Why didn’t you tell me?”

“Because every time I tried, you looked so tired. And I thought, let her have one thing that isn’t broken.” The glasses went back on, and her mouth did something complicated. “I’ve kept secrets out of love all my life, child. I’m not proud of it. It’s a very good way to hurt people for their own good.”

“Eli said the same thing.”

“Eli is a fool. I’m only an old woman.” She tapped the folder. “Now. There’s one more thing, and it is not a secret, exactly. It’s a thing you never read.”

She opened the folder. Inside lay a stack of papers, creased and yellowed at the corners, with a county seal pressed into the top sheet.

“When your father died,” Dot said, “he left the building to the three of us. Me, you, and your sister. One third apiece. I put your names on the deed because it was what he wanted. You signed where I told you. You were seventeen.”

“I remember signing something.”

“You signed this.”

I looked at the line at the bottom. My own signature, young and rounded and eager, looped across the paper in blue ink beside two others.

Dorothea Vale. Nora Vale. Wren Vale.

“The shop,” I said slowly, “isn’t yours.”

“It’s ours.” Dot closed the folder. “And Calloway Pell has spent twenty years trying to buy the last parcel on the waterfront. He’s never been able to, because it requires two of three signatures, and I will sign nothing he writes. But your sister has one third. And your sister is, at present, in his debt for a crime I spent seven years paying to bury.”

“Wren would never.”

“Wren has been very brave about the whole thing. But a girl can only be brave so long.” Dot looked at me, and her eyes were wet, and she did nothing at all to hide it. “He doesn’t want his money, Nora. He’s never wanted his money. He wants the floor under our feet. And he wants the two of you to be the ones who hand it over.”

On the landing, the brass lamp burned on, steady and gold, as it had every night for seven years.

Vows for the Man I Almost Married — Chapter 6: WHAT THE TIDE LEFT OF THE ANNIE | BlueNov