Chapter 5: THE GIFT I NEVER ASKED FOR0% read • ~8 min

Chapter 5

THE GIFT I NEVER ASKED FOR

8 min read•1,705 words

I did not let go of her hands. I want that understood. Every instinct I owned told me to stand up, to cross the room, to put a counter between me and whatever was coming, and I stayed crouched on the wet floorboards with my sister’s cold fingers in mine and tea soaking into the knees of my good wool trousers.

“Say it plainly,” I said. “Like you’re reading it off a card.”

“I can’t read it off a card. It doesn’t rhyme.”

“Wren.”

She drew a breath that shook all the way down. “I took money from Calloway Pell.”

The radiator ticked. A gull walked along the gutter above us, claws scratching slate.

“How much?”

“Forty thousand dollars.”

I laughed. I could not help it. It came out of me thin and wild, and Wren flinched as though I had slapped her. “Forty thousand. You were twenty-one. You were waiting tables at the Anchor.”

“I know what I was.”

“What on earth did you need forty thousand dollars for?”

“For you.” She said it so quietly I almost lost it under the ticking of the pipes. “For your wedding.”

I let go of her hands.

“Don’t,” Wren said. “Please. Let me do it in order, or I’ll never get it out.” She wiped her face with the heel of her palm, smearing mascara into the soft hollow under her eye. “You remember that spring. You’d spent six months saying we’d do the church basement, and a cake from Theo, and your good green dress, because that was what you could afford. And every time Dot offered to help, you said no. You said you’d never take what you hadn’t earned.”

“That’s a perfectly reasonable thing to say.”

“It’s the saddest thing I ever heard.” The tears were running freely now, and she let them. “You planned your own wedding like an apology. Like you were sorry to be taking up the room. And I thought, for once in my life, I could be the one who fixed something. I was always the one getting carried. Always the baby. You and Dot, deciding what I could handle. I wanted to hand you something and have you say, Wren, you did this.”

“You went to Pell.”

“He had an office on the pier with a window and a bowl of butterscotch candies. He was so kind. He asked after Dot. He said any Vale was good for it.” Her mouth twisted. “He wanted a guarantor on the loan. Someone with property. The shop was in Dot’s name, so I wrote her name.”

The words dropped into the room like stones into a well, and I listened for them to hit bottom.

“You forged Dot’s signature.”

“I did it on the kitchen table, with a tracing from a birthday card. I thought, I’ll pay it back by summer, no one will ever know, and then you’ll have your lace and your flowers and your good shoes and I’ll just be the girl who made it happen.” She laughed, a horrible small sound. “I got the church flowers, you know. Seven hundred dollars of peonies. You never asked where they came from.”

I had not. I remembered them now, white and heavy, banked along the altar rail, and how I had stood at the back of the nave the night before the wedding and thought, with a flash of guilty pleasure, how very much they looked like a real wedding.

“The night before,” I said. “The rehearsal.”

“Pell sent a man with papers that afternoon. He was calling the loan. All of it, immediately, on a technicality, some clause I didn’t even know I’d signed. He said a quiet word to the bank, and the bank said they’d be examining the guarantor’s signature.” Wren pressed her fist to her sternum. “Nora, it was forgery. Do you understand? They were going to take the shop, and then they were going to take me.”

“You could have come to me.”

“I couldn’t come to you. You were getting married in the morning. You were so happy. You’d sung in the shower, did you know that? You never sing.”

“So who did you go to?”

She looked at me with those wet eyes, and I knew the answer an instant before she said it, the way you know the next step in a dark house is a stair that isn’t there.

“Eli.”

“In the vestry,” I said.

“After the rehearsal dinner. You’d gone home to sleep. He found me crying behind the hymn racks. I told him everything. He didn’t say a word. He just took out that stupid brass compass and turned it over, and over, and over, and I thought he was going to be angry. And then he said, Leave it with me.”

“And he went to Pell.”

“He went to Pell that night. I don’t know what they said. I only know that when I woke up the next morning, there was a note under my door in his handwriting. Look after your sister. I’m sorry. Don’t tell her.” She swallowed. “Don’t tell her. It was the last thing he ever asked me. And three days later Pell’s lawyer came to the house, very polite, and said the matter had been resolved, and that Mr. Hartwell had taken on the full obligation himself, on one condition.”

“Which was?”

“That he never contact you again. Not a letter, not a call. If he did, the forgery went to the county prosecutor.” The room tilted around me, small and bright. “I ran, Nora. I couldn’t stand to look at your face. I ran because I was a coward, and because every time you said his name I wanted to scream, and because I thought you would find out and hate me worse than you hated him.”

I stood up. My knees ached. I walked to the window and looked out at the fog, and the long gray harbor, and I did the thing I always do when something is too large to look at directly. I turned it into sentences.

He did not leave me. He left Wren. He took a knife meant for her and he walked away with it in his side, and he let me believe seven years that I wasn’t worth staying for.

“He could have told me,” I said.

“He said you’d never forgive him for making the choice for you. And he said, And she can survive being left. She can’t survive being the reason her sister goes to prison.”

“That is the stupidest thing I’ve ever heard.”

“I know.”

“He decided what I could bear.”

“He does that,” Wren said. “He’s very good at it. It’s his worst quality.”

I turned from the window. “Why did you let me hate him? For seven years, Wren. I wrote letters for strangers about forgiveness and I couldn’t even say his name in my own kitchen.”

“Because I was twenty-one and I was afraid.” She wiped her eyes. “And because by the time I wasn’t afraid, you were so used to being angry I thought it might be the only thing holding you up.”

That one landed somewhere I did not want to be touched.

“And Boston?” I asked. “That was no accident, was it? A flower shop on Charles Street, and a man who looked at you like a ghost.”

“It was an accident. The first time.” She almost smiled. “The second time, he came back with a plan.”

“A plan.”

“He said Pell would never let him near you. Not openly. Not as long as the forgery hung over my head. But Pell’s a man who respects a wedding. He said a groom has to marry somebody, and a bride has to marry somebody, and if the somebody was a Vale, and the whole town was invited, and Pell could stand in a church and watch it...” She stopped. “I don’t know all of it. I wasn’t supposed to know all of it. He said he’d explain when you’d agreed to write the vows. I only know he needed a reason to put your pen in his hand.”

“A sham engagement.”

“I didn’t say that.”

“You hummed,” I said. “Tuesday. In the car. I love him, you said, and you hummed.”

Wren’s mouth opened, closed. She laid her hand flat on her own throat, as though she might find the sound there and take it out.

“I do love him,” she said. “I love him like a brother. I’m the one who’s lying when I say it the other way.”

“Does he know that?”

“He’s never asked.”

“No,” I said. “He wouldn’t.”

We stood in the wreck of a Thursday morning, two women with the same eyes, in a shop that smelled of lavender and old glue and sick-sweet lilacs, and I thought about my sister’s seven years of silence, and my own seven years of rage, and how neatly the two had fit together, like a lid on a jar.

“Where is he?” I said.

“The pier. He goes every morning. To the Annie.”

“His father’s boat?”

“What’s left of her.” Wren bent and began gathering the pieces of the broken cup, her hands careful, her face turned away. “Nora. Whatever you say to him. Be kinder than he deserves. He’s been so tired for so long.”

I took my coat from the hook. I took my gloves too, because Dot would ask, and I did not want her to be right about anything today.

At the door I looked back. Wren knelt on the floor in her good coat with a handful of shattered china, and she was twenty-one and twenty-eight at the same time, and I did not know how to forgive her yet, but I knew I would.

“Wren,” I said. “The peonies were beautiful.”

She made a small sound, and her shoulders shook.

I went out into the fog. And on the far side of the street, half hidden behind the post office mailbox, tall and still and gray as the weather, a man in a dark sweater stood with his hand in his pocket and his eyes on my face.

He had been there the whole time.