Chapter 4
THE OTHER JULIAN
The Corliss weighed less than she remembered.
Iris lifted it off the easel at six in the morning, with the north window going from black to the color of dishwater, and laid it face down on the padded bench. She had done this ten thousand times with other people's paintings. She wore her cotton gloves. She laid out her tools in their usual row. Her hands knew what to do and did it, while the rest of her stood somewhere far off and watched.
Owen stood by the door and did not come closer. She had not asked him to leave.
The back of the panel was a gray slab of oak, bare and dusty, with three old gallery labels peeling off in layers like sunburn. She had seen it once, in the first week, when she logged the condition report. She had not looked at it since. Why would she? It was the front that needed her.
She went over it now with a raking lamp.
Oak, yes. Seventeenth century, probably. But in the lower right corner the grain changed. A strip about the width of a ruler, set in so tightly that the join was nearly invisible, ran along the bottom edge. The wood there was paler and cleaner. It was cedar. And when she bent close, a smell rose from it, faint as a held breath. Pencil shavings. Cedar and graphite and cold hands.
She stopped.
"He used to keep pencils in a cigar box," she said. She did not know she was speaking aloud. "In his desk drawer. He sharpened them with a penknife. It drove me mad. He'd do it over the wastebasket and miss."
"Posy smelled it," said Owen, very quietly.
"Yes."
"On the first night. She said it was the only thing she remembered." His voice was rough. "Do you think she was standing near the studio?"
"She was always near the studio."
She slid the thin blade of the spatula along the cedar strip. It gave, with a click, like a lid. The whole strip lifted away on a hidden hinge. Inside was a shallow channel, an inch deep, lined with green baize, and in the channel lay three things.
A black notebook, the cheap kind sold at pharmacies. A flash drive, wrapped in a handkerchief. And a photograph, curling at the corners, face down.
She took out the photograph first. She did not know why.
A wooden dock. A gray sea behind it. A tall man in a fisherman's sweater stood with one foot on a coil of rope, laughing at someone off to the side, and beside him a young woman with dark braids held a baby on her hip. The baby was perhaps a year old. He had been caught with his mouth wide open, in the middle of a furious, delighted shout.
The man was Henry Vandermeer. She would have known the long upper lip anywhere. It was the face on the mantel in Eleanor's house, in a silver frame, with a black ribbon across the corner.
She turned it over. On the back, in faded pencil, was written: Ruth and the boy. Lunenburg. August.
Iris looked up.
Owen had gone the color of paper. He had not moved from the door, but his hand had come up, slowly, as if to shield his eyes from a light.
"That's my mother," he said.
They sat on the studio floor with their backs against the cabinet of pigments, a foot apart, with the black notebook between them.
"He came to Lunenburg in nineteen eighty-six," said Owen. "For a conference. He was a young lawyer. He stayed a summer." He turned the photograph in his fingers, carefully, by the edges, as if it might smear. "My mother never told me. She said he was a sailor, lost at sea. I grew up on a dock with a ghost."
"When did you find out?"
"Three years ago. In October." His mouth twisted. "A man knocked on our door at midnight. Thin, tall, hair going gray. He stood on the step with a look I knew from the mirror. He said, Are you Ruth Pike's son? I said I was. He said, I think I'm your brother."
She sat very still.
"He'd found a box of Henry's papers in Eleanor's attic. Letters from my mother. Bank drafts, every month, for thirty-one years, from an account Eleanor kept in her own name." His laugh had no sound in it. "She knew. She'd known since the day I was born. She never once wrote back. She just paid."
"Eleanor paid for you."
"She paid for my silence. I was eleven before I knew we had money that didn't come from the boats." He let out a long breath. "Julian wasn't angry. I thought he would be. He sat in my kitchen, and my mother made him tea, and the two of them looked at each other across the table for an hour. And he said, I'd like to know you, if that's allowed."
"And you let him."
"I'd been waiting my whole life for somebody to say it."
She picked up the notebook.
It was not Julian's usual hand. It was cramped, fast, careful at the beginning and ragged by the end, as though the writer had been losing his grip on the pen. The first page was dated the fourth of September, three years and seven months ago. It began without a greeting.
I have decided to write it all down, in case I don't get the chance to say it.
You may be reading this because I'm gone. Or because I'm a coward and left you holding it. Either way, Ivy, it is the whole of it, and I will not soften anything.
In the first year of the partnership, Graham brought me papers on Fridays. Trust transfers. Distributions to beneficiaries. He said they were routine, and that if I signed them quickly, I could be home for supper. I trusted him. More than that, I wanted to be home. I wanted to be with you. So I signed. Fourteen transfers, in eleven weeks, and I did not read one.
You will say this was not a crime. It was. It is what Graham needed. A partner's signature on forty-one trusts, belonging to forty-one clients, the oldest eighty-nine, the youngest a boy of twelve whose father had died in the war. The money moved into a company called Corliss Holdings. Graham named it for the painting in our conference room. He said it was a joke.
I laughed.
She read for a long time.
It was all there, written out in a plain man's plain words. The dates and the amounts. The names of the clients. The way Julian had discovered it, by accident, on a wet Tuesday in March, when a widow named Mrs. Abernathy rang the office and said her check had bounced. The way he had stood in the corridor with the phone to his ear and felt the floor tilt. Eleven weeks of signatures, and every one of them his.
I could have gone to the police that night. I did not. I went home and I made dinner and I told myself I would think. I thought for eight months.
I want to say it was fear for the firm. It was fear for myself. I was thirty-six years old, with a wife who loved me and a baby on the way, and I had put my name to forty-one thefts. I thought, if I speak now, I'm the one who goes to prison. I thought, let me find a way to fix it quietly. I thought, let me wait until the baby is born.
The page ended. Iris turned it over, and the next was dated the ninth of October, and in the middle of it, in the center of the white paper, was a single line.
Theo was born on a Friday.
She put her hand against her mouth. Beside her, she felt Owen go still.
He lived two days. I held him for most of the second, and I thought, this is what I get. This is the cost. I have been a coward, and the universe has taken the one clean thing I had. And for two days I could not stop thinking, quite coldly, that it was my fault. That I had waited, and a child had paid for it.
It was not true. I know that now. But Ivy, I believed it with every bone in me, and when we buried him, I stood at that grave and promised him I would end it. I would take the notebook and the drive and I would walk into the state attorney's office on the Monday morning, and I would give them everything, and I would take what I deserved.
I did not do it.
I went to Graham first.
I did not know why. I think I wanted him to confess. I thought, if I give him the chance, he'll see the good in it, he'll turn himself in. I walked into his office on the Sunday evening with the photocopies in my bag, and I laid them on his desk. He looked at them for a long time. Then he looked at me, and I saw his face change. It was the face of a man who had been waiting a very long time for someone to find him out, and was only sorry it had been me.
He said, You've been very brave, Julian.
Then he said, Does Iris know?
I understood, in that moment, what he would do. Not to me. To you. To Posy. To Eleanor, who held the largest of the trusts, whose money had gone in the first week. He was not a violent man. He did not need to be. He had every key to every door in our lives.
So I gave him what he wanted. I said I would stay silent. And I walked out of that office and I drove to the lake and I sat in the car until it was dark, and I thought: I can't stay here. I can't be in the house with him knowing, and you not knowing. I can't look at you across the table and say nothing. I can't be the man who signed.
But I could vanish. And if I vanished, he would spend the rest of his life wondering where the copies were.
It was the only weapon I had.
She had stopped breathing. She became aware of it only slowly. A sound had begun in the back of her throat and she could not tell if it was a laugh.
"He left me with it," she said. "He left me with a painting. He knew I'd find it eventually, and he knew I'd take three years."
"He didn't think you'd take three years," said Owen. "He thought you'd flip it over the first week."
"I didn't have a reason to."
"No."
"I never turn them over unless they ask me to."
"He knew that too." Owen's voice broke. "He knew you'd do it exactly right. He said, she'll treat it as if it's the most important painting in the world. And for the whole time she's handling it, nobody will ever have a reason to open it up."
She laughed then. It came out of her cracked and awful, and she folded over her knees, with her gloved hands over her face, and laughed and cried until her ribs hurt. He did not touch her. He sat beside her on the floor, with his head against the cabinet, and let her do it.
When she stopped, the window was gold.
"I don't forgive him," she said.
"I know."
"I want to. I'm going to spend years wanting to. But he made the decision for me. He decided I'd rather be the widow of a coward than the wife of a man who stood in a courtroom." Her throat worked. "He didn't ask."
"No."
"He should have asked."
"Yes," said Owen. "He should have."
She took her gloves off. She laid them neatly on the bench, one over the other. She picked up the flash drive, still wrapped in its handkerchief, with a monogram in the corner that she had embroidered herself.
"Forty-one clients," she said.
"Yes."
"Mrs. Abernathy."
"I looked her up. She's eighty-three. She lives in a care home in Bellhaven." He swallowed. "Graham pays her bills. Out of her own money."
"Of course he does."
There was a knock at the studio door.
Not Eleanor. It was a smaller knock, two soft raps, a child's. Iris was on her feet before she thought, with the handkerchief closed in her fist.
Posy stood in the doorway in her whale pajamas with Mister under one arm. She had a pillow crease across her cheek. She looked at her mother's face, and then at Owen on the floor, and her small chin came up.
"You were talking about Daddy," she said.
"Baby..."
"I heard from the stairs." She walked across the floor in her bare feet. She stopped in front of Owen and tilted her head back, and studied him with the solemn attention she gave to a painting she was not sure she liked. "You're not him."
"No," said Owen.
"You smell like the sea."
"I've lived by it all my life."
"Daddy smelled like pencils." She said it as a statement, without accusation. "You're his..." She frowned. "You look like him. But you're different. You're a different shape."
"I'm his brother," Owen said. He did not look at Iris for permission. He knelt, on both knees, so that his face was level with hers. "I'm your uncle, Posy. I should have told you the first night. I was afraid."
"Why?"
"Because I knew what you would ask."
She waited.
Owen drew a breath. "He died, sweetheart. Your dad. In October, three years ago. I was with him. He wasn't alone, and he wasn't scared, and he talked about you until the end."
For a long moment the little girl did not move.
"I knew," she said.
Iris made a sound.
"I knew he was dead." Posy was looking at Mister. She turned the whale over in her arms, and ran her thumb along the seam where one of his fins had been repaired. "Nobody said. Everybody kept saying away, away, and I thought, that's a lie, because he'd have come. He'd have come for my birthday." She sniffed. "He never missed my birthday."
"No," said Owen. "He never would have."
"Was he in pain?"
"A little. At the end. Not very much."
"Did he say anything?"
He hesitated. Then, quite slowly, he said, "He said to tell you that the second line of the song is the best part. And that you should always sing it first."
Posy's face crumpled.
It crumpled all at once, like paper in a fist, and she dropped Mister on the floor and flung herself against Owen's chest, small and furious and sobbing, and he gathered her in with both arms. He put his cheek against the top of her head. Iris stood with her hand over her mouth. She saw the whale lying on his back on the boards with his one eye staring at the ceiling, and she saw her daughter hold onto this stranger with every ounce of her seven years, and she thought, quite clearly: that is a man who knows how to be held.
"It's okay," Owen was saying, over and over, in a low voice. "It's all right. I've got you. I've got you."
Iris knelt beside them and put her arms around both.
Eleanor Vandermeer came at eight, with no driver.
She came in her own small blue hatchback, which she hadn't driven since her husband's funeral, and she parked it crookedly on the lawn. She walked up the steps without her cane. She was wearing her gray wool coat and a scarf she had knotted wrong, and her hair was not combed, and her eyes were red.
She let herself in. She did not call out. She stood in the front hall, listening, like a woman in a church, and then she followed the sound of voices to the kitchen.
They were all at the table. Iris, with the flash drive in front of her. Owen, with a mug between his hands. Posy, on his left, eating toast with her whale beside her plate. The black notebook lay open on the wood. Eleanor stood in the doorway for a long time, and no one spoke.
"I see," she said.
"Eleanor."
"Don't." She held up a hand. "Let me do it." She crossed the kitchen. She did not look at Iris. She stopped in front of Owen, and he stood up, slowly, with his napkin in his fist, like a boy called to the headmaster. She raised her hand. She laid it flat against his cheek.
"You have his eyes," she said. "I knew the moment you came through the door. Brown, with gold at the rim. I used to look at them across a dinner table for thirty years, and I wanted to scratch them out of his head." Her voice broke. "I have been looking for them in you ever since I let you in."
"Mrs. Vandermeer..."
"Eleanor. Please. It is a great deal later than I thought." She took her hand away. Her fingers shook. "I knew Julian was dead."
Iris stood up so fast the chair fell over.
"I'm sorry. I am so sorry." Eleanor did not turn. "Ruth wrote to me in October. A short letter. Three lines. She said he had gone peacefully, with his brother beside him. She said she thought I should hear it from someone who loved him." Her voice thinned to a thread. "I read it at the breakfast table. I put it in the drawer. And I have sat at that table every morning since, and I have said nothing."
"Why?"
"Because Graham was watching me." She said it flatly. "He is very patient. He has had me followed for three years. He reads my mail. If I had said one word, if I had so much as put on black, he'd have known Julian was out of reach, and he would have come for you. For Posy." Her mouth trembled. "I made a decision. I decided that I would be the woman who did not know. I would be cold and stiff and foolish. And I would keep him guessing."
"You let me think..."
"I let you hope." Her eyes were wet and terrible. "It was the only kindness I could manage. I stood at that little grave on Sundays, and I thought, if I tell her, she will stop writing the letters. And as long as she writes them, Graham thinks Julian is reading."
Iris could not speak.
"I'm sorry," said Eleanor. "Child. I am so sorry."
She did not weep. She only stood there, a straight gray woman in a crooked scarf, with the whole long silence of her life behind her, and held out both hands. After a moment, Posy slipped down from her chair. She walked across the floor and took one of them.
"Grandma," she said. "You've got a button undone."
"Have I?"
"On your coat."
"So I have." She looked down. The corner of her mouth moved. "Well. Thank you, darling. I haven't noticed a button in years."
The phone rang at twenty to ten.
It was Okonkwo. His voice came through low and tired and carefully even, the voice of a man calling from a parked car. "Mrs. Vandermeer. I'm sorry it's early. I wanted to tell you before anyone else."
"The swab."
"The lab rushed it. Three days became thirty hours." A pause. "I'll be plain. It's not your husband."
"I know."
"You know."
"I've known since the porch." She closed her eyes. "Sam. Listen. I have something I need you to see. Not on the phone. Not at the station. I need you to come here, alone, and I need you to leave your cell in the car."
"Why?"
"Because I think there is a man in your department who reports to Graham Pryce."
The silence on the line was long and very still.
"Who?" said Okonkwo.
"The officer in my kitchen."
She turned.
She had walked into the hall without thinking, with the phone against her ear, and she stood now at the foot of the stairs with the front door ten feet away. The door was ajar. Through the gap she could see the porch, and the gray morning, and the back of a police uniform.
Officer Lyle stood with his hat in one hand and his radio in the other. His back was to her. He was speaking in a low, quick voice, and she could not hear the words, only the shape of them. A name. A question. A date. He laughed once, short and humorless, and she saw his shoulders drop in a very particular way.
It was the relief of a man reporting good news.
"Iris?" said Okonkwo, from the phone. "Iris, are you there?"
She had the flash drive in her other hand. She had been carrying it since the studio, closed in her fist, and now she felt the monogrammed edge of the handkerchief bite into her palm. In the kitchen behind her, she heard Posy's laugh, and Eleanor's low voice, and the scrape of a chair.
On the porch, the officer lowered the radio. He settled his hat on his head. He turned around.
He saw her. He saw the phone. His eyes went to her closed hand, and held there.
"Mrs. Vandermeer," said Officer Lyle, with a very gentle smile, and came through the door. "I think you'd better give me that."