Chapter 2
KITCHEN LIGHT
The voice called me Mom, and my body answered before my mind could object.
I was on my feet and through the bathroom door before I had decided anything at all. That is what the ones who have had children will understand. There is a place in you that does not consult you. It hears one word in one pitch, and it moves.
“Eli?” I said. I did not know why I said it, or where the name came from.
The hall was dark. I had the toothbrush in my fist, the little blue one, and my bare feet found the runner by memory and carried me to the second-floor landing. There the stairs curled down into the black. At the top of them hung the frame I had turned to face the wall.
It was facing out again.
I did not stop to look. I did not have the courage. I went down with one hand skating along the banister and my pulse climbing in my ears, and at the bottom, where the hall met the kitchen passage, I saw a line of light under the door.
Gold. Thick and slow, like honey run under a gap.
I put my palm flat on the wood. It was warm, the way a living thing is warm.
I pushed.
The kitchen was empty.
Nobody stood in the doorway in socks. No chair had been drawn out, no cupboard left open. The copper pots hung in their rows and the black range ticked softly to itself and the long scrubbed table sat in the middle of the room under that impossible light.
But the table was set.
Three bowls, steaming, at three places. Two spoons, one big and one small. And at the end, where the bench met the wall, a fourth bowl, a child’s, blue-rimmed and chipped. A little spoon lay beside it. A chair had been pulled back from the table just far enough for someone small to climb in.
The cushion on the seat was dented. Still dented. As if a boy had only that moment gotten down.
I should say what the light did, because I have never found anyone who believed me. It did not feel like light. It felt like being forgiven. I stood there in my nightgown on the threshold, and the warmth came at me across the flagstones, and the ache under my breastbone, which had been gone since the dancing, did not so much stay away as lean toward me, curious, and then lie down.
I took one step in.
And the toothbrush in my hand grew lighter.
It was the oddest sensation. Not a loss. A loosening. The way a heavy suitcase feels when someone takes the other handle. I looked down at it, at the bitten neck and the splayed bristles, and I thought, with great sweetness, that it did not matter. That it was only a toothbrush. That I could set it down on the table beside the bowls, just there, next to the little spoon, and be done.
I had my hand halfway out before the old voice in me said, very clearly, in the Walter Quill tone, Mind what you put down.
I jerked my arm back like a woman snatching a hand from a stove.
“No,” I said.
The light went on glowing. The range ticked. The bread on the board beside the sink gave a small, contented sigh of steam.
“Mom.”
It came from under the table. I knew it did. I did not look. It was a very small voice, very reasonable, a child’s voice with the smallest rasp in it, as if it had been crying earlier in the day and stopped.
“You can put it down,” it said. “It’s okay. It doesn’t hurt anymore.”
I want you to understand that this was the worst thing it could possibly have said.
Because it was true. That was the horror. In the whole house there was no hook, no teeth, no cold hand on the back of my neck. There was only a warm room and a hot supper and a child’s voice telling me the pain was over. And I wanted it. God forgive me, I wanted it more than I have ever wanted anything. I stood there in the doorway with my whole body leaning forward like a plant toward a window.
“Who are you?” I said.
“I’m the one who stays.”
“That isn’t a name.”
A pause. The light gave a very small tremor, like a held breath, and I knew I had said something it had not planned for.
“Why do you keep asking?” the voice said, a little sadly. “You were so happy.”
I backed out of the kitchen.
I backed out the way you leave a room where something is asleep. One step. Another. The toothbrush crushed in my hand, my shoulders against the doorframe, the gold light pooling around my ankles like warm water and then letting go. When my heel touched the cold boards of the passage, the weight came back. All of it, all at once, the whole stone, settling into its old place under my ribs with a kind of dreadful tenderness.
I cannot tell you how it felt to have it back. It hurt so much I nearly cried out. And I held on to it, God help me, as if it were a child.
The door swung shut on its own. It made no sound at all.
Daniel was not in our bed.
I found that out after I had stood in the hall with my forehead against the wall for I don’t know how long. The master bedroom was at the end of the second-floor corridor, a high room with a blue ceiling and a four-poster we had assembled that afternoon with an Allen key and a great deal of bad language. The covers were turned back. The pillow on his side was cold.
I found him in the library.
The house had a library, of course. Of course it did. A square room off the landing, two stories of shelves under a ceiling of painted stars, a leather armchair drawn up to a fire that nobody had lit. He sat in that chair with a photograph album open on his knee and a mug of tea in one hand. His cardigan was buttoned wrong. He looked up when I came in, and he smiled.
It was the sweetest smile I had seen on him in two years. That is what undid me.
“Hey,” he said. “You’re up.”
“Daniel, what are you doing?”
“Couldn’t sleep. Then I could, and I didn’t want to waste it.” He lifted the album slightly. “I’ve been looking at us. Isn’t it funny? I keep expecting to feel something. I don’t, really. It’s just very nice. We look so happy.”
I crossed the room. I did not take my eyes off him. His hands were steady. His eyes were clear. He looked rested, almost young, like a man coming back from a long voyage to find his own front door still standing.
“Daniel. Look at me. Do you remember why we left Portland?”
“Sure.” He thought. “Because of the mortgage. And the school. And...” He stopped, and a small crease appeared between his brows. “Because of something. Huh. That’s strange. It’s right on the tip of my tongue.”
“Look at this.”
I held out the toothbrush.
He looked. I watched him look, and I will carry the next three seconds with me until I die.
The smile did not fall. It simply stopped, as if somebody had taken hold of the edge of his face. His eyes went to the dinosaur on the handle, the green crooked dinosaur with the bitten neck, and his lips parted. His whole body leaned forward a fraction, exactly as mine had, toward a window.
“That’s...” His voice was very quiet. “Clara, where did you find that?”
“In the bathroom wastebasket.”
“That’s...” His throat worked. A tear slid from his left eye into his beard, and his hand shook so hard the tea slopped over the rim of the mug. “That’s not ours. We don’t have a kid that small.”
“Daniel.”
“We don’t.”
“Turn it over.”
He did not want to. I saw that. He held the thing like a man holding a live wire, and at last, very slowly, he turned it. Along the back of the handle, in a child’s careful capitals, in permanent marker long faded to the color of dishwater, two letters.
E.B.
Daniel read them. I watched him read them. I saw the whole room come up in his face, the kitchen of the old house and a lake with its edges gone silver and a yellow raincoat on a gravel path. Then a hand moved behind his eyes like a hand wiping a window, and all of it was gone. The tears dried on his cheeks. His face smoothed out.
“Strange,” he said, brightly. “Somebody must have left it. Do you want some tea?”
“Daniel.”
“The tea’s good.” He shut the album. “I think I’ll go to bed. Don’t you feel better, Clara? I feel better.”
He kissed my forehead as he passed. He smelled of bread and warm wool, and he went out of the library humming something tuneless, and I stood alone in the painted stars with a child’s toothbrush in my fist and a name I did not have.
E.
I climbed the third-floor stairs on my hands and knees for the last four steps. I do not remember deciding to.
The light was on in Junie’s room. It always was. She sat on the green window seat with her knees drawn up and a shoebox at her feet, and the moon through the old glass turned her face the color of the sea. She had been waiting. I knew that the moment I saw her. She did not look surprised.
“You found something,” she said.
I sat on the floor beside her. It seemed to be the only thing my legs could do. I held up the toothbrush, and Junie looked at it, and her chin trembled once and went still, and she reached out with one finger, not touching, only hovering, the way you reach toward a sleeping animal.
“It’s his,” she said. “He hates that one. He says the dinosaur’s too scary. He uses it anyway because Dad bought it.”
“Whose?”
“Mom.”
“Junie, I don’t...” My voice cracked in half. “I can’t hold on to it. Every time I get close to it, it goes.”
“I know.”
“How do you...”
“I don’t forget it.” She said it so plainly that something turned over in me. “I don’t know why. I don’t. I keep trying to, because you and Dad are so much happier, and then it comes back worse. It hurts all the time.” She dragged up her sleeve. “So I do this.”
There was writing on her arm.
It ran from wrist to elbow in thick black marker, in her own blunt capitals. Three letters.
E L I
They were already fading. I watched it happen. The ink had been dry for hours, I could see that, and still the lines were going soft and gray at the edges, as though rain were falling on them in a room with no weather. The L thinned and blurred. A smudge crept over the I.
Junie grabbed the marker from the shoebox and went over it again, hard, her tongue between her teeth, her fingers shaking so badly that the letters came out crooked.
“I do it every hour,” she whispered. “In the morning, it’s gone. Even the dark ones. Even the ones I pressed into my skin until they bled.”
“Eli.”
I said it out loud.
I did not mean to. It rose out of me on its own, and for one clean, shining second the room went absolutely still. The moonlight held. The wind outside caught its breath.
And then it hit me.
I have never been struck by anything like it, before or since. Not grief. Grief had been a long gray winter. This was the thing that grief grows out of, the root and the hook, a blow so total that I folded forward over my own knees. A small hand in mine. A cowlick in the sun. The weight of a boy asleep against my shoulder in the back of a car. The lake. The lake. My mouth opened and no sound came, and I pressed my forehead against the cold floorboards, and wept like a woman drowning on dry land.
Junie put both arms around my neck.
“There,” she said, fiercely, into my hair. “There. That’s him. Hold on. Hold on to it, Mom, please, hold on.”
I held on.
I held on for what must have been a minute. I had him, whole and shining and terrible, my son, my seven-year-old, my Eli, the one I looked away from for four minutes while he went down to the water in his yellow raincoat. I held on with everything I had.
Then the clock on Junie’s mantel struck three, and the grip of it began, gently, to slip.
I felt it go. It was like trying to hold water in a closed hand. A thread of the memory, then another, drawn out through the gaps in my fingers. His face went first. Then his voice. Then the name itself, spooling out of my head like silk out of a spindle, and I said it again, “Eli, Eli, Eli,” faster, louder, desperate, and I could hear it turning into sound.
Junie was crying. “Don’t let it. Don’t let it, Mom.”
“I’m trying.”
“Say it again.”
“Eli.”
It meant nothing. It was a word. It was two syllables, a pleasant, ordinary name, and I could not think why it should make my eyes sting.
Junie let me go. She sat back on her heels, in the light of the lamp, and looked at me with a face I had never seen on a child. It was not despair. Despair is soft. This was a kind of terrible patience, a face that had already lost a great many nights like this one and was going to lose a great many more.
“It’s okay,” she said. “You got closer this time. You said it twice.”
“Junie, who...”
“Don’t go in the kitchen light again.” She was already uncapping the marker. “It feels good. That’s how it gets you.”
I walked down the third-floor stairs like a woman wading through a river.
I did not go to bed. I went instead to the second-floor landing, where the staircase turned, and stood in front of the photograph in its tea-colored frame, which had been turned back to face the room. The lamp I had left on the newel post made a small pool of yellow on the wall.
I looked at the four of us on the dune.
Daniel in his green jacket. Junie, squinting. Me, laughing, thinner than I am now.
The boy was gone.
There was not even a blank space. The picture had closed over the place where he had been, as water closes over a stone, the dune grass and the pale sky continuing on without a seam. Only my hand had not changed. In the photograph, my right hand hung curled at my side, fingers bent around nothing, held out at exactly the height of a seven-year-old’s head.
I put my own hand beside it. The same curve. The same shape of a small warm palm.
And on the inside of the glass, at the very bottom of the frame, I saw a mark that had not been there before. It was small. It was damp. It was five tiny fingertips pressed flat against the pane, as if someone had stood on his toes behind the picture and was trying, very gently, to get my attention.