Chapter 3
TWO SETS OF VOWS
Celeste Ashworth did not sit until she had straightened the pencil cup.
Nora watched it happen from the other side of the counter. It was a small thing, a half inch of adjustment, the way someone might nudge a picture frame in a stranger’s house. Then the brass stapler, squared to the edge. Then a stack of unsold greeting cards, tapped level with two gloved fingers.
“I’m so sorry for the hour,” Celeste said. Her voice was lovely and perfectly clear and faintly cold, like glass held up to the light. “I couldn’t sleep. I thought if I waited for business hours, I’d talk myself out of it.”
“Out of what?”
“This.” A gesture that took in the shop, the desk, the coffee, Nora’s face, the creased skin under Nora’s eyes. “I’m told I should be intimidated by you. I’m trying very hard, and I find I’m only curious.”
Theo had come in through the back door at the exact moment Celeste crossed the threshold. He now stood frozen by the ribbon wall holding a pack of wax seals he was pretending to count. One sock was sunflowers. The other was a tiny pizza. He had never, in the six years Nora had known him, looked so thoroughly like a man trying to be furniture.
“Theo,” Nora said, “could you make Miss Ashworth some tea?”
“I would love to,” said Theo, with unconvincing warmth, “do that. In another room.”
He fled.
Celeste’s smile was small and amused. She took the chair across from the desk and set her white umbrella against her knee. “He’s protective of you.”
“He’s nosy.”
“Those can be the same thing.”
Nora sat. She hid her hands in her lap, because the edge of the desk was calling her fingers and she refused to let this woman watch her fidget. Up close, Celeste Ashworth was prettier than the photographs in the society pages, and that was a quiet kind of cruelty. Pale lashes. A mole beneath her left ear. A lipstick the exact shade of a rose that had been told to behave.
“My fiancé,” said Celeste, “came to see you on Friday.”
Nora said nothing.
“He told me he’d admired your work. He does not usually admire things. Dane likes things in the way a man likes weather. He’s glad they exist and doesn’t plan to carry an umbrella.” A breath. “When he came home, he stood in the doorway of the kitchen for twenty minutes without turning on the light.”
“That sounds like a conversation you should have with him.”
“I did. He said it was nothing.” Celeste lifted her eyes. They were a pale green, steady as a pond. “He tapped his wrist when he said it.”
Something small and cold turned over in Nora’s stomach.
“I know who you are, Miss Bellamy.”
“Do you.”
“I’ve known for months.” Celeste smoothed a glove. “Dane talks in his sleep. Not often. Not much. But there is a woman in one of his dreams, and she wears a yellow dress, and he says her name the way people say the name of a place they can’t go home to. I assumed it was a ghost.” A pause. “Then in August I found a photograph in his father’s study. A girl on the steps of a courthouse, holding daisies. Written on the back, in a hand I did not recognize, was a date and the word resolved.”
“Resolved.”
“I thought that was an interesting word to use for a girl.”
The room was very quiet. Out on the street, a delivery truck rattled over the cobblestones and a pigeon clattered off the awning. Nora realized she had stopped breathing, and made herself start again.
“What do you want?” she said.
“Vows,” said Celeste.
“I’m sorry?”
“I’d like to hire you.” Celeste folded her hands. “Not instead of Dane. In addition to Dane. I want you to write mine.”
Nora looked at her.
“That’s not how this works.”
“Isn’t it? You write for a hundred people a year. Two sides of the same wedding is hardly unusual. I’m told you did it once in Beaufort, a couple who didn’t know.”
“Those people didn’t know each other’s hearts.”
“Neither do we,” said Celeste, quite pleasantly, “so I suspect we’ll fit right in.”
It should have been funny. For a moment Nora almost laughed. Instead she saw the thing underneath, small and hard, a pulse in the pale throat as Celeste swallowed. The poised woman was working very, very hard, in the way a swan works under the water.
“Let me understand,” Nora said carefully. “You know who I am. You know Dane has a history with me. And you want me to write the words you’ll say as you marry him.”
“Yes.”
“Why?”
“Because I’d like to know what a person sounds like when she’s telling the truth.” Celeste’s eyes did not waver. “I’ve spent my life learning how to sound sincere. I’m excellent at it. It would be a novelty to hear it written down by someone who is not.”
“I’m not sure I’m that person.”
“I think you are exactly that person.” Quietly: “I read the Charleston vow. The one about the porch light. I cried in a coffee shop, and I do not cry in coffee shops.”
Nora heard herself say, very low, “That wasn’t about you.”
“No. It never is, is it?” Celeste tilted her head. “That is the entire gift. A good vow isn’t about the bride. It’s about the world she’s afraid of losing.”
It was the single most perceptive thing anyone had ever said about her work. Nora felt it land in her chest and stay there like a swallowed stone.
She did what she always did when something got too close. She reached for the pen.
“My fee is high.”
“I’d assumed.”
“It’s double for a client who’s lying to me.”
Celeste’s lashes moved. “And am I?”
“I don’t know yet.” Nora clicked the pen. “But you’re not here because you’re curious. People with money don’t wake up at dawn to be curious.”
For the first time, something genuinely shifted in the polished face. A flicker of the real thing, brief and bright.
“My family,” said Celeste, “is not what it appears.”
“Neither is yours,” said Nora, and Celeste gave a short laugh like a cracked cup.
“No. I suppose it isn’t.” She looked at her gloves. “I’ll be direct, since you seem to prefer it. The Ashworth name is a very large house with a very small foundation. I’m marrying into Calloway Hospitality because that is what keeps the roof up. I know what I am to Walter. I’m a transaction with a good posture.” She said it without self-pity, the way a woman reads out an inventory. “What I’d like, before it happens, is for one person to write down what I might say if I were allowed to say anything. Even if I never do.”
The brass stapler sat between them, perfectly squared.
Nora should have said no. She knew it with the cold clarity of a woman about to step off a curb into traffic. Two sets of vows. Two people, one wedding, and herself in the middle with a pen. She could hear Mags in her head, saying something about fire and kerosene.
“I’ll think about it,” she said.
“Of course.” Celeste rose and gathered her umbrella. At the door she paused, one hand on the glass. “Miss Bellamy. One more thing, so you don’t hear it from someone worse.”
“Yes?”
“Dane has asked me twice to postpone.” The gloved hand pressed flat against the door. “Once in September. Once on Friday night. I said no both times. I’d like you to know that I did not do it out of cruelty.”
“Then why?”
“Because if I let it slip,” said Celeste Ashworth, “I will never be brave enough to do it again.”
The bell chimed. She was gone.
Theo reappeared with a tray and three cups of tea and an expression of staggering innocence. “Was that the part where I come back in?”
“You listened.”
“I listened through a very thin door with the water running.” He set the tray down. “She cried at your porch light vow, Nor. I’d like it noted that this makes it harder to hate her.”
“Noted.”
“And I’d like it noted that this changes nothing about my hating her.”
“Noted.”
Nora drank the tea. She did not taste it. All day she wrote nothing, answered customers like a person underwater, watched the clock crawl through the afternoon. On Sunday, she did not open the shop. On Sunday night she took the cream envelope out of her coat and set it on her kitchen table and looked at it until the candle burned low.
She was still sitting there at nine o’clock on Monday evening, when the bell over the shop door downstairs rang once, softly, exactly as it had on Friday.
She went down in her socks.
Dane stood just inside the door, with rain on his shoulders and no umbrella. He looked as if he had not slept since she last saw him. He looked as if he’d walked here from somewhere very far away.
“You said Monday,” Nora said.
“I did.”
“I didn’t think you’d actually come.”
“I didn’t think I’d be allowed.” He glanced at her feet, the gray wool socks, and something in his mouth went helpless. “Nora. I need to tell you something before you say anything else.”
She folded her arms. “That depends on what it is.”
“I lied to you on Friday.”
The two fingers, she noticed. They were not tapping. They were pressed hard and flat against his wrist, holding the pulse down.
“Which part?” she said.
“I told you I kept the letter.” His voice was very low and very steady, and it cost him; she could see what it cost. “I didn’t. My father did. He kept it eleven years in a locked drawer, and I found it in August, the week before I proposed to Celeste.” A breath. “I didn’t open the seal. I swear on anything you like. I don’t know who did, or when, or why.”
Nora stared at him.
The rain fell. The little glass sailboat caught the streetlight on the desk behind her.
“Why tell me now?”
“Because you found the second page.” He nodded toward her coat, where she had, without realizing it, put her hand over the pocket. “And you’ve already talked to your grandmother. I can see it on your face. And I would rather you hear this from me than think the lie was the last one.”
“What else did you lie about?”
For a long moment he did not answer.
Then Dane Calloway, thirty-four years old, a man who picked his words like they cost money, took one step toward her across the lamplit floor. And he said, so quietly she almost lost it beneath the rain:
“The part about the car.”