Chapter 18
RESOLVED
Celeste had laid the photographs out on the dining table in neat rows, and that was how Nora knew things were bad.
She had come to the door in her coat, as if she had been about to leave and had forgotten where to. Behind her the townhouse was lit in every window. The pearl-colored hall smelled of lemon oil and cold tea. Dane stood at Nora’s shoulder with Theo’s yardstick under his arm, because Theo had pressed it on him at the door of the shop and said, “For emotional support.”
“You came,” said Celeste.
“You said before Walter hears.”
“Yes. I’m told I have about an hour.” She stepped back. “Please don’t straighten anything. I’ve done that for both of us.”
The dining room had been cleared of its centerpiece. Under the chandelier lay thirty-eight rectangles of glossy paper, arranged by date in six tidy lines. Every one was face up. Every one had a small neat word written on the border in a hand that leaned very slightly backward, like a man bowing.
Resolved.
Nora’s eyes went along the first row without wanting to. A man on a loading dock, laughing at something off frame. A woman at the gate of a school, holding the hand of a child with a bright red backpack. A priest on a bench with his face in his hands. A girl of twenty on a set of courthouse steps, in a thrift store dress, holding a bunch of grocery store daisies.
She stopped. It was her own face, caught in profile, hopeful as a lit window.
“That’s the one I found in August,” Celeste said quietly. “There were thirty-seven others in the drawer under it. I counted them last night, three times, in the bath.”
“How did you get in?” said Dane.
“I walked.” She smiled, thin and unsteady. “Your father was at the bank board until four. Mrs. Mallory let me in because I am the fiancée, and she’s been dying to tell someone she never liked the portrait. I went upstairs. The drawer was locked, so I took the letter opener from the desk and I forced it.” She held up her right hand. A thin red line ran across the heel of her palm. “I’ve never broken anything in my life but a vase. It’s much louder than you’d think.”
“Celeste.”
“I took all of them. I took the little notebook beside them, with the names and the dates. I put the lock back as well as I could. I’m sure he’ll see it by morning.” She drew a breath. “That’s the unforgivable thing. I’d like you to hear me say it. I stole from the man who feeds my family, and I’m going to give what I stole to a policeman.”
“That isn’t unforgivable,” said Dane.
“My father will say it is.”
“Your father,” said Nora slowly, “is in this row.”
She had found him. Third line, fourth from the left. A heavy man in a good suit at a card table in a private room, a stack of chips in front of him, a cashier’s check under his hand. A date three years back. And in the margin, one word.
Resolved.
Celeste did not look at it. She looked at the chandelier.
“The first note was a gambling debt,” she said. “I always thought that was my father’s own disaster. He has been a fool all my life, but a gentle one. It turns out the room was Walter’s. The dealer was Walter’s. The check was Walter’s, written out in my father’s name and signed by him very late on a Sunday night, and then, in a very kind and very patient way, Walter was sorry about it.” Her voice went flat and precise. “He didn’t buy my family’s ruin, Dane. He farmed it.”
Nobody spoke.
Dane walked slowly down the row. His coat hung off one shoulder. He looked at a man in a hospital corridor, a woman with a suitcase in a train station, a boy of maybe seven asleep in a hospital bed with a tube taped to the back of his hand. At the end of the third line he stopped.
It was a photograph of a young man on a bench in an airport, asleep with his head against a pillar, one arm flung over a canvas bag.
“That’s me,” he said.
“Atlanta. The twelfth of November.” Celeste’s voice had gone very gentle. “He kept you in the drawer too.”
Dane touched the edge of it with one finger. He did not pick it up. He looked at his own sleeping face for a long time, and Nora saw his two fingers go to his wrist, and press, and then, deliberately, lift away.
“I look about twelve,” he said.
“You look tired.”
“Same thing.”
Nora had moved on to the last row. It was a short row, only four photographs, and the first three were ordinary and terrible. The fourth lay by itself at the end, and it made the skin on her arms go tight.
A woman in a headscarf and a coat too big for her. She stood in a doorway, one hand on the frame like the rail of a ship, with a ribbon wall behind her, out of focus, a bright wash of color. It was the front of Bellamy and Daughter. It was shot from across the street, at an angle, through the window of a car.
The date was the twelfth day.
And the word on the border was not Resolved.
It was Unresolved, underlined twice.
“He knew she came,” Nora said.
“He’s known for eleven years.” Celeste had come to stand beside her. “It’s the only one in the drawer he never closed. The ink is different. He’s written the word over and over, I think. You can see where it’s gone through.”
“Why?”
“I don’t know. I thought you might.”
Nora looked at the little figure in the headscarf. She thought of a green Parker pen, and a slip of paper folded in three, and a dying woman saying I understand to a girl she could not see. Eleanor had come to Bull Street to give a message. Walter had watched her do it. And for eleven years he had kept the only picture he could not bring himself to file.
“Because he loved her,” she said slowly, “and she got out.”
Dane turned his head.
“I’m not saying it excuses anything.”
“I know.”
“I’m saying a man like that doesn’t keep a photograph face up for eleven years because he’s winning.”
The clock on the mantel struck midnight. Celeste flinched at the first chime, and Nora noticed that her hand had gone to the empty place on her finger where the ring had been. She was rubbing it with her thumb, over and over, like a woman worrying a stone.
“I’ve written to the Savannah paper,” Celeste said. “It’s in my drafts. I haven’t sent it. I wanted to ask you first, because the second photograph in the third row is of a man whose son is, as far as I know, the only reason the Calloway trucks run on time.”
“Hobbs,” said Dane.
“Hobbs.” She nodded at the sleeping boy in the hospital bed. “That’s his. Walter paid for his treatment. Walter has the hospital’s lien. Walter has, I suppose, a very good reason to have a man in narrow gray shoes do whatever he’s asked.”
Nora felt something cold run down her back.
“The cufflinks,” she said. “He took them because of that.”
“I would imagine he took them for the child.”
The doorbell rang.
It was a short, flat, polite sound, one press, not two. All three of them turned toward the hall. Celeste’s face went to marble. Dane set down the photograph very carefully and slid the yardstick from under his arm, and held it before him like a man with a sword who has never in his life used one.
“He couldn’t have,” said Celeste. “Not already.”
“It isn’t Walter,” said Nora. “Walter wouldn’t ring.”
She went to the door. She did not know why she was the one. Her legs just took her, the way they had taken her up twenty-four steps.
On the porch, under the yellow lamp, stood a stooped, gray-haired man of about fifty, holding a chauffeur’s cap in both hands. His coat was buttoned wrong. His eyes were red. On his feet, planted very carefully on the mat, was a pair of very narrow gray shoes.
“Miss Bellamy,” said Mr. Hobbs. “I understand there’s a warrant out for me.”
“There is.”
“Good.” His voice broke in the middle of the word. “I’d like to be arrested, please. But first I need to know whether Miss Ashworth has a photograph of my Tommy, because I would very much like to see his face before they take me away.”