Chapter 5
The Report in the Drawer
Eli recognised the angle of the photograph before he read the message.
“Third floor,” he said. “Empty flat over the boiler room. You can see the cracked edge of the window in the corner.”
Nora enlarged the picture. A dark triangle cut across the upper left edge. A window frame, perhaps. She had been looking only at herself, at how exposed she was beneath a sky she had mistaken for empty.
“Who has access?”
“The contractor. The survey team. Me.”
Rose had gone very still beside the cassette player.
Nora put the phone down. “I'm saving it. Not replying.”
“They'll know you saw,” Rose said.
“They already know I went in.”
She asked Rose whether she wanted someone called. A friend. A doctor she trusted. Rose shook her head at each suggestion, until Nora stopped listing strangers in the shape of help.
“Would you like me to stay?”
“Until you leave,” Rose said.
It was not an answer that could be argued with.
They sat while Eli checked the landing and returned to report that it was empty. Nora kept the lower lock open and let Rose decide about the upper one. Rose turned it, tested the thumb piece twice, then put the key in her trouser pocket.
Only when Nora had written her number in large letters beside the telephone did Rose let them go.
In the courtyard, Eli said, “There's something at my dad's.”
Nora faced him. “Something you thought I knew?”
“No. Something I should have told you before now.”
She waited with her hands inside her coat, keeping them from doing anything she would regret.
“He has copies of case papers. Old things he brought home. I found Iris's name when I was clearing his spare room last winter.”
“You found my sister in a drawer and didn't ring me.”
“I found an envelope. I didn't open it.”
“You could have rung.”
“Yes.”
His agreement offered her nothing to push against. She wanted a defence she could take apart. He stood there holding his own failure without trying to make it lighter.
“We're going now,” she said.
Arthur Mercer lived in a bungalow above the harbour, behind a hedge cut so level it looked measured with a spirit rule. The garden gate had a new keypad. Nora noticed it before anything else. Eli entered the code with his shoulder between her and the numbers, then glanced at her and looked ashamed of the reflex.
“Work habit,” she said.
“His, not mine.”
Arthur opened the door wearing slippers and a cardigan buttoned incorrectly. For a moment he seemed merely old. Then he saw Nora and his face recovered the attentive blankness she remembered from the station.
“Nora. I'm sorry about Ruth.”
“Were you sorry when she was alive?”
Eli closed the gate behind them. Arthur looked toward the street before stepping aside.
Inside, the bungalow smelled of furniture polish and overcooked cabbage. Two framed commendations hung beside a photograph of Eli's mother. Nora had forgotten how much he resembled her, the shape of the mouth especially. Arthur watched Nora notice the photograph and seemed to expect it might improve her manners.
It did not.
“I want the papers about Iris.”
“I don't know what you mean.”
Eli set his van keys on the hall table. “The envelope in the blue cabinet. Bottom drawer.”
Arthur's eyes moved to his son.
“Those are private.”
“Whose privacy?” Nora asked.
“Old working notes. You could misunderstand them.”
“Then you'll be here to explain.”
Arthur led them into the small room overlooking the garden. The blue cabinet stood beneath a desk with an unused computer on it. He took a key from a hook inside the wardrobe. Nora watched him unlock the bottom drawer and resisted the absurd urge to evaluate his technique.
The envelope was thick and soft at the corners. Iris's surname appeared in black capitals, followed by a reference number.
Nora sat before her knees could make the decision for her.
Arthur kept the envelope in his hand. “This isn't an official file.”
“Good,” she said. “Then you won't mind me asking for the official one too.”
He laid it on the desk.
The first page was familiar. Nora had received a copy at twenty one, after her third request. Iris Vale, nineteen, last seen Tuesday evening, personal belongings absent, possible intention to travel. She remembered reading possible as probable because everyone around her seemed certain.
Underneath was a carbon copy of a handwritten incident sheet.
Thursday, 10.35. Ruth Vale attended reporting daughter not returned from employment. Last contact Monday. States daughter concerned employer altering personal details. Requests welfare check Hartwell House.
Nora read the sentence twice.
“You had the address.”
Arthur moved a paperweight on the desk. It held down nothing.
“We made enquiries.”
“Where's the welfare check?”
“Not every conversation went on a form.”
“Where's this sentence in the final report?”
Arthur looked toward Eli. His son had remained standing by the window, arms at his sides. Whatever help Arthur expected was not waiting there.
“There were concerns about reliability,” Arthur said.
“Whose?”
“Your mother's account. She was upset.”
Nora felt herself smile. It was an awful, involuntary thing. “I imagine she was.”
“Nora.”
“Don't say my name like you knew me.”
The room seemed smaller when she said it. Arthur sat on the edge of the desk, then stood again. His slipper heel had folded beneath his foot. He did not fix it.
Nora found a second sheet. A telephone message from a man identified as S. Voss. Iris had left voluntarily, he said. She had been overpaid and might wish to avoid questions. No cause for concern. A neat initial in the margin confirmed receipt.
She remembered the phrase about money from the first article in the local paper. It had appeared near the bottom, after Iris's height and the colour of her coat. No one quoted a source. At school the next morning, someone asked whether her sister was a thief. Nora had pushed the boy against a bank of lockers and received a week's detention. Ruth signed the letter without asking why.
Now Nora could see where the question had begun. Not with a child who wanted to be cruel. Here, on a message sheet, where an adult had chosen which account deserved to travel.
“Did this go to the newspaper?” she asked.
“There was a press office.”
“That's not what I asked.”
Arthur looked at the paper for a long time. “I briefed them. I shouldn't have included the allegation. It hadn't been established.”
Nora photographed the sheet before she spoke again. She needed a task between what he said and what she might say back. The phone made a soft artificial shutter noise, absurdly cheerful in that room.
“It stayed established at school,” she told him. “For years.”
Arthur lowered his head. He had nothing useful left to offer that particular child.
“You believed her employer over her mother.”
“He supplied a signed statement.”
“Did Iris sign it in front of you?”
“No.”
“Did you speak to her?”
Arthur's silence was answer enough.
Eli turned away from the window. “Dad.”
“I wasn't the only officer.”
“You were the one in the room.”
Arthur's mouth moved before he found words. “I had a household. A mortgage. The clinic paid for half the town's charitable work. Voss knew people I couldn't even get on the telephone.”
Nora stared at him. “My sister had a household too.”
He sat down properly then, in the chair beside the cabinet. The paperweight remained where he had moved it, its bright glass trapping a dead looking flower.
“Why keep this?” Nora asked.
“Because I knew it wasn't right.”
“Knowing in a drawer doesn't help anyone.”
He nodded, a small movement that infuriated her more than argument would have. She wondered how many years he had practised admitting just enough in an empty room.
“May I photograph everything?” she asked.
“You won't publish my address.”
“I'm asking to preserve evidence about a missing person. I haven't asked your permission to protect you.”
Arthur rubbed his face. “Yes. Photograph it.”
She did, page by page, including the backs and the envelope. Eli read each sheet after she finished. His breathing changed at the telephone message. He set it down carefully, aligning its edges with the desk as if an untidy movement might release something.
Nora found the final item beneath an expenses form.
It was a small photograph of a harbour locker. Number forty one. Its door stood open. Empty shelves showed through the metal frame.
On the back, Arthur had written a date: the Friday after Iris disappeared.
“You cleared it.”
Arthur closed his eyes.
“What was in it?”
“Copies. Forms. A notebook. I took them to the station.”
“Where are they?”
“I don't know.”
“Who took them from you?”
His eyes opened. “My inspector.”
“Name.”
“Peter Hales. He died four years ago.”
Nora put the photograph on the desk. There was no dramatic music, no slamming door. Just a square of paper where an answer had been, sixteen years before she finally learned to ask for it.
“Why photograph an empty locker?” Eli said.
Arthur looked at his son. “To prove I'd been there.”
“To whom?”
He did not answer.
Nora gathered her phone and the sleeve holding Iris's tape. She had kept it on her lap throughout, without noticing. Before leaving, she wrote down the case reference number, the station, the names on each page. Her hand was steady now. The steadiness frightened her a little.
At the front door Arthur said, “Ruth came back last month.”
Nora turned.
“She wanted me to make a statement. I told her I would think about it.”
“Did you?”
He stared past her toward the hedge.
“Did you think about it?” she asked again.
“Every day.”
“She ran out of days.”
She left him standing inside the doorway.
Eli followed without speaking. At the gate he stopped to press the latch firmly into place, an automatic act of care for a house he suddenly seemed unable to look at.
Nora waited beside the van.
“I don't know what to say,” he told her.
“Then don't say anything about him.”
“All right.”
“You can be angry.”
He looked down at the keys in his palm. “I am.”
“You can love him too.”
His face changed. She regretted the kindness for a moment because it brought them closer, and closeness felt like another thing that might fail to hold.
Arthur tapped on the glass beside his front door.
He held a sheet against it. Nora walked back far enough to read it through the pane.
The typed heading was a company name: Hartwell Property and Care Holdings.
Below it, a handwritten instruction directed Arthur to deliver the locker contents to a named recipient.
Not Inspector Hales.
Simon Voss.