Chapter 7
THE MAN WITH MY CHIN
Eli crossed the cellar in three strides.
I did not see him decide. I saw only the canvas of his shirt pull across his back, and then he had my father by the coat front and was walking him backward up the stairs, one step, two, until the old man’s cap fell off and bounced down past my feet. Their faces were inches apart. Daniel did not fight. His hands hung open at his sides, palms out, like a man at a checkpoint.
“Go on,” my father said. His voice was hoarse and very quiet. “I’d think less of you if you didn’t.”
“Eli,” I said.
His right fist drew back. I saw every tendon in his forearm. I saw my father close his eyes.
“Eli.”
The fist stayed there, trembling, for a long time.
Then he opened it. He let go of the coat the way you let go of a thing that has burned you, all at once, and stepped back so fast he hit the rope rail. Daniel caught the wall to keep from falling. A cough shook him, deep and wet, and when he lifted his hand from his mouth I saw how thin his wrist was inside the cuff, how the skin had gone the color of old piano keys.
He was not sixty-two. He looked eighty.
“Say it,” Eli said. He was breathing hard. “To my face. Not on a page.”
“I was driving the truck.”
“Say all of it.”
So he said it. Standing there with one hand on the cold brick, in a voice stripped of everything but fact, my father told it. Nineteen hours. The rain like static. The Dunmore mill pull-off where he parked afterward and sat with the engine running for forty minutes, shaking so hard he couldn’t light a cigarette. The woman on the stones. The siren. The walk up the bank.
“She said your name,” he finished. “Twice. I’ve heard it every night since. I don’t expect you to want that. I’d have kept it from you if it were mine to keep.”
“How long?”
“I’m sorry?”
“How long was she alive. After you got her out.”
Daniel looked at him. “Five minutes,” he said. “Perhaps six.”
I watched the number go into Eli like a nail.
“Five minutes,” he said.
“Yes.”
“And you could have. A phone. A flare. Anything. You could have stayed with her. She wasn’t alone, she wasn’t, you were right there, and you chose to.”
“Yes.”
“Why?”
My father said nothing for so long I thought he would not answer. When he did, he said it to the floor. “Because I was a coward. That’s the whole of it, son. I’ve had twenty-five years to find a better word and I haven’t.”
Eli made a sound I had never heard from him, not a word, only breath, torn. He turned and put his forehead against the brick and stayed there with his fists pressed flat on either side, and I went cold with the sudden fear that I would have to watch him break.
Nobody moved. Above us, a gull screamed over the harbor.
“Why did you lock us in?” I asked.
My father’s eyes came to me, and the effect was like being touched. “I came last night to take the box and burn it,” he said. “I saw your light from the road. I thought, she’s here already. I thought if I let you read it first, all of it, I wouldn’t have to watch you read it.” His mouth twisted. “So I turned the key and stood up there for six hours with my hand on it. Six hours. I never could make myself go down.”
“You took the Polaroid.”
“In April I took a picture of the post office. Last week I took one of you. Tessa told me you were coming.” He gave a small, dry exhale, almost a laugh. “I suppose I wanted something that said you had been real. In case I lost my nerve.”
“Tessa,” I said.
“She doesn’t know what I did. She only knows I’m Walt’s friend and I come in April.” He coughed again, longer this time, and sat down heavily on the third step as though his legs had been cut from under him. “I’m dying, Maren. I think you’d already worked that out. Pancreas. They give me till Christmas, and I’ve never trusted a doctor’s arithmetic, but I thought I should believe it enough to stop running.”
I stared at him. I had come into this room armed with twenty-one years of fury, ready to say each sentence I had rehearsed in the shower, and every one of them had gone out of my head like water through a sieve. All that was left was a stranger on a stair with my chin and a cap on the floor.
“The June deposit,” I said.
“That was the last of it. I sold the truck.”
“The trust.”
“It was never about what I owed you.” He lifted his gaze. “It was what I could pay.”
“That is not the same thing.”
“No. It isn’t.”
Eli lifted his forehead from the wall. His face was gray. He did not look at me, and he did not look at the man on the steps. He walked up past Daniel, close enough that his sleeve brushed the old man’s knee, and he stopped on the top step, one hand on the frame of the steel panel.
“I’m going to go,” he said. “I’m going to walk out of this building and I’m going to be somewhere you aren’t, and I’ll come back when I know what I’m going to do. Don’t come after me. Either of you.”
“Eli,” I said.
“I mean it, Maren.”
He went. His boots crossed the pine floor overhead. The front door banged. A few seconds later, an engine caught and tore away down the harbor road, and then there was only the gull and the radiator ticking behind the wall and the sound of two people breathing in a room that had held too much.
“Well,” said my father, after a long silence. “That went about as I deserved.”
I wanted to scream at him. What came out was, “You don’t get to joke.”
“No.”
“You don’t get to be sad, either. You get to be accountable. That’s all you get.”
“I know.”
“Where were you?” My voice cracked down the middle and I didn’t care. “Twenty-one years. I did the crosswords. I did them in pen, like an idiot, because I thought, I don’t even know what I thought. I thought if I never crossed anything out you might look at it and come back.”
He turned his head away. His eyes were wet. I had never once, in thirty-two years, seen my father cry.
“Mostly,” he said, “under a post office.”
I laughed. It was a terrible laugh, helpless, more like a hiccup, and it cost me something to let it out. He looked at me then with a startled sort of hope, and I shut it off like a tap.
“I left,” he said, “because every time I looked at you I saw a little boy in a kitchen with no mother. And I couldn’t be the man who made breakfast for one child while another sat in a cold house on Route 9. I thought leaving was the only honest thing I had left. It wasn’t. It was only the easiest.”
“The easiest thing is still a choice.”
“Yes,” my father said. “It is.”
Upstairs, a door opened. A woman’s voice called, bright and unguarded, “Eli? Your truck’s idling in the lot with the door hanging open, I swear to God, I thought somebody.” The voice dropped. “Hello? Who’s down there?”
A moment later, Tessa Okafor appeared at the top of the stairs, a white paper bag in one hand, her apron under her coat. She took in the cellar, the lamp, the open steel panel, the box, and finally the old man on the third step with his cap on the floor.
“Mr. Hat,” she said.
My father lifted one hand. “Morning, Tessa.”
“Oh, honey.” She came down, set the bag on the cot, and knelt in front of him without hurry, as if she had done it a hundred times, and put two fingers against his wrist. “You skipped your pills.”
“I forgot.”
“You didn’t forget.” She glanced at me, a quick, level look, apology and defiance in equal measure. “Walt asked me to look after him every April. Said he was a friend, said he was ill, said he’d rather nobody asked. I never asked.” She took a paper cup from the bag, a coffee, still hot, and folded my father’s fingers around it. “I figured a man who looked like that was owed a cup of something.”
“Tessa.”
“I didn’t know what he’d done. I swear on my mother. If I’d known, I’d have.” She stopped. “I don’t know what I’d have done.”
“Where did Eli go?” I said.
She looked up. Something in her face went soft and unhappy. “The cemetery, probably. St. Anne’s, up the hill over the harbor. He goes when he’s.” She shook her head. “He goes there when he can’t go anywhere else.”
I took my coat off the cot. It was Eli’s coat, I realized. I had been wearing it all night. I started to shrug it off, and stopped, and left it on.
He had told me not to follow him.
I got as far as the post office steps before I understood that I was not following him. I was going to my van. My hands knew the way: the keys, the seat, the mirror. Dolores’s tire iron lay across the passenger floor next to my overnight bag, and without deciding anything at all, I started the engine.
He doesn’t want you here, said the quiet voice in my head, the old one, the one that had written four letters on a kitchen table and meant them for a husband. Let him have his space. Let everyone have theirs. Handle it from a distance, where nobody can watch you fail.
I drove to the end of Harbor Road. At the stop sign, I turned left.
Not toward the hill. Toward the turnpike.
Ninety-eight miles to Portland, said the green sign at the on-ramp, in clean white letters. My hands were steady on the wheel and my face was dry. I looked, in the mirror, exactly like a woman making a sensible decision.
I put on my signal.
My phone lit on the dash, charged at last, from a coil of yellowed cord I had plugged in without thinking, and buzzed once, twice, against the plastic.
MOM.