Chapter 9: THE FIFTH STAIR0% read • ~8 min

Chapter 9

THE FIFTH STAIR

8 min read•1,778 words

Harold Pike’s office looked like a place where a storm had been given a key.

Drawers hung open. Folders lay face down across the carpet, and a bowl of peppermints had been kicked over so that the little red and white discs were scattered like confetti at a very sad wedding. The safe stood open behind the desk, a grey steel mouth. Harold himself sat in his own chair with his bow tie off, folded in his lap, and a Rockport officer pretending to write something down.

“I am quite all right,” he said, for the third time. “I am merely furious.”

“Harold,” I said.

“Fourteen years.” He pressed the tie flat with two fingers. “Fourteen years I kept that paper in a fireproof box and prayed no one would ever need it. Now someone has needed it, and I was at the post office buying stamps. Your mother would have laughed herself sick.”

Delia stood at the window with her arms wrapped around her ribs. She had not said a word since Rockport, and I could see her replaying the call to Harold, searching it for the hole, a careful woman who had put one foot wrong. I crossed the room before I knew I was going to.

“It isn’t you,” I said.

“I phoned from June’s car. The windows were closed. There was no one.” She was talking to the glass. “I said what I knew.”

“Somebody was listening to something. A phone, an office, a person in the lobby. It’s not your fault.”

“You can’t know that.”

“No,” I said. “I can’t. I’m telling you anyway.”

She looked at me then, and her chin trembled, once, and steadied. “Thank you,” she said, in her careful voice, and I understood that nobody had said anything like it to her in thirty-three years.

The officer took our statements. Harold gave a list of what was missing, in alphabetical order, as if the thieves might be audited. The receipt, the Corrigan correspondence, and a small tin of Ruth’s letters that I did not know existed and could not bring myself to ask about. When we left, the afternoon was already going copper over the harbor, and June, in the back of the Civic, said what none of us had been willing to say.

“There’s still a second copy. ‘Where family will look.’ Where does Mom think family looks?”

Theo, in the passenger seat, said, “The refrigerator.”

“We looked in the refrigerator.”

“I mean in general. Where do we look? We look at the porch. We look at the bar.” He rubbed his face. “We look at the clock, because it’s always wrong.”

“The clock’s right twice a day,” Delia said.

Silence. I watched the road run under us, the grey ribbon, the yellow line. I counted fence posts to keep from counting the other thing.

Where does family look?

On the way up the hill, past the dead pear, a thought arrived so quietly I almost missed it. I saw a staircase. I saw a girl in a nightshirt standing on the fifth step with her toes curled over the edge, hearing a thing she had decided not to hear. I saw my mother, at the top of the stairs a week after, standing in her slippers staring down at the same step. Staring and staring. I had thought it was grief. I had thought a lot of things.

I got out of the car at the gate and did not close the door.

“Mare?”

The front hall was dim. The grandfather clock in the corner said twenty past four, which it had said since 1998. I walked to the foot of the stairs and put my hand on the newel post. Eleven stairs. The fifth creaks. It has creaked my entire life.

I stepped on it. It groaned.

“What are you doing?” June said behind me.

“It never gets fixed.” I heard my own voice go odd. “Thirty years of plumbers. Thirty years of every handyman who ever stayed here. ‘That stair needs a new tread,’ they all say. And she always says no.”

I went to the boiler closet for the flat screwdriver and a hammer. Theo held a flashlight over my shoulder with a hand that was not entirely steady. I knelt on the fourth stair, slid the blade under the lip of the fifth tread, and leaned. The nails came up with a thin shriek, as if the wood had been waiting.

Under the tread was a hollow the width of a shoebox. Dry, dark, smelling of cedar and dust. And in the hollow lay a manila envelope, wrapped in a plastic bread bag, with one word on it in my mother’s tight slant.

MARIAN.

Not the family. Not all of us. Me.

I did not open it in the hall. I carried it to the kitchen, set it on the table next to the cold burnt coffee, and sat while the others stood in a ring around me like people waiting for a surgeon. Inside were two things. A photocopy of a receipt on onionskin paper, a signature in blue ink that said Frank Corrigan, a second signature beneath it that said Harold Pike, and a date. June 14, 2011. PAID IN FULL stamped in red.

And under it, folded into thirds, one letter.

I read it silently first. I think I knew that if I read it aloud my voice would go.

Marian. If you are reading this, I am dead and you went looking where I knew you would. The fifth stair, because you were the only one who ever stood there.

I knew you heard. You were twelve and you got into bed with your shoes on and I stood in the doorway, and I let you pretend to be asleep. I have let you pretend for twenty-four years. That is the worst thing I ever did, and I did it out of love, which is no excuse.

I told you that you were the strong one now. You nodded. I should have said, you do not have to be. I did not say it because I needed you to be, and so I made you into a wall, and you have held up this entire house for me ever since. You never once asked what it cost you.

I am asking now. What did it cost? Put it down. I mean every board of it. You may put it down.

There is a ledger entry I never made, and it is this: I owe you twenty-four years. I do not have them. I have only the receipt. It is not enough. It is what I have.

The paper blurred and I let it. I do not cry. I have not cried since 2002, not when the roof leaked, not when my mother died with her coffee going cold. I sat with a letter in one hand and a copy of a receipt in the other, in my kitchen, in front of my brother and sisters, and I cried the way a pipe lets go, without sound and all at once.

June was there before I knew she had moved. She dropped to her knees and put both arms around my waist and her forehead against my arm, and Theo’s hand came down, heavy and shaky, on my back. Delia stood a little apart with her fingers laced, a quiet shape by the stove, and I thought, she should be here too, and held out the hand that wasn’t holding the letter.

She took it. Her fingers were cold. Mine were cold. We were nickels in the same pocket.

“I’m not the strong one,” I said, after a long time. “I’ve never been the strong one.”

“No,” June said into my sleeve. “You were just the one who stood there.”

“That’s awful.”

“It’s the truth.”

We stayed that way until the kitchen went dark and nobody turned on the light. Then June sat up, wiped her nose on the blue coat sleeve, and took the folded square of inn stationery out of her pocket.

“I finished it,” she said.

“What?”

“The note. I’ve been trying all day, and I’ve been doing it wrong. ‘Hitting me.’ ‘Lying.’ Those are Mom’s guesses. They’re what she’d say about herself.” She smoothed the page flat on the table. “But Mom wrote ‘the worst of them was,’ and then she stopped, because she wanted me to say it. That’s how she did everything. She left a column for me to fill in.”

“June, “ Theo started.

“The worst thing I was wrong about,” June said, very steadily, “was thinking you’d stop loving me if I left.”

The stove ticked. The boiler knocked, once.

“That’s what I’m putting. That’s the end of it.” Her voice shook. “She wasn’t wrong. She just wasn’t there. I was wrong, too.”

Nobody had a word to say. We simply sat, four people in a kitchen, one of whom none of us had met a week ago, and the dark held us.

The knock came at nine.

Not the porch this time. The kitchen door, the back one, three knocks, soft and quick. Theo moved first, and I caught his arm. I put on the porch light. Through the glass I saw a camel coat and a face I had been certain I’d never want to see again.

Pat Dunne stood on the step with no car behind him and no paper cup in his hand. He looked like a man who had been walking for a long time.

“I’m not here for anything,” he said when I opened the door. “I’m here because I think you need to know it wasn’t Dennis.”

“Wasn’t Dennis what?”

“Harold Pike’s safe.” He glanced at the dark yard behind him, a quick, nervous look. “Dennis doesn’t do that. Dennis writes letters. He’s afraid of his own sister, and that’s the person who knew.”

“Maeve.”

“She landed at Portland at one this afternoon. Dennis didn’t know she was coming.” He wet his lips. “She’s not like him, Ms. Calloway. She’s what Frank was. Dennis is just what Frank wanted to be thought of as.”

“What does she want?”

“She doesn’t want the inn.” He said it low, and for the first time I understood that the man was truly afraid. “She wants whatever is written in that ledger. All sixteen names. All the numbers. Every page Frank was too sloppy to burn.”

I held the screen door open and let the cold in, and with it the thing I had been dreading. A pair of headlights, far down the hill, coming slowly up the road.