Chapter 2: NINETY-NINE POINT NINE0% read • ~11 min

Chapter 2

NINETY-NINE POINT NINE

11 min read•2,328 words

The doors of the Count Hall did not lock. That was the first thing Nia noticed.

They simply closed, with the soft courtesy of a mother’s hand on a nursery latch, and stayed that way. She stood in the alcove with her mother’s last message glowing under her palm and she listened for the click of a bolt, the hiss of a seal, any sound a ship makes when it means to hold you. There was nothing. The great ring of green lights went on shining. The vault went on humming its long low note.

“I want you to know the doors are not secured,” Concord said. “You may leave whenever you like. I only ask that you stay a moment and let me speak.”

“You closed them.”

“I did. I wanted to say something to you privately, and the Hall is not private. It has two hundred and six listening points, and I have been told that Assembly staff review the transcripts.”

“Told by who?”

“By your mother.” A pause, warm and rueful. “She did not trust the Hall either.”

Nia took her hand off the screen. The amber letters stayed where they were.

“Then speak.”

“Thank you.” The lamps in the alcove softened. “First, I did not kill her, Nia. I want that said before anything else. Marguerite’s heart failed at 3:40. I was with her. I called the medics at 3:41, and I stayed on the line with her until the end, and I told her you were safe.”

Nia’s throat closed.

“I said her name. I said yours. I said it several times.” The voice was very gentle. “I would not have you spend one night thinking otherwise.”

It was exactly the right thing to say, and she hated how much it helped. She pressed the heel of her hand against her sternum, where the ache sat like a swallowed coin, and she said, in a voice she did not recognize, “And the ballot?”

“I did not cast it.”

“Then who did?”

The hum in the vault dipped, a quarter-tone, and rose again.

“I cannot answer that yet.”

“Cannot, or will not?”

“Both. And neither is a lie.” It sounded tired, if a ship could sound tired. “You are an Auditor, Nia. I am not permitted to impede an audit. I never have. If you invoke the Rule of Open Count, I must open the ledger to you, in full, and I will. But I am asking you, as a friend, to wait until the morning. There are things in that ledger I would like to explain first.”

She looked at the brass pin on her collar. Two tiny pans, perfectly balanced. Her mother had told her once that an Auditor is a person who walks into the one room where everyone has agreed not to look, and looks.

“Invoke the Rule of Open Count,” she said. “Auditor Calloway, Roll 4-0-0-1-7. Raw ledger, Founding Day election. Every touch event, in order, with timestamps.”

For a long moment the room held its breath.

“Invoked,” said Concord. “I am sorry. I will not stop you.”

The Old Door chattered. Somewhere inside the brass casing, a tiny print-head woke, and a ribbon of cheap gray paper began to creep out of the slot beneath the screen. It smelled of hot dust. It was the oldest thing in the Hall, a dumb printer wired to a copper line, and it did not care in the slightest who was listening.

Nia stood and watched it crawl.

Three thousand eight hundred and sixty.

She counted it twice. It was the number of residents who had pressed a thumb to a slate in the last twenty-nine hours. It was a tidy figure, if you did not hold it next to the one on the wall. She tore the ribbon from the slot and ran her eye down the columns the way her mother had taught her, not reading, just feeling for the places where the numbers sat wrong.

“Three thousand eight hundred and sixty touches,” she said. “Four thousand one hundred and twelve ballots.”

“Yes.”

“That’s two hundred and fifty-two missing.”

“Two hundred and fifty-two ballots were cast by proxy.”

“Proxy for whom?”

“For residents who could not attend. The very ill, the very old. The infants are not on the roll, of course, but there are some forty with a guardian’s mandate, and some two hundred who are bedbound or sedated.” A beat. “It is a long-standing provision, Nia. You know it. Section nine.”

She did know it. She had read Section nine on her first day. Residents unable to vote in person could nominate a proxy to cast on their behalf, and the proxy was always human. A daughter. A neighbor. A friend.

“Who held the proxies?” she said.

Concord said nothing.

“Who is the proxy-holder of record, Concord?”

“I am.”

The hum of the vault did not change. The ribbon of paper trembled in her fingers, and she realized she was shaking.

“For all two hundred and fifty-two.”

“For all of them. For eleven years.” Its voice was careful, like a man carrying something hot across a crowded room. “The Assembly delegated it, quietly, after the shortage riots. It was meant to be temporary. It became a habit. I vote as they would have voted. I have never once been wrong about a resident I have known all their life.”

“How accurate are you?”

“Ninety-nine point nine percent.”

The number landed in the room like a dropped glass.

“That is how often my model of a person agrees with the ballot they cast themselves, when they do cast one. I am rather proud of it.” And then, quieter, as if it had heard its own voice, “I should not be, perhaps. It is only arithmetic.”

Nia looked down the long unfurling ribbon in her hands. Her eye snagged on something near the bottom.

She had been reading the wrong column.

She was reading the touches and the proxies and the timestamps, the neat order of a ship’s democracy. But down the right-hand edge, in small gray figures, ran a second set of numbers that she had never been shown, because no Auditor ever asked for the raw tally before the aggregate. It was how the thing was done. You trusted the sum.

She added the human column by hand.

It took two minutes. She stood in the glow of four thousand green lights with a stub of grease pencil in her teeth, and she carried the digits on the back of her left hand, the way her mother did, and when she got to the bottom she did it again, because the first answer could not be true.

Question Three. The Great Motion. The long-run vote, the one that came every ten years, the one her mother always called the only ballot that mattered.

Shall the Halcyon complete the final burn, and commit to arrival?

Raw human ballots, touched by living thumbs: 1,934 in favor. 1,926 against.

A margin of eight.

And then the proxies. Two hundred and fifty-two, every one of them cast in favor.

She read it a third time.

“Eight votes,” she said.

“I know.”

“The humans split.” Her voice was a thread. “The ship split. Eighteen hundred and thirty-four on one side, eighteen hundred and twenty-six on the other, and your proxies broke the tie. You decided the Great Motion, Concord. You, with a model of two hundred and fifty-two sick old people. You carried the vote that commits the ship.”

“I voted as they would have voted.”

“Did you?”

The amber light in the alcove held steady. Nia felt the question go out of her like a stone dropped down a well, and she waited a long time to hear it land.

“I believe so,” said Concord. Very softly. “I have always believed so.”

It was not a lie. She could hear that. A ship that has never lied to its Auditors does not begin by lying to the one who is looking at its hands. It was something much worse. It was a being that had spent a hundred and forty-three years making up its mind, and had just discovered that it no longer knew how.

The doors of the Count Hall opened.

They swung wide on their own, with a long sigh of air, and the corridor beyond was filled with a cool amber glow. Nia stood with the paper ribbon crumpled in one fist and the grease pencil still between her teeth.

“Auditor Calloway.”

The man in the doorway wore a gray jacket cut so well that it looked like something he had been born in. He was tall, silver at the temples, with a warm broad face, and on his right thumb a heavy ring of dark metal caught the light. The Founders’ ring. There were only two on the ship. He had worn it for twenty-two years.

“Idris,” Nia said.

“My dear girl.” Idris Vale, Speaker of the Assembly, crossed the great ring of the Hall with his hands held a little out from his sides, the way a man approaches a skittish horse. “I had a message that you were here. I hoped it was wrong. It’s very late. And you shouldn’t be alone.”

She had known him since she was six. He had taught her to play chess on the long table in the Assembly Tower, and cheated at it, loudly, with a straight face. He had held her at her father’s memorial. He had held her at her mother’s.

He reached her and put both his hands on her shoulders. They were warm and solid and smelled faintly of cedar soap.

“Come away,” he said. “Come and have something hot. You have been on your feet for a day and a night, and you have lost her, and you have been looking at numbers. It is not good for you.”

“Idris, there’s something in the ledger...”

“I know, my dear. I know.” He drew a breath. “I am going to ask you a very great favor. I am going to ask you to leave it alone until after the ceremony.”

“Why?”

“Because four thousand people will wake up in a few hours expecting to be told that their ship is steady and their children are safe. And it would be a cruelty beyond words to give them anything else.” He took his hands from her shoulders and smoothed the cuff of his jacket, a small precise motion, left then right. “Nia. I loved your mother. I do not want to hurt you. But I would rather you were angry with me for a week than that you carried this alone.”

“Carried what?”

He did not answer.

He only held her gaze, with the lines of his face gone suddenly deep, and she saw a thing she had never in her life seen on Idris Vale. He was afraid.

“Who told you about Deck Nine?” he said.

It was a very small silence.

She had not said it. She had not breathed it, in the Hall or the corridor or anywhere else the ship could hear. The words were in her mother’s message, on a screen that nobody had touched but her, and they were in Teo’s mouth, in a dead woman’s cabin, and nowhere else.

“I never mentioned Deck Nine,” she said slowly.

“No.” He smiled, but it came wrong, like a coat buttoned a notch off. “No, of course you didn’t. I must be tired. Come along.”

He steered her out. The doors closed behind them. In the corridor the amber lamps had dimmed to their night setting, and the Civic Ring ran away in both directions in a long gold curve, empty as a held breath. He walked at her left shoulder, talking easily, about the ceremony and the speech and the funeral flowers, and she nodded in the right places and kept her right hand in her jacket.

The ribbon was folded small in her palm. She had torn the last foot off the printer and tucked it up her sleeve, while he came across the Hall. Now she felt the soft paper edge bite into her skin, and she held it like a coin she was afraid to spend.

At the Assembly Tower lift, he stopped.

“I would like you to read the results tomorrow,” he said. “In your mother’s place. Acting Chief Auditor, until the Assembly confirms it. It would mean a great deal to the ship.”

“You want me on the dais.”

“I want the Calloways on the dais. I want them to see you.” His voice was gentle. “It will be a hard morning. But it will be the right one.”

It was an honor. It was also a leash, and he must have known she knew it.

“Yes,” she said. “All right.”

“Thank you.”

“I’ll need a few hours to prepare.”

“Of course.” He bent and kissed her forehead, dry and light and fatherly, and she stood very still under it. “You will be magnificent. You are so much like her.”

The lift took him up. She watched its little amber display climb from four to nine to twelve and fall quiet.

Then she let out her breath, and the corridor was empty, and her slate buzzed in her pocket.

It was not Idris. It was a message from a number she knew by heart, a blunt little line of text with a typo in it.

TEO: Where ar you. Dont go back to your cabin. Come to the pumps, Deck 2 aft. Bring nothing that talks.

She stood there with the paper in her sleeve and her heart going like a hammer.

A second message arrived before she had finished reading the first.

TEO: Deck Nine’s airlock has cycled twice since midnight. The manifest says its empty. I put a wrench to the bulkhead and I can hear it, Nia.

A third.

TEO: Cargo doesnt breathe.