Chapter 1: The Notebook in the Returns Bin0% read • ~14 min

Chapter 1

The Notebook in the Returns Bin

14 min read•3,007 words

The notebook was already half full when Rhea Whitaker found it, and every page was in her own handwriting.

She noticed that second. First she noticed the weight. She had been reaching into the returns bin of the Alder Falls Public Library to drop off a copy of Persuasion four weeks overdue, her fingers sliding across a drift of mystery paperbacks and a single wet umbrella, and something at the bottom had pushed back against her hand. Dense. Warm, almost. It felt like touching the flank of a sleeping animal.

She pulled it out.

A black cloth notebook, the old kind, with a red spine and corners worn soft as felt. No barcode. No call number. In the bottom right corner of the cover, stamped in flaking gold, two letters.

R.W.

Rhea turned it over. There was no price tag. No library stamp. She held it up toward the high window, where the late October light fell in long dusty bars across the stacks, and she told herself that plenty of people had those initials. Rebecca Walsh. Raymond Wu.

She opened it.

Page one was a single paragraph. The ink was blue, the line slanted hard to the right, the g’s looped twice because she had never learned to stop at once. And the sevens in the date at the top were crossed, the way Dev had made fun of since she was nine. Who crosses a seven, Dictionary? Europeans and serial killers.

It was her hand. She would have sworn it on anything.

Rhea. You won’t believe this, so test it. Something small. Then come back and read this part again.

It does what you write. Every word. It always has. It also takes something for it, and you will not see what until it is too late to want it back.

Don’t write Mom’s name.

Please. I am begging you. I know what you are going to want. Don’t.
R.

She read it twice. Then she shut the notebook, very gently, as one closes the door of a room where someone is asleep.

“Miss Whitaker.”

She nearly dropped it.

Mr. Finch stood at the end of the aisle with a stamp in one hand and his spectacles pushed up on his forehead. He was a tall, stooped man in a gray cardigan, with white hair combed carefully over a pale scalp and pencil stubs sticking out of every pocket. He had been head librarian since before her mother was a teenager. He stamped due dates by hand, with a little flourish at the end, as if signing a very small contract.

“Persuasion,” he said gently. “I believe it is a month late.”

“Four weeks. I’m sorry. I’ll pay the fine.” She hoped her voice sounded like a normal voice. “I was just about to put it in the bin.”

“Of course.”

His eyes had gone to the black notebook in her hand. They stayed there. Something moved across his long, tired face, so quick and so complete that she could not have named it. It looked like a man glimpsing, at the far end of a train platform, someone he had spent decades hoping not to see.

“That isn’t ours,” said Mr. Finch.

“It was in the returns.”

“Then I suppose it has been returned.” He took a long breath. “I would leave it where it is, Miss Whitaker. If I were you.”

“Why?”

“Because I’ve watched people pick it up before.” He turned the stamp over in his fingers. “They always begin with something small.”

A bell rang above the door, thin and bright. A woman came in shaking out an umbrella, and Mr. Finch looked toward her, and the moment broke. When he glanced back at Rhea, he was only a kind old man with a stamp.

“Closing at five,” he said. “Mind the step on your way out.”

She left. She did not leave the notebook. She walked down the library steps with Persuasion in the bin behind her and the black cloth cover pressed against her ribs, and she did not look back, because she knew exactly what she would see. A tall shape at the window, watching her go.

The oncology floor of St. Brigid’s smelled of lemon cleaner and warm plastic and, underneath, something sweet and flat that Rhea had learned never to think about. She took the stairs because the elevator was slow and she was already late. Four flights. By the third landing her legs were shaking.

Her brother was in the family room at the end of the corridor, folded into a vinyl armchair too small for him, with a bag of vending-machine chips unopened on his knee. He was nineteen. He had grease under his fingernails that never entirely washed out and a bike chain tattooed around his right wrist, and he looked up when she came in, and his whole face did the thing it always did, the crooked grin like a door thrown open.

“There she is. The Dictionary.” He held up the chips. “Contraband. Smuggled in under the nose of a very large nurse named Bernadette.”

“You bought those.”

“I liberated them. The machine stole my dollar twice, so it owes me.”

“Is Mom awake?”

“Asleep. Since two.” He shifted his weight and the armchair groaned. “She asked for you. I said you were at school. She said, Of course she is, good girl, and then she told me my haircut looked like a cry for help.”

“It does.”

“Thank you, Rhea.” He tipped his head back against the wall. “Scan’s tomorrow. Nine o’clock.”

“I know.”

“Dr. Okafor says we shouldn’t expect anything.”

“I know what she says.”

He looked at her. Dev had a way of looking at people that she had never found a name for, a steady, tilted look, a mechanic looking at an engine that has started making a new sound. He did not ask her anything. He only reached over and tapped the cuff of her jacket, which was his jacket, the old denim one with the frayed collar, which she had been wearing since March.

“Hey,” he said. “Whatever they say. We’re okay.”

“You don’t know that.”

“No.” The grin flickered. “But I’m saying it anyway. That’s what older brothers are for. You do the words, I do the lifting.”

She could not answer. She held up her hands in a gesture that meant I can’t, and he nodded as if she had.

At ten past eight she went to the bathroom at the end of the hall and locked the door.

The room was a narrow white tiled box with a flickering strip light and a cracked mirror. She sat on the closed lid of the toilet with the black notebook on her knees. She had been afraid to open it again. She had been afraid all through the dull orange sunset on the bus, and the walk from the stop, and the four flights of stairs.

She opened it to the first blank page.

It was ruled in pale blue, with a red margin, like a school exercise book. There was a pen clipped inside the spine, a plain black fountain pen with a chipped cap. She had not noticed it earlier. She uncapped it, and the nib was already wet.

Test it, she thought. Something small.

Something that could not possibly matter.

The strip light above her was buzzing. She looked up at it and, feeling like a fool, wrote:

The lights in the family room flicker twice at 8:15.

She capped the pen. She sat in the quiet, with her pulse in her throat, and watched the clock on her phone count down from 8:13.

8:14.

8:15.

Through the thin wall of the bathroom, from the direction of the family room, she heard Dev’s voice say, “Whoa.” And then, a beat later, “Did you see that? The lights just went.” And then a nurse’s low murmur, and Dev again, delighted: “No, I mean twice. Twice! Like a signal.”

Rhea sat very still.

The ink on the page was drying. She could see it happen, the glossy blue going matte, sinking into the paper as though the page were drinking it. And when she touched the line with one fingertip, it was warm.

She wrote a second sentence before she could stop herself.

The vending machine gives Dev both bags of chips and does not keep his dollar.

She waited.

A thump, from the corridor. A rattle and a long crash. And Dev’s whoop, so loud it carried through the wall: “Oh, you beautiful, evil box! Rhea! Rhea, get out here, the machine paid me back! It paid me back double!”

She put her hand over her mouth.

She read the first page again, in her own writing. It does what you write. Every word. She turned to the very back of the notebook, where the paper was thicker, and found a column of small neat entries running down the final leaf, in several different hands. Some were rounded and childish. Some were tall and spiky. Some were in pencil, and had been rubbed out so hard the paper had torn. Each had a name, and a date, and a short phrase. She read the first she could make out.

Bethany Marsh. Sister. 1987.

Then the next. And the next. They ran back and back, decades of them, a long sad ledger. There was a column to the right of each one, and she understood only slowly, with a cold rising from her stomach, what the heading said, in her own hand, in blue ink at the very top of the page.

ERASED.

She shut the book.

Dev drove her home in Gerald, his rusted green hatchback, with the heater on high and the radio turned down to a murmur. It was nearly ten. Neither of them had said much. He had made her eat half a bag of liberated chips, and checked on their mother one last time, and kissed the top of her head through the scarf. Dana Whitaker had opened her eyes for exactly four seconds, said, “You smell like a vending machine,” and gone back under.

“You’re quiet,” said Dev, at a red light.

“I’m always quiet.”

“You’re quiet like a person is quiet. This is the other kind.” He glanced over. “Spill.”

“Nothing.”

“Dictionary.”

“I’m just tired.” She watched the streetlamps swim past. “What if it’s bad, Dev?”

He did not say it’ll be fine. She loved him for that.

“Then we’ll be sad,” he said. “And then we’ll do the next thing. That’s all there is. You think of a next thing and you do it.” The light turned green. “Dad left. That was a bad thing. We did the next thing.”

“We did a lot of next things.”

“Yeah. We’re good at it.” He grinned at the windshield. “Not great. But good.”

The house on Linden Street was dark except for the porch lamp. He walked her up to the door and stood on the step with his hands in his pockets. There was a bike-chain sticker on the back of his jacket, and a smear of oil on his jaw. He looked, she thought, like someone drawn in a hurry by a person who loved him.

“Go to sleep,” he said. “I’ll be in my room, on the other side of the wall. If you need me, you can knock three times, like when you were six.”

“I’m sixteen.”

“Knock three times anyway.”

He went in. She heard his boots on the stairs, and the creak of his bedroom door, and then a thin, tuneless hum drifting through the plaster, off-key as always. It was the song their mother sang when she cooked. Dev had learned it by osmosis and never once got it right.

Rhea stood in the dark hall, listening, until it stopped.

Her room was at the back of the house, small and low-ceilinged, crammed with books and the paper carcasses of eleven years of diaries. She sat at her desk. She switched on the lamp. She took the black notebook out of her jacket and set it down in the pool of yellow light, and for a long time she did not touch it.

She thought about her father. She never meant to. It happened whenever she was afraid.

She was eleven years old. It was the end of a Sunday argument that had gone on for three days. She had stood in the kitchen doorway in her pajamas, with her hand on the frame, and watched a tall man in a gray coat pick up his car keys. He looked at her. He said her name, only her name, as if there were another sentence behind it and he could not find the first word. Then he went out. The door closed with a quiet, ordinary click.

She had written the ending she wanted that night, in her diary, in the careful block capitals she used for things that mattered. He turned around. He came back. He said I’m sorry. The next night she had written it again. She wrote it for three hundred and sixty-one nights, and not one of them came true.

She had learned something from that. She had learned that she could not stop an ending by writing it. But a part of her had never believed it.

She opened the notebook to the first page.

Don’t write Mom’s name.

Please. I am begging you.

She looked at the sevens in the date. She looked at the loop of the g. It was her handwriting, her pleading, in a voice she knew so well it hurt. And she thought, with a flat clear cruelty that frightened her: you don’t know what it’s like. Whoever you are. You haven’t sat in that waiting room. You haven’t watched her hands go thin.

She turned to a blank page.

She uncapped the pen.

Nine o’clock tomorrow. A room with a long gray machine and a technician who would say, in a voice trained to give nothing away, that the doctor would be in touch. Her mother’s scarf. The pill organizer, which had a color for every day of the week. Dev’s cheerful, terrible, hopeful jokes. And all of it moving toward a sentence that someone else would write.

I’ll write it for her, she thought. I’ll write it better.

Her hand shook. She steadied it with the other. The nib touched the paper, and the ink flowed so smoothly that the words seemed to form themselves.

Dana Whitaker’s scan comes back clean. The cancer is gone, completely, as if it had never been.

The last full stop trembled on the page.

Then the ink sank. All of it, at once, as though a mouth had drawn it in. The page went warm under her palm, warm as a living thing, and the lamp on her desk flickered. Once. Twice. Every light in the house dimmed together, and a long low hum ran through the walls, up from the foundations, through the floorboards and the plaster and the bones of the house itself.

It stopped.

Rhea sat in the silence with her hand over her mouth.

She had not meant to cry. She did so anyway, silently, for a long while, bent over the desk with her forehead against the cover of the notebook. The ink on the page was dry. The lamp burned steadily. Nothing had changed that she could see.

At some point she fell asleep.

She woke to the sound of someone humming in the kitchen.

It was not the quiet, thready hum of the last six months. This was full and warm and slightly flat, with the clatter of a pan under it. The smell of butter and cinnamon came up the stairs like a hand. She lay with her cheek stuck to the cover of the notebook, and the morning sun slanted across the floor, and she thought: no.

She thought: it can’t have.

She was on the stairs before she knew she had stood up. Her bare feet found every creak. She hung onto the banister with both hands, and at the bottom, in the doorway of the kitchen, she stopped.

Her mother stood at the stove in her old green dressing gown.

She had no scarf. She had hair. A thick, dark, silver-streaked braid hung down her back, the braid she had lost in February, handful by handful, in the shower. Her cheeks were pink. Her hands were steady. She was flipping pancakes with the easy flick of someone who had done it ten thousand times, and humming, and when she turned and saw her daughter standing in the doorway, she laughed.

“Look who’s up. I was about to send out a search party.” She slid a pancake onto a plate. “Don’t just stand there, my love. You’ll catch a cold. Sit.”

Rhea could not move.

“Mom,” she said. Her voice came out in a crack. “Mom, are you...”

“Hungry? Starving.” Dana Whitaker set the plate down on the table and pressed the back of her wrist to Rhea’s forehead, a gesture of such exact, ordinary tenderness that something inside Rhea broke clean in half. “You’re warm. Did you sleep badly? You look like you’ve been crying.”

“I’m fine.”

“Mm. Of course you are.” Her mother smiled. “Sit down. I made the good syrup.”

Rhea sat.

She looked at the table, because she did not trust herself to look at her mother’s face. It was the old oak table, the one with the burn mark from the summer Dev tried to forge a candle. Two plates. Two forks. Two glasses of orange juice, bright in the morning sun, and two folded paper napkins.

Two.

She sat very still with her hands on her knees.

“Mom?” she said.

“Mm?”

“Where’s Dev?”

Her mother turned from the stove with the spatula in her hand and a pleasant, puzzled frown, the frown she gave to a word she half knew and could not place.

“Who, sweetheart?”