Chapter 3: RULE THREE0% read • ~13 min

Chapter 3

RULE THREE

13 min read•2,864 words

"Dev?"

"Hey, Dictionary."

It came through the plaster like a voice through a closed door, muffled and warm, with a small crackle in it like an old radio. Rhea pressed her cheek against the wall. The paint was cold. Her whole body had gone to wire.

"Where are you?"

"Honestly? Great question." A rasp of breath that might have been a laugh. "It's a hallway. A long one. Kind of like the school corridor in summer, when everyone's gone and the floors are freshly waxed. It smells like ink. There are doors."

"Doors."

"Paper ones. Thin as a page. Each one has a name on it in handwriting, and when you get close you can hear them breathing." His voice slid sideways, and caught. "I'm trying not to open any."

"Are you hurt?"

"I don't think so. I can't find a mirror." A pause. "I'm not scared, if that's what you're asking. I'm a little scared. I've been here, what, a day? I've met nine people. One of them tried to sell me a cookie."

She laughed. It came out as a sob, and she pressed her fist against her mouth.

"Hey. Hey, no. None of that." The voice gentled. "I'm okay, Rhea. Honest. There's a woman here who's been very kind. She wears a yellow scarf, she hums. She taught me a dance step. I'm terrible at it."

"A woman."

"Silver hair. Lovely laugh. She keeps asking me to tell somebody that she's still dancing badly." He faltered. "She can't say who. It's like her name's fallen off the end of her tongue."

Rhea's skin went cold. A photograph on a blotter, turned a little away from the man who owned it, a little toward the door.

"June," she whispered.

"Does that mean something?"

"Dev, listen to me. I'm going to get you out."

"Rhea."

"I know how it works. I'll write you back. I'll write it carefully, I'll do it right this time."

"No." It came sharp, so sharp that she jerked away from the wall. "No. Dictionary. Listen. Every sentence you write, I lose a door. I can hear the pen. Every time you put a word down it gets a little darker in here, and the walls get a little closer, and I'm not being dramatic, I'm telling you what I see." His voice shook, and steadied. "Please. Don't write anything else. Not tonight. Not until you know the rules."

"There's a third rule. It's blank."

"I know. It's on my side." The crackle thickened. "It's printed on the wall at the end of the corridor, in letters about six feet tall. I can't read it. Every time I get close, the words slide out from under me. It's in your handwriting, and I keep losing it." A beat. "I think it only lets itself be read by someone who's ready."

"Ready for what?"

"I'm... I don't know. Rhea. I can barely hear you."

"Dev!"

"Ask Noor," said the faint voice. "She was there at the cemetery. She'll remember something. It doesn't take everything. It leaves... it leaves crumbs." The words were thinning like breath on glass. "Seven nights, okay? Don't panic. Panic's for amateurs."

"Dev, wait..."

Knock, said the wall. Soft now, hardly a sound. Knock. Knock.

Then nothing.

She stayed there until the window went gray. She did not sleep again.

Her mother was dancing in the kitchen.

Not with anyone. She had put the radio on, an old song with a saxophone in it, and she moved across the linoleum in her green dressing gown, spatula held like a microphone, singing every word slightly wrong. Her braid swung. Her cheeks glowed. When she saw Rhea in the doorway, she held out both hands.

"Come on. Come on! You're not too old."

"Mom."

"I have been sick for fourteen months. I get one dance." She caught Rhea by the wrists and spun her once, laughing, and let go. "Oh, I'm so happy I could be sick. The ward threw me a party. Bernadette made a cake in the shape of a stethoscope. They want me back Monday, if you can believe it. Dr. Okafor says I'm to take it slowly."

"That's great."

"It's wonderful." She stopped, a little breathless, and studied her daughter's face. Her smile softened. "And you've been up all night."

"Bad dream."

"About your brother again?"

Rhea went still.

"The one you made up, I mean." Her mother's voice was gentle, careful, the voice of a woman who had loved a child through eleven years of invented friends. "You used to talk about him when you were little. When your father left. You'd say, Dev's going to fix it. Dev knows. I thought you'd grown out of it."

"I did," said Rhea. "I'm sorry."

"No, no." She pulled her into her arms. "Don't be sorry. You've had so much to carry. You can invent a whole family if you want, my love. I'll set a place for any of them."

Rhea closed her eyes.

Over her mother's shoulder, on the kitchen windowsill, sat a plastic pill organizer, seven compartments, one for each day of the week. It was empty. It had been scrubbed clean. Someone had put a single sprig of dried lavender in the Sunday slot.

Noor came at four, with chocolate.

She had four bars of it, and a bag of salted pretzels, and a paper cone of hot chips from the stand outside school, and she stood on the doorstep with her plum-colored hijab slightly askew and her silver rings catching the light, and held it all out in front of her like an offering. "Medical emergency," she said. "I brought the entire first-aid kit."

Rhea took her upstairs. She shut the door. She sat her friend down on the bed, and put the black notebook on the quilt between them, and told her everything.

It took twenty minutes. She did not leave out the part about the ledger, or the knocking, or the hallway of paper doors. She told it flat, in order, as if she were reading a report. Noor did not say a word. She sat cross-legged with a pretzel halfway to her mouth, and by the end the pretzel had gone soft in her fingers.

"Okay," said Noor.

"I know how it sounds."

"No, I mean, okay. I believe you." She put the pretzel down. "Not because it makes sense. Because you've never once lied to me in nine years, you're a terrible liar, you go red from the collar up. You're doing it now."

"I'm not lying."

"I know. That's what I'm saying." She picked at her rings. "Show me."

"I'm not supposed to write anything."

"Something small. Something so small it can't hurt." Noor held out her hands. "Rhea. If I'm going to help you I need to see it."

She should not have. She knew that. But Noor's face was so open, and the room so quiet, and the old human hunger to prove a thing true was stronger than the warning of a boy behind a wall. She uncapped the pen.

Noor's left shoe comes untied.

The ink sank into the page like water into sand.

Noor looked down. Her left sneaker lay on the quilt, and the lace slid, quite slowly, out of its bow, loop by loop, as if drawn by an invisible hand, and went limp.

"Okay," said Noor, in a very small voice.

"Yeah."

"That's... that's really..." She swallowed. She reached for a chocolate bar and tore the wrapper.

Gray dust poured out.

It fell on the quilt in a soft dry stream, with a faint, sweet smell like burned sugar. Noor turned the wrapper upside down and shook it. It was empty, and under the dust lay nothing but a little crumpled foil.

"Rule Two," Rhea said. "Everything true is paid for."

"I paid for a shoelace with a chocolate bar."

"I think the price is always about the size of the thing." Rhea's mouth had gone dry. "That's why it was so..."

She did not finish. She did not need to. Her mother's scan was the size of a life. Her brother was the price.

Noor was quiet for a long minute, with the dust in her lap. Then, quite slowly, she said, "There was a boy."

"What?"

"At the cemetery." Her brows came together. "I told you this morning it was your mom holding the seat. And it was. I know it was. But when you said Dev, I... there's something else." She pressed her hands against her eyes. "He sat down on a gravestone. He was laughing so hard he couldn't stand. Horace Pym. That was the name on it, Horace Pym, 1894, and he said, I'm sorry, sir, and he couldn't stop. I've never forgotten that. I always thought it was my cousin."

"You don't have a cousin in Alder Falls."

"No." Noor's voice cracked. "No, I don't."

Rhea took her hands.

"I remember someone's hand on the back of my seat," Noor whispered. "Warm. Big. Calloused. It wasn't your mom's. I remember thinking, he's going to let go any second, and I wasn't afraid, because I knew he wouldn't." She was crying now, quite openly, with her hijab slipping off one ear. "Rhea, who was that?"

"My brother," said Rhea.

"Oh my God."

"Yes."

"I remember a person who isn't there." She pressed the heels of her hands to her cheeks. "That's the worst feeling I've ever had in my whole life. That's like having a tooth pulled out and still tasting it."

"I know."

"What do we do?"

"We read the margins," said Rhea.

They bent over the book together under the lamp, heads touching, while the light slid red across the carpet.

The margins held nothing but what she had already seen. Rule One. Rule Two. A colon. A blank. Noor ran her finger along the empty line and said, "Maybe it's not ready."

"Dev says it only shows itself to someone who is."

"Ready for what?"

"I don't know."

They turned to the back. The ledger was longer than yesterday. At the bottom, in her own handwriting, a line had changed.

Devlin Whitaker. Brother. 2 of 7.

Noor made a small, strangled sound.

"It's tomorrow night," Rhea whispered. "He's been gone two nights. It moves at midnight." She put her thumb beside the number, where a second tally mark had appeared in the margin, scratched small and neat. "Five nights left. Then it's too late."

"Then we need the third rule."

"I know."

"Rhea." Noor gripped her wrist. "Look."

There was writing on the last page.

It had not been there a moment before. She was sure of that. It was small and slanted, in block capitals, in blue ink gone slightly smeary, as if written in a hurry by someone with greasy fingers. It ran along the very bottom of the leaf, under the ledger, upside down.

Rhea knew the hand. She would have known it anywhere. It was the hand that had labeled every jar in the garage, and signed her permission slips in the third grade, and written Rhea Is A Dork in tiny letters inside the cover of her first diary.

DICTIONARY. FLIP IT. TURN IT UPSIDE DOWN.

"Do you see it?" she breathed.

"See what?" Noor frowned at the page. "It's blank."

She had known it would be.

Rhea turned the notebook around. Her hands were shaking so badly that the pages whispered. She held it upside down under the lamp, with the red spine against her knee, and read the line beneath the ledger the way you read a message on a mirror.

It was ruled in the same pale blue as every other page. It was written in her own hand. The letters were clear and firm and black, sunk into the paper so deeply that they stood in relief, as if pressed in with a seal.

RULE THREE: TO UNWRITE A SENTENCE, THE WRITER MUST WRITE HER OWN ENDING.

She read it again.

Beneath it, in smaller print, a second line was forming, rising out of the page like breath on a cold pane.

THE PEN WILL NOT LET HER TAKE IT BACK.

And below that, in block capitals, smeared and shaking and a little crooked, the other hand, the one that wasn't hers:

I'M SORRY. I READ IT FIRST. DON'T.

"Rhea?" Noor's voice came from a long way off. "What is it? What does it say?"

"It says there's a way."

"That's good, isn't it?"

"It says I have to write my own ending."

"Your own..." Noor stopped.

"Not Dev's. Not my mom's. Mine." Rhea's mouth was numb. "That's the price. That's what Mr. Finch meant. A trade you choose. It's not a purchase. The notebook doesn't want what I have. It wants what I'm going to be."

"Which means what?"

"I don't know." She turned the book right side up. The ledger lay open before her, with its long column of names, Bethany Marsh and a hundred others, and she saw, for the first time, what she should have seen at once. Beside every entry, at the end of the line, a tiny blue mark had been inked in the margin. A small, curling flourish, like a signature.

They were all in different hands. All of them were the same mark.

She had thought the warnings were from her. She had thought, with a kind of horrified tenderness, that she was reading a note from her own future self. But the first page had been signed R, and the ledger had a hundred different hands, and every one of them said Don't.

Someone had written this book out of the world, one name at a time, and each time, the person who paid had left a warning for the next.

"Oh," said Rhea. It was hardly a breath.

"What?"

"The people in the ledger. The ones who wrote themselves out." She turned the page, and the next. "They didn't leave. They're still here. It's their ink. They're the book."

She was cold from her hair to her feet.

Downstairs, in the kitchen, a pan clattered on the stove. Her mother's voice rose in song, warm and slightly flat, a long way off.

Noor had stopped crying. She sat very straight with her hands clasped between her knees and a gray smear of chocolate dust on her cheek.

"If you do it," she said slowly, "if you write your own ending. Does it work? Does he come back?"

"I think so."

"And you?"

"I don't know." Rhea closed the notebook. The gold letters flashed once in the lamplight, R.W., flaking at the edges. "I think that's what the page is for."

"Then we aren't doing it."

"Noor."

"We're not." Her friend's chin came up, small and fierce. "Rhea. I've known you since you were seven. You don't get to trade yourself for anybody. I don't care how much I'd like to meet a person I can't even remember. We'll find another way."

"Mr. Finch said there's always a way."

"Then we'll find the one that isn't this."

It was the kindest, most stubborn thing anyone had ever said to her. She put her face in Noor's shoulder and they held on to each other in the dusk, two girls on a quilt with a book between them, and downstairs the radio played its slow saxophone song, and somewhere beyond the wall a boy's voice had gone quiet.

She woke in the dark with her heart going like a fist.

The clock said 2:07. It always said 2:07. She lay rigid under the quilt in her clothes with the jacket over her shoulders, listening to the house. A stair creaked. A pipe ticked. No knocking from the wall. She waited for it for eleven minutes, and the silence stretched out as thin as wire.

Then, from downstairs, a sound.

It was soft and dry and very small, a sound she had known better than any other for fourteen months. She had learned it the way some people learn a language, without ever wanting to. It rose through the floor and the dark and the sleeping house, a thin, papery cough, and it did not stop.

Rhea sat up.

The cough came again. Longer. A rattle in it, like a pebble in a tin.

Her hand found the ginger candy in the pocket of the denim jacket. She held it so tightly that the wrapper cut her palm. And on the desk, in the little pool of moonlight, the black notebook lay open to the page where the ink had sunk, as it had done on the night she wrote her mother's name.

The line had changed.

It was her own handwriting. It was still faintly wet. The words she had written in that long terrible night were exactly where she had left them, but a second sentence had been added beneath, in a smaller, harder, more exact script, as if the book itself had picked up the pen.

Dana Whitaker's scan comes back clean, until the one who paid is gone.

Down in the dark, her mother coughed again, and did not stop.