Chapter 4: WHAT LUCIA KNEW0% read • ~8 min

Chapter 4

WHAT LUCIA KNEW

8 min read•1,795 words

“Don’t move,” Noah said, “and don’t touch the door.”

He said it to the bathroom, not to me. The water had stopped, and in the silence that followed I could hear a person standing very close to a very thin piece of wood, trying to breathe quietly.

“Lu.”

“I’m brushing my teeth.”

“You’re not.”

A long pause. “I’m brushing them with great attention.”

Noah closed his eyes. It was the first time I’d seen him look his age, and then some. He pressed the heel of his hand into his forehead, and when he lowered it, his face had the scrubbed, weary look of a man who has run out of places to put things.

“Come out,” he said.

The door opened. Lucia stood there with her braid over one shoulder and her chin up, not even pretending anymore. She had heard everything. She wasn’t sorry, and she wasn’t afraid, and she was clearly, fiercely thinking.

“You said they took the building because of a loan,” she said. “You told me Dad got sick and the bank moved fast. You told me it was bad luck.”

“It was bad luck.”

“It was a paid receipt.” She pointed at the brown folder. “You kept a paid receipt in a drawer for three years and let me think we were just unlucky.”

“I didn’t know what it meant.”

“You didn’t ask.”

“Who would I ask, Lu? The people who sent the notices?”

They stared at each other, brother and sister, with the same dark eyes and the same stubborn mouth. I felt like a person who had wandered into a church during a private argument. I looked at the framed menu on the wall instead. Under the red border, in handwriting that bent a little to the right, somebody had written in the corner: Always feed them first, ask questions after.

“I should go,” I said.

“Sit down,” Noah said, not unkindly.

“I don’t think I’m welcome.”

“You’re not,” said Lucia. “But you’re here, and you’ve got the paper, and he isn’t going to sleep tonight no matter what you do. So sit.”

I sat. The chair was wooden and wobbled on one leg. A tin of buttons rattled beside my elbow, and I saw now that they had been sorted by color, a careful rainbow of tiny plastic circles, and I thought, absurdly, that a person who sorts buttons at midnight is a person who is trying very hard to keep something from falling apart.

Noah laid the ledger page flat on the table between us. He read the back again. If anything happens to me, ask Julian’s mother what she signed.

“Who is Julian’s mother?” he asked.

“Margaret Ashford.” I was surprised by how steady it sounded. “She’s on the board of the Hartwell Foundation. She and my mother were friends once. Close. She came to the lake house every summer when I was small.” I hesitated. “I haven’t thought about that in years.”

“Why not?”

“Because after the funeral she stopped coming. And nobody said why.”

“That’s a lot of people who stopped coming,” said Noah.

“Yes.”

“And a lot of people who didn’t say why.”

“Yes.” I looked up. “I know how it looks.”

“I haven’t said how it looks.”

“You’re thinking it.”

“I’m thinking your family is very good at silence.” He said it without heat. A fact on a table. “I’m trying to work out if you’re good at it too.”

It stung, because it was fair.

“I only learned she was an immigrant’s daughter from a woman at her funeral,” I said. “I was twelve. My father took down every photo of her from the house the week she died and told the staff to stop saying her name in front of me. It was easier, he said. Kinder.” I turned my ring around and around until the pale dent in my skin began to ache. “I was very good at silence. I was the best in the house. I’d like to stop.”

Nobody said anything. In the stairwell, I heard Priya shift her weight on the step, and the soft chime of a spoon against a cup. She had evidently found somewhere to get tea.

Noah rubbed his jaw. “Okay,” he said at last. “So we ask her.”

“We can’t just knock on Margaret Ashford’s door.”

“Why not? You’re engaged to her son.”

“Because if she signed something that matters, she’s had fifteen years to prepare an answer. And because Julian’s in that house too.” I swallowed. “And because there was a man in a black car tonight, and I think he was wearing Julian’s cufflinks.”

Noah’s head came up sharply. “You saw him?”

“I saw a cufflink.”

“That’s not seeing a man.”

“It’s the cufflink he adjusts when he’s thinking. I’d know it anywhere. Silver, little square, with a blue stone.” I flexed my fingers. “I’ve watched him do it ten thousand times.”

“So he knows,” Noah said slowly. “He knows you came here, or he will in an hour.”

“I think someone has wanted all of us in the same room since the party. The texts went to me, to Walter, to you. Whoever it is, they’re not trying to scare us. They’re herding us.”

“Toward what?”

“I don’t know.”

“I do.”

All of us turned. Lucia had not sat. She stood at the end of the table with her arms folded tight across her chest and her textbook pressed against her ribs like a shield, and her face had gone the color of old paper.

“Lu?” Noah said.

“I need to tell you something and you can’t be mad.”

“I’m not going to be mad.”

“You are, though. You’re going to be so mad you’ll go quiet, and I hate it when you go quiet.” She took a breath that shook. “Three weeks ago, I got a letter.”

“What letter?”

“From the Hartwell Foundation.” She said the name like something that might leave a stain. “A full scholarship. Tuition, books, housing, a stipend. Four years, anywhere I get in. They said I’d been nominated. I didn’t apply, Noah. I didn’t even know it existed. A woman in the guidance office handed it to me in a sealed envelope and said it had come with a personal reference.”

“From who?”

Lucia’s eyes went to me, then away, and I felt it in my sternum before she spoke.

“The Ashford Family Trust. Signed by Margaret Ashford.”

The room did not move, but everything in it stopped. Noah rose to his feet so slowly the chair didn’t make a sound.

“You took money,” he said. “From them.”

“I haven’t spent a dollar. I haven’t told anyone. I wanted to tell you after the acceptance came, after I knew it was real, so you wouldn’t say no before you saw it.” The words were pouring out of her now, fast and ragged. “You work three jobs, Noah. You sleep in pieces. I do math at night and I can hear you in the bathroom, running the tap so I won’t hear you cry. I’m so tired of being the reason.”

“Lucia.”

“I got the best grades in my class. I earned it, so don’t act like it’s a bribe.”

“It might be a bribe.”

“It might be a miracle!”

“It’s a Hartwell miracle. Do you hear how that sounds?”

“It sounds like somebody finally gave us something instead of taking it!”

Her voice cracked on the last word. She wiped her face with the back of her wrist, angry at it, and the sight of her, small and furious and seventeen with a geometry book, made my own eyes burn. I thought of every plate of food my father had ever put in front of me and what it would have cost me to refuse it. I thought of what it must cost her to say yes.

“Can I see the letter?” I asked.

She looked at me as though I’d asked for a kidney.

“Please,” I said. “I won’t take it. I only want to see the signature.”

A long moment. Then Lucia went to her bag, pulled out an envelope with a crisp ivory edge, and set it in front of me with exactly the care of a person defusing something.

I didn’t need to open it. The paper was ribbed along the border. It smelled faintly of lavender.

The same stationery as my mother’s ledger page.

I laid the two side by side under the lamp. The weight, the tone, the watermark of a tiny crescent moon in the corner. They matched.

“Elena,” Noah said quietly. “What is it?”

“My mother ordered this paper from a shop in Paris. It’s discontinued. She used to say she bought the last four reams in the city.” I heard my own voice go thin. “Margaret Ashford was the only other person she ever gave any to.”

“So Margaret wrote Lucia’s letter.”

“Or someone wants us to think she did.” I pushed the pages away from each other as though they might touch and spark. “Either way, somebody had access to my mother’s stationery. Fifteen years later.”

“That’s not a coincidence,” Lucia whispered.

“No,” I said. “It’s a message.”

Noah was looking at his sister as if seeing her for the first time. Not the child who needed shoes. Someone who had stood in a hallway in the dark, running numbers and refusing to tell him.

“I’m not mad,” he said.

“You’re being quiet.”

“I’m thinking.” His voice caught. “You should have told me. But you shouldn’t have had to be the one carrying it.”

Lucia made a small noise and then she was across the room, her forehead pressed to his chest, the textbook crushed between them. He folded his arms around her without a word, one hand on the back of her head, and over her shoulder his eyes met mine. There was no accusation in them now. Just exhaustion, and something lower and warmer that I wasn’t ready to name.

I looked away first.

That was when the knock came.

Not a loud one. Three soft, measured taps, evenly spaced, the knock of a man who has never in his life had to knock twice.

Nobody breathed. Lucia lifted her head. Noah’s arm tightened.

From the stairwell, I heard Priya’s voice, bright and brittle. “Oh. Hello. Can I help you?”

And a second voice answered her, warm and easy and perfectly kind. A voice I’d heard say darling more times than I could count.

“I’m sorry to intrude. I’m looking for my fiancée. Her father said she wasn’t home, and I thought, well, I know a girl who runs away when she’s frightened.”

A pause.

“Elena,” said Julian Ashford, through the green door. “Darling. Won’t you come out?”