Chapter 13: THE GOAT ON THE ROOF0% read • ~8 min

Chapter 13

THE GOAT ON THE ROOF

8 min read•1,826 words

I called her back before Noah finished reading the note a second time.

The prepaid phone was at twenty-one percent, and my thumb slipped on the cracked glass. Behind me, Noah knelt on the checkerboard floor with the stapler in one hand and Thomas’s handwriting in the other. He had gone very still. It was the stillness of a man who has run toward a door and found a wall painted to look like one.

Priya answered on the first ring.

“Do not say anything clever,” she said. “I am in a stairwell and I have had a very long night.”

“Priya, where are you?”

“Where are you?”

“The restaurant. Noah’s family’s restaurant. Thomas left a note saying Lucia was never here, and then you sent me one word, and I need you to tell me that word means what I think it means.”

“It means goat.” Her breath came fast and bright, and under it I heard something else. A scrape of chair legs. A clatter of dishes. And a voice, high and breathless and unmistakably seventeen, saying, “Wait, no, you’re doing the dough wrong, you have to fold it, you don’t just punch it.”

I put my free hand over my mouth.

“Is that...”

“Say hi, Lucia!”

“Hi, Lucia!” A pause, and then a startled, helpless peal of laughter, the kind that gets away from you at funerals. “Priya, your grandmother has flour in her hair.”

“Grandmother has flour in everything,” said Priya. “It’s her whole personality.”

Noah had risen. I don’t remember seeing him do it. He stood at my shoulder with the note crushed in his fist and his eyes fixed on the phone as though it were a window onto the sun.

“Give it to me,” he said, hoarse.

I held it out. His hand shook so badly he had to use both. He pressed it to his ear, and I watched the sound of her voice go through him like a tide.

“Lu?”

I could not hear her answer. I only saw his face. His mouth opened and no sound came, and he turned his back on me and put his forehead against the old kitchen door, one hand flat on the wood, shoulders working, while his sister talked and talked into his ear about dough.

I gave him his minute. I took my own, too, standing in the cold dark of a restaurant where somebody had once cried over a health inspection. I let the tears come the way you let rain come, without a plan for them.

When Noah handed the phone back, his face was wet and he did not hide it.

“She’s fine,” he said. “Split lip. Mad about the textbook.”

“Priya,” I said. “How?”

“Long story, short bus ride.” Priya’s voice had steadied into the dry tone she used for emergencies and hair. “After Garrick put me in a taxi, I told the driver to circle the block twice. Then I got out and walked back to Cardiff Street, because I am my grandmother’s granddaughter and I do not take orders from men with necks. I was on the stairs when Lucia came out of Dominic’s car. Dominic was driving her home. They’d closed early.”

“They said she was taken at ten forty.”

“She was. And by ten forty-three she was back.” A beat. “Because Dominic really does throw knives.”

I blinked. “What?”

“He doesn’t throw them at people. He throws them at things. Tires, mostly. Two men grabbed her on the sidewalk outside the restaurant, shoved her in a van, and Dominic put a boning knife through the front left tire from forty feet. The van slewed into a fire hydrant. Water everywhere, very cinematic. He got hit on the head with a pipe, which is why that part was true. Lucia bit a man on the thumb and ran. I would like it noted she did this with a geometry textbook under her arm.”

“She left it.”

“She dropped it in the street. Somebody picked it up.” Priya paused. “That’s what I figured. The video of her, in the yellow room. Thomas must have staged it from earlier footage, or made her sit for it while they had her those three minutes. He needed you to believe it was current.”

“Priya, you are a genius.”

“I am a woman who owns a very small car and a very large grudge.” Her voice cracked on the last word, and she cleared her throat. “Anyway, I texted you the second I had her in the stairwell. Then Dominic’s sister, who lives in my building, said we couldn’t stay on Cardiff Street, because men with necks go where they know. So I took them to my grandmother’s.”

“Your grandmother’s shop.”

“Nobody has ever once thought to look for me in a sweet shop. Even I forget I have one.” A shaky laugh. “She put Dominic on a stool with an ice pack and gave Lucia an apron. They’re making gulab jamun. Your friend Lucia is, and I say this with love, a menace. She has already corrected my grandmother’s fractions.”

Noah had sunk down against the wall, knees up, head back, eyes closed. His hand was loose at his side. The stapler had rolled from his fingers and lay on the tile like a small, ridiculous witness.

“Where did the cooking come from?” I said. “In the kitchen. Somebody was cooking in here tonight. It smells like his family’s staff meal.”

“I don’t know.” Priya’s voice dropped. “Elena, that’s the part I wanted to talk about. When you texted me from the lake house, I called Dominic. I thought he’d know someone who’d seen anything. And he said something strange. He said he’d had a call yesterday morning from a woman who wanted to know whether the Reyes kitchen still had its original back key. She said she was an old friend of the family.”

“What woman?”

“She wouldn’t give a name. But she asked if he still kept the staff meal recipe, the one with the lime. And she asked it the way you ask about someone you used to know.”

The cold in the room deepened. I looked down the long dark of the front room, past the empty bar, toward the line of gold under the kitchen door. The smell hung there, patient, warm, impossible. Cumin and lime and slow-cooked onion.

Noah’s father had made it every night for twenty years, and had never once written it down.

“Priya,” I said slowly. “I have to go.”

“Wait. There’s more. Your mother’s number rang through to my phone.”

“What?”

“It showed up as a call from a blocked line, and I picked up. It was Margaret Ashford, in a panic. She said Thomas had gone quiet. She said he put his phone in his pocket, said it was time for his check-in, walked out onto the porch, and didn’t come back. Your father followed him. Your mother went after them. And Margaret has a very large kitchen knife and absolutely no idea what to do with it.”

“When?”

“Four minutes ago.”

The line crackled. Somewhere behind her a voice shouted, “Priya, the syrup!” and something clanged. A normal life, loud and sweet and burning on a stove, and I held on to the sound of it as though it could be carried.

“Keep Lucia safe,” I said.

“I will bite anyone who comes near her. I’ve picked up the habit.”

“I love you.”

“I know. Go. Bring me a goat or don’t come back.”

She hung up. The screen dimmed to twenty percent.

I turned. Noah was on his feet again, wiping his face with the back of his wrist, eyes red and clear and terribly awake.

“He lied about her,” Noah said. “He lied about the building. He lied about the place.”

“He wanted us in the wrong city while he did something at the lake.”

“What?”

“I don’t know. But he took my father out onto a porch in the rain, and I think my father let him.” I heard my own voice go thin. “I think my father went because he decided he deserved whatever came.”

“Elena.”

“He said he wouldn’t have another chance to speak. He said it twice. And I thought it was guilt.” I swallowed. “I think it was a plan.”

Noah didn’t answer. He crossed the floor and took the stapler off the tile and, very carefully, set it on the old bar, where it stood small and black against the cracked wood. Then he walked to the kitchen door and put his palm against it.

“Stay here a second,” he said.

“No.”

“One second.”

“I’m not letting you open that door alone.”

“I’m not asking to be alone.” His voice shook, just slightly. “I’m asking to see it first, the way he left it. If it’s what I think it is, I don’t want anyone watching me be a kid.”

I let him. I stood where I was with the phone against my chest, and counted to ten, and counted again. Then I heard the door swing, and a sound came out of him that I will not describe, because it belonged to him.

I went in.

The kitchen was small and bright and spotless. A copper pot simmered on the back burner, giving off its slow steam. Three bowls sat on the steel prep table, each with a tortilla folded on its rim, and beside them lay a spoon, a napkin, and a folded square of paper held down by a salt shaker. The framed menu from Cardiff Street hung above the stove. It had been taken down from Noah’s apartment wall that evening and rehung here, with the red border and the faded handwriting. Always feed them first, ask questions after.

Noah stood in front of it with his hands at his sides.

“Who,” he said. “Who does that.”

I picked up the folded paper. It was plain white, no lavender, no ribbed edge. In ballpoint, in handwriting that bent a little to the right, someone had written four lines.

Mijo. I am sorry it took me so long to come home.

Eat. Then run. They are not at the lake. They are coming here.

The back door slammed open.

Headlights swept across the front window in a long white arc, and then a second pair, and a third, and the street outside filled with the low rumble of engines idling in the rain. A man’s voice called from the front room, calm and courteous, and not at all unfamiliar.

“Elena. Mr. Reyes. I did say eight minutes.”

Noah’s hand found mine and gripped it so hard the bones ground together. Above the stove, the pot lid rattled once and went still.

“Julian,” I said.

But when I turned toward the front window, the sedan we had come in was empty at the curb, its engine running, its door standing open on the dark.

Love With Poor Guy — Chapter 13: THE GOAT ON THE ROOF | BlueNov